Little stoned kiwi wrote:gilesgoat wrote:
"Self defense" it's a weird subject in Italy, more often than not "if you react in any way" the part that "in theory" "was in its right to react" ends up in being "the monster" with the worst outcome
"They came straight at me without provocation, I was in fear for my life and reacted to their assault."
It's NOT - AS NOTHING IS IN ITALY - so clear cut as you say here ...
I did check "briefly" some notes about the "Italian principle of self defense" .. it's .. complicated ..
With things like "the reaction has to be
necessary and
proportionate .. " ..
Now here begins 100 pages of law describing "the criteria of necessity" and "the definition of proportionate" ...
.. and goes with things like " .. the comma 2 says that there can be a
presumption of proportionality when the following conditions are satisfied .. "
In other words there are things like "there had to proven there was a real danger situation, unavoidable, not JUST that you PERCEIVED DANGER, that HAD to be danger " ...
I think that's "for discussions like" "he pointed a gun at me" .. "I was only scaring him I DID NOT have intention to shoot" .. etc. .. "you perceived danger" .. but "what is really there" ???
" .. la difesa deve essere operata attraverso un'arma o un altro strumento di coercizione legittimamente detenuto da chi la adopera. " ..
Which means things like "if you shoot someone with a weapon that you did not have a license for you are into problems" ..
Not sure what happens "if you use an improper weapon" .. like a pole or a baseball bat or anything like that ...
" .. poiché in tal caso mancherebbe il requisito del pericolo come rimarcato dalla sentenza della Suprema Corte di Cassazione del 23 marzo 2011 n. 11610 " ...
If you shoot/injury someone that was fleeing away and/or on his/her back you CAN NOT invoke the "self defense" thing according to this sentence of the supreme court ..
However the same court seems to grant you the "presumption of danger" thing if the intruder was actually entering your home and/or your workplace.
So if someone enters your house/workplace and treatens you you are guarantee the "presumption of danger".
Anyway the more I read I read the more is "full of cases by cases thing" and INSITS A LOT on this "principle of proprtionality" .. where "the (your) reaction has to be proportional to the action".
So if someone punches you and you kill him/her with a weapon "self defense is not valid".
Also keep in mind "X attacks you", "you respond and injury X" .. X has still the right to sue you for "damages" .. by absurdity I've seens stories happening, you can both win, X goes in prison for attacking you BUT you HAVE TO PAY DAMAGES to X for what you done.
So don't crippple someone because it's going to cost you a fortune ...