The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Cloudane »

Well, that was exciting! Regarding that last bit (including rumours)
Spoiler: show
I hope David Tennant doesn't leave yet. He's quite possibly the best Doctor ever, and deserves at least as long as Tom Baker :) He'd be a tough one to beat, and I'd rather see him stick around. He may be contracted for the xmas special etc but what's to say it's not one of these "2 doctors" scenarios.

But then "All is not what it seems" (they completely copied that hype generator from JK Rowling!) - but even that could refer to Donna's impending 'death' rather than the Doctor. I do think it likely that he'll stay the same though - the hand theory is good, I can't think of any other reason for it to still be hanging around.

If he does change, I've heard (weak) rumours of James Nesbitt as the next one. Just don't know... I can't see him charging around with a grin on his face, unless the Doctor's personality is going to regenerate again...
Oh yeah, and that slow motion bit..
Spoiler: show
I was fairly convinced that it was going to zap Rose. After all that... that would've been sooooo cruel!
Last edited by Cloudane on Mon Jun 30, 2008 1:17 am 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

Hajile wrote:
arron wrote: Just because shows happen to be on at the same time doesn't mean they're similar, or even aimed at the same target audience. If it did, Star Trek Enterprise would be comparable to Malcolm in The Middle.

The Doctor always gets out of every situation every time because he's magic. If you don't like that, then you're got no magic in you.
Malcolm in the Middle is not even closely comparable to Enterprise. One's a sitcom, and the other is a sci-fi series. Sounds like a strawman argument to me given that the Doctor "gets out of every situation" doesn't mean "magic". More like "fix what you can, then draw a line under it for now". It's only relatively recently that the deus ex machina has been the "magic" plot fix for what should be a plot arc.

Given that Terry Nation had a hand in both series they are pretty similar in their initial ideas. They both had remarkably similar premises about the fight of good against evil with the heroes in command of superior technology, despite overwhelming odds and a massive universe to explore.

Look at Genesis of the Daleks as an example of a "light knockabout romp" - the Doctor was pushed from defeat to defeat given the options he had to choose from..and in the end as it was all falling apart, the only way left was to delay the inevitable by blowing up the bunker and leave it at that. Compare and contrast with "Killer" the season two episode from B7 written by Robert Holmes (a vintage Dr Who writer) where a robbery and blackmail mission goes pearshaped with the addition of a spaceship that turns up out of the past, which has been sabotaged to destroy human civilisation..and the crew are left with a choice to destroy the federation with a virulent space virus or warn them, but then put them back onto their backs again. It seems to me that both episodes have many common elements, with at least two different sub-stories running at any one time, and no, I don't believe that B7 and Who are that different from having a pretty encyclopediac knowledge of both[1].

[1] HGFB is more of fan than me. I own no dollies or other merchandising.. :)
Last edited by arron on Mon Jun 30, 2008 1:37 am 0, edited 2 times in total.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
betamax
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10520
Joined: Thu May 01, 2003 11:36 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Betamax_W
Location: Coalition Anxiety
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by betamax »

Cloudane wrote:Well, that was exciting! Regarding that last bit (including rumours)
Spoiler: show
I hope David Tennant doesn't leave yet. He's quite possibly the best Doctor ever, and deserves at least as long as Tom Baker :) He'd be a tough one to beat, and I'd rather see him stick around. He may be contracted for the xmas special etc but what's to say it's not one of these "2 doctors" scenarios.

But then "All is not what it seems" (they completely copied that hype generator from JK Rowling!) - but even that could refer to Donna's impending 'death' rather than the Doctor. I do think it likely that he'll stay the same though - the hand theory is good, I can't think of any other reason for it to still be hanging around.

If he does change, I've heard (weak) rumours of James Nesbitt as the next one. Just don't know... I can't see him charging around with a grin on his face, unless the Doctor's personality is going to regenerate again...
I think they'll pull the tablecloth off while we are still eating and
Spoiler: show
stick John Simm back in as the Dr. The emotional fallout could last the entire next series. :) In any case I never really liked Tennant as the doctor, for reasons I've given in this very thread. Ecclestone was much more my cup of tea.
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

betamax wrote:I think they'll pull the tablecloth off while we are still eating and
Spoiler: show
stick John Simm back in as the Dr. The emotional fallout could last the entire next series. :) In any case I never really liked Tennant as the doctor, for reasons I've given in this very thread. Ecclestone was much more my cup of tea.
Yes, that could be a clever trick. Plus everyone would want his autograph once he gets back to Earth because everyone likes him! :D
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

arron wrote:I think that it's completely unrealistic [...]
Realism? In Doctor Who? When did that ever happen? An episode of an eight-parter in the Pertwee days or something? Are you confusing DW with, say, Captain Scarlet?
Sid James wrote:
arron wrote: I would dearly like it to be better.
So come on then, put your money where your mouth is. What would make it better in your eyes?
Moreover, why is arron, with his seemingly extensive experience of producing mass audience television series, not applying to succeed Mr Moffat?

