Hajile wrote:Why did they take Rose and her mum back to the parallel dimension at the end? Weren't they there by, you know, accident? That The Doctor would undo in a second if he could, but it was permanent, so they were stuck apart? It seemed like they decided to part again just so they could have yet another teary-eyed farewell. And to plot device the second Doctor out of future episodes.
Did I miss the explanation, or was there no explanation given?
IIRC, it was to prevent the Doctor and the DonnaDoctor from sharing the same universe.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
silent_unicorn wrote:Ok I was youtubing Lalla Ward today and came across return of Romana snippets on there with the new doctor. Can someone explain to me what is going on
Well, if I'm looking at the same search results that you're looking at, those are just "fan fiction" videos. Cutting bits of old Romana footage with recent Tenth Doctor footage, in some kind of "fantasy episode" music video thingamabob.
It just so happens that more than one person has decided to independently "riff" on the same theme of "Romana vs. the Tenth Doctor", which, yes, can make it look like there actually was a "return of Romana" episode or something. But there wasn't. This is just "fan fiction" stuff, splicing footage.
As far as I'm aware, in the new series, Romana remains "presumed dead" from the Time War, along with all the other Time Lords. They haven't brought her back yet - if they ever will. Anyway, if they did, chances are that she'd be regenerated and no longer played by Lalla Ward anyhow.
Ahhh that's what got me because there was a death scene from the original series and well it gets too confusing as I really don't follow it enough to know what's going on.
Given how Sir Moffat was saying quite repeatedly that the Time War stuff was to be left to our imaginations I doubt it. But then he's not in charge yet.... and it does seem an interesting theory.