I think as long as it points out the difference it's fair game. If I wanted to buy something that was like mayonnaise without eggs in it, I'd much rather it was called "egg-free mayonnaise" because I'd have the vaguest idea at what they were trying to achieve flavour-wise, rather than something like "egg-free continental-style salad-dressing".ThetaReactor wrote:My point is that calling something without eggs "mayonnaise" is like calling something without grains "beer". It's kind of an integral part of the food.
Also, to use your own example, you can get alcohol-free beer, where most of us would think the alcohol was pretty much integral to the whole point. And in the case of wine, whilst grapes are expected, you can get away with making it with just about anything, but should probably tell folk that it's carrot and raisin rather than Sauvignon Blanc.
There's loads of other examples. Tea made with not tea, milks that aren't squirted from animals, sausages made from not meat*. It's a handy shortcut to what the intention of the end product is as much as anything. So if you want something to put on your cornflakes that hasn't seen a nipple you can pick soya milk or almond milk, knowing it's the right tool for the job (regardless of how well it performs it).
*Hastily runs away to watch thread from behind the sofa