(As an aside, I find it difficult to accept that responses such as, "That's not true, but I can see that it makes your life a bit easier if you believe that," are products of balanced and non-egoistic minds. They instead read to me as sickeningly condescending).
arron wrote:Given that Terry Nation had a hand in both series they are pretty similar in their initial ideas [...]
Mr Nation had barely a fingernail in Doctor Who aside from creating its most iconic villains. The series was created by Sydney Newman of The Avengers (for which Nation also wrote) and greatly molded by its first producer, Verity Lambert (thus the names of John Smith's parents in Human Nature).
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
CarlBillen
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1410
Joined: Tue Feb 04, 2003 3:34 pm 0
Location: Belgium

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by CarlBillen »

Well, I really hope that they don't press the 'reset' button like they did at the end of the last season...
Because if they...
Spoiler: show
...reset the Doctor's regeneration, that would be SERIOUS cheating...

And why is it that, while they will probably do that <groan> I REALLY don't hope they are going to reset the whole Time War in the same episode too...
PS4 : Carolus-Billius
User avatar
Sid James
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 579
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2005 9:54 am 0
Location: Guildford,UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Sid James »

arron wrote:
How about the Doctor defend someone he wouldn't normally defend in a courtroom setting (like the Master?). Start the trial about halfway through and then piece it together out of evidence and flashbacks after the Doctor has done an investigation to determine what is going on. Is the Master innocent? Who would wants him found guilty if he is? Will the Doctor find himself in the dock as a result of the trial for defending what has happened?
....and maybe we could have a mutilated Captain Jack in a motorised wheelchair with a buzzer and light on it. On buzz for yes, two for no? :wink:
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

Harlequin wrote:
arron wrote:Given that Terry Nation had a hand in both series they are pretty similar in their initial ideas [...]
Mr Nation had barely a fingernail in Doctor Who aside from creating its most iconic villains. The series was created by Sydney Newman of The Avengers (for which Nation also wrote) and greatly molded by its first producer, Verity Lambert (thus the names of John Smith's parents in Human Nature).
I agree with everything that you said about Terry Nation's contribution to Who, given that his major contribution was the Dalek stories that he did. I feel that the work he did on Survivors and Blake's 7 also took a lot from his work on Who given how you can compare one with the others. And Blake's 7 also had a number of contributors who also worked on Who, such as Robert Holmes, Douglas Camfield, Pennant Roberts and Michael Briant.
Harlequin wrote:
Sid James wrote:
arron wrote: I would dearly like it to be better.
So come on then, put your money where your mouth is. What would make it better in your eyes?
Moreover, why is arron, with his seemingly extensive experience of producing mass audience television series, not applying to succeed Mr Moffat?

(As an aside, I find it difficult to accept that responses such as, "That's not true, but I can see that it makes your life a bit easier if you believe that," are products of balanced and non-egoistic minds. They instead read to me as sickeningly condescending).
I think that someone reading my comments so far could probably determine that I'm very happy for Steven Moffat to take the job. I do have two of my own that I'm pretty fully occupied in doing. And I'm sure that he could do a better job of scriptwriting than me! :D Someone suggested that I "put my money where my mouth was" so I suggested two ideas for stories that If I were involved in the production process could be fleshed out into a more complex longer-term story which I feel would have more depth to it, so they wouldn't so much filler. That was all. This whole thread is basically a light discussion about a television program and that's all I see it as. I know some people must imagine that I'm involved in some frantic foaming-at-the-mouth internet warfare here, but it's nothing like that at all. I'm usually working whilst I'm on here, and switching to the browser window whilst what I'm working on tries again to do a job based on my piecemeal attempt at software engineering. The discussion last night was during attempts of my program to process DICOM files into something else.

The other "condescending comment" as you put it, was because I can't see how people can make a definitive statement about what I am, or how I feel and then it becomes fact. So I make a firm statement that "You may think that, but as I know me better than what you may guess based on what you think you know."

Here's an example, as one should always qualify what one says. I don't watch football because I can't stand watching it. So I don't comment about football given that I don't watch it. Applying the same logic to Who, the elements that I tend to be critical of are certain stories, certain characters and dialogue, which ironically is probably one of the cheapest things to fix. And they stem from pretty much one writer who is leaving. The location filming, the costumes, the special effects, the acting of the primary characters..I think that's all good. So to come out with a statement that "Arron hates new Who" is incorrect and it should be put right with more information. If I hated Who, then I wouldn't watch it, but I do watch it..broken bits and all.
Harlequin wrote:
arron wrote:I think that it's completely unrealistic [...]
Realism? In Doctor Who? When did that ever happen? An episode of an eight-parter in the Pertwee days or something? Are you confusing DW with, say, Captain Scarlet?
If you quote the entire line that I wrote - I think that it is completely unrealistic that you have have events that would destroy entire civilisations without consequence. Inferno (to quote a six part Pertwee story) destroyed an alternative earth without winding the whole thing back to as it was before with a plot device. You could see the consequences of the bad action without destroying the first earth. The Doctor spent his time in that episode without any quick fix, and the only option was to turn the "bad characters" to his side and flee the situation as there was nothing he could do by that point. I'm sure that he knew he was leaving those characters to their doom as a result. That's what I'm talking about. I'm sure that the Doctor couldn't come away from that episode with the sense that there was a happy clean ending to his involvement in that story. Real people perished in a final sense from his inability to help, even if they were alternative versions of people.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

arron wrote:Fifty minute episodes? 7pm in the evening..Spaceships, computers, guns, good on evil action, running around, pre watershed, no blood, no bad language, no sex? Looks like Doctor Who's target audience to me..and I was nine at the time it was shown.
At the time Doctor Who was on 23-minute episodes shown at half five in the evening on a Saturday night. Blake's Seven opened with the lead character being accused of child abuse and then teaming up with a group of amoral murderers.

You're applying modern standards, where 7pm is an 'acceptable for the older kids' slot. In 1980 the BBC thought Blue Peter and Grange Hill were TV for 16 year olds.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

Great eppisode in terms of dialog and fitting everyone in. (always hard to do)
I look forward to how this fits in with the stars disapering and whats on that disk. (

Shame about the crap villians. I managed to avoid all the spoilers.
I shouldnt have bothered.
Any others villians have worked just as well or, heck, why not try something new?
Have some varation on that darkness swarm, or that unknown enity in Midnight.
Id have even prefered the Slitheen.
The one thing the Dr Who has had is quite a lot of fantasic ideas. Why it thinks it has to go back to the same old one each final I have no idea.

--

oh, and stop having a go at Arron.
Just because someone points out faults dosnt mean they think they can do a better job, or that you can dismiss their views "because they hate the show".
If you like some bits but not others, surely its not wrong to want less of what you dont like?

Not sure of the point of compareing B7 to Dr Who though. They are hugely different shows.
Regardless of how "adult" or "child-friendly" a show is, theres no reason to have Dues-Ex moments. I've seen plenty of childrens shows that handel endings better then the recent Dr Who has.
(and before anyone points it out, if anyone does, I am well aware Reboot Season 3 did have a Dues Ex ending, or well, a human-out-of-the-machine at least.)
We've also never seen a Time War actually occur. What happens when someone else gets themselves technology to travel through time and fight a war with it? Once the timeline gets fragmented with constant action and reaction between the two sides, then it starts to get more difficult to stop. The Doctor has to track down where the technology came from originally, and try to contain it so the Time War cannot happen on schedule. If stopped now - does it happen later? Does the Doctor face reprisals from technology left behind from previous timelines protected against paradoxes used as a defence against the Doctor doing what he did?
Well , that last bit sounds a bit too Terminatorish the way you put it :p

Overall though, a TimeWar could indeed form a very interesting and bezire story. Not to mention cool visualy unique things.
The war wouldnt be waged with explosions and fire would it?
It would be a war of eraseing and building.
Why blow up a city when you can stop it from being made? Just make the city vanish.
Likewise you can arrange/rearrange your own cilivisations whole history to better prepare you to fight the war.
For the war to "work" as something comprehensable to non-timelords to watch, youd need a plot device to pretect the memories and areas from which those fighting the war operate. Id suggest a Paradox Engine, as has already been established. Allowing things to exist, even with the historical events nesscery for their existance has gone.
Of course though, something as major as a "TimeWar" would only be best shown in glimpse's.
User avatar
Jonesey
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2464
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 3:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: J0n3seY
PSN: MrJ0n3s3Y
Location: Gwynedd

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Jonesey »

You folks are clearly all nuts! :D

Anyway, can anyone point me in the direction of some episode wallpaper? Specifically the scene from the street looking up at the planets and the Dalek ship flying over attacking?
"PC Load Letter? What the fuck does that mean?"
*XBL-J0n3seY
*PSN-MrJ0n3s3Y
*SWITCH-SW112256510736
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

arron wrote:
Sid James wrote:
arron wrote: I would dearly like it to be better.
So come on then, put your money where your mouth is. What would make it better in your eyes?
I think the issue for people like Aaron and myself is that there is no other British sci-fi TV. Other than Primeval, though that show appears to have vanished off most people's radar. Dr Who is therefore in the position of having to be all things to all people: old fans, new fans and those who just stick the tv on while eating dinner. As such, you're always going to have those who love it, those who hate it and those who go *meh* :lol:

The other issue is that when Dr Who is good (e.g. The Empty Child), it casts a very harsh light on the failings in other episodes. I've always been very critical of the RTD soap-opera themes (ever since Mickey first reared his head), but done my best to praise the plots and elements I perceive to be good. I know the Dr Who production team will never read any of this, but in much the same way as the Neilsen ratings extrapolate from cumulative data, so I hope that adding my voice into the chorus will help direct the show's focus going forward.

For me, what would make it better is:
1) Get off planet Earth and humanity. Get away from plots which try to force Earth.England(from: 2000, to: 2008) culture, ethics and genepool onto plots set parsecs away and/or thousands, millions or billions of years into the future. It is possible to write good, popular scifi in this way - see the Forever War, Farscape or even Red Dwarf! :D Even Star Trek TNG did a better job when attempting to depict alien races and cultures, though this normally involved a few lumps of clay stuck to an actor's face. [*]

2) Back off from making the Doctor the Messiah. He's not, he's just a naughty boy^H^H^H the last 900 year old rogue timelord armed with a sonic screwdriver, an encyclopedic knowledge, an insatiable curiosity and a charmed life. Let's have some stories around this, rather than The Doctor Saves The World (Or At Least 21st Century London) Again At Christmas Time. Moffat's stuff is a good example of this, as was Gareth Roberts stuff (the Shakespeare Code and The Unicorn and the Wasp) - or even Human Nature (though the ending was something of a copout, at least the Doctor's actions were called to task for once).

3) Strengthen the science in the show. The Doctor shaking his foot to remove radiation is entertaining, but belongs in shows like Red Dwarf. I know this is science fiction, but that doesn't mean that plot devices can't be logical and/or internally consistent.

I'm aware that there's good reasons why the show has focused on the 21st Century, Wales/London and the godlike view of the Doctor, but I'd hope that the show's now strong enough to be able to experiment a little more.

After all that, here's another thought for the day. If the Time War stuff is liable to be rebooted, would that be a route for Eccleston to return?

[*] Oh, and back when Star Trek: TNG was still going, I used to enjoy contemplating a STTNG/DW crossover. I'd have loved to see the TARDIS materialise on the Enterprise's cargo deck, or for the Doctor to greet the Borg by asking them if they like gold...
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

Jonesey wrote:You folks are clearly all nuts! :D

Anyway, can anyone point me in the direction of some episode wallpaper? Specifically the scene from the street looking up at the planets and the Dalek ship flying over attacking?
Yus. There were some very pretty backdrops in that episode (very 70's airbrush style) and I'd love to see them as wallpaper :D
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

Backdrops where nice indeed. Wish the BBC supplied some nice-res ones.

Although some shots of the Tardis in the cascade looked a bit dodgy. Like it was matted-over and the anti-aliasing was off or something.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

juice wrote:1) Get off planet Earth and humanity. Get away from plots which try to force Earth.England(from: 2000, to: 2008) culture, ethics and genepool onto plots set parsecs away and/or thousands, millions or billions of years into the future. It is possible to write good, popular scifi in this way - see the Forever War, Farscape or even Red Dwarf! :D Even Star Trek TNG did a better job when attempting to depict alien races and cultures, though this normally involved a few lumps of clay stuck to an actor's face. [*]
It's expensive to do well though. I do agree that the out-of-time culture stuff should be eased off on, but constantly bouncing through different sets of future humans wears just as quickly as endless UNIT stories.

I'd like to see more historical episodes myself. They're usually better than the average story, and much easier to do well than the future stuff. For a 13-episode series, I think a really good balance would be ~ three historicals, ~ three current-day, and ~ seven future / space eps.
Post Reply