Sigh.Kamineko wrote:Fixed that for you.Acronym wrote:Some of the time, sure, it's a record label squatting on a record, but don't tell me you've got any right to determine how any musician presents their work. They get to set their context, whether that's a retail box, a download, an installation, or a gig.
RIP Oink (Was: Oink Invites Going Begging)
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
Depressing, isn't it?Jimaroid wrote:Sigh.Kamineko wrote:Fixed that for you.Acronym wrote:Some of the time, sure, it's a record label squatting on a record, but don't tell me you've got any right to determine how any musician presents their work. They get to set their context, whether that's a retail box, a download, an installation, or a gig.
It proves that despite these albums being downloaded very heavily they still did very well indeed. Meaning that if downloads were a significant negative factor that you would not see any album doing well and specifically the albums MOST heavily downloaded were still going double platinum (I believe 300k for a platinum). Very few artists sell 300k albums.pogo wrote: So the most popular albums, i.e. those that sold the most, are also the most popular downloads. Well, duh. And this proves what exactly?
Maybe. I don't know enough about the figures to comment.pogo wrote: But using raw download data and interpreting it as in the above article? Worse than useless.
I'm sorry but I don't agree.pogo wrote: My own take on this is the 20% or so fall in music sales since 2001 must have an explanation. It's not other forms of entertainment - video games and home videos have been around for decades, steadily growing like music sales were until a few years ago.
Lets take video games. Limiting this to the US (the easy place to find figures) the dollar value of console and computer game spending over the last 10 years has almost trippled from 2.6Billion in 1996 to 7.4 Billion in 2006. My assumption is that this is reflected in the other two major areas (Japan and Europe) not to mention other markets. Thats a fairly significant increase baring in mind that the retail value of sales for recorded music in the US for 2006 was only 11.5 billion.
Now, if you take the 2000 figure for retail music sales in the US which is 14 billion and now which is 11.5 you see a 3.5 billion drop in sales. In comparison the sales figures for games in the US went from 5.6 billion to 7.4. There we've cut those losses to 1.7 billion.
Now factor in all the other pull on your money (DVD, Cinema, mobile phones, clothes etc) and things are looking a LOT less bleak. Also in a number of areas, UNIT sales actually increased but the revenue from those sales decreased.
Heres the US DVD shipment figures in millions from the last 10 years
I'm sure a good proportion of that is mirrored by an equal decline in VHS sales but I'm also pretty certain that a good proportion aren't.
1997 5.5
1998 25.1
1999 98
2000 182.4
2001 364.4
2002 685
2003 1,023.30
2004 1,518.30
2005 1,656.90
2006 1656.6
This is taken from the 2006 report for the UK.
What I get from this is• UK acts claimed a 61.9% share of best selling albums in 2006
• Domestic UK album market topped 150m sales for the 4th year running, representing the most successful year for British talent for at least a decade
• Snow Patrol top end of year chart (1.5m units)
• 14 UK debut albums reach top 100
• Digital accounted for 79% of singles sales
• The digital albums market saw 2.2m units sold between April and December 2006; digital sales now comprise 1.4% of the overall album market
• Overall album sales decline 2.5% to 155.1m units
• Singles market grew by 39.7%, fuelled by growth in downloads
UK Bands are doing very very well in the UK showing the best sales in 10 years.
Album sales declined by about 4 million units but was offset by a huge growth in online digital single downloads. This is pretty significant to me and echos a number of people I've heard - those that used to buy an album to get a couple of tracks now probably don't. Again factor in the huge growth in video games, mobile phone costs and the like and it's no so bad after all.
Basically, I just don't buy the rhetoric they spout. I read their figures VERY differently to the way they do. Or rather their propaganda completely ignores all the massive increases in digital sales and focus on lost revenue . Simple fact of the matter is we're now paying a lot less for our music and not all of it goes to them because we're no longer limited by their control of the radio and TV networks.
And when you look at the sales figures for digital download they've shown massive exponential growth over the last 10 years.pogo wrote: But people listen to more and more music than ever. The iPod, other music players, video players and MP3 phones have all been massively successful, and have 10x the capacity of five years ago.
None of the online sales that were not from the major companies are counted . They make estimates but unless you're in the big 5 and activly submit your figures theres no record of it. So now there are many 1000's of artists who regularly get listened to with no imput to these figures. Also always remember that a huge number of people take their existing media and convert it (which is what the music industry hates). Previously with any new technology (vinyl>tape, tape>cd, vhs>dvd) people were re-buying almost everything they used to have again. This time it's COMPLETELY different. There is no new technology in music to force people to re-buy what they already have. This, I'm sure, has had a huge impact on that market (hence all this DRM crap to make sure it can't happen again - they want to force you to re-buy it for every single new format)pogo wrote: And there's more music than ever to buy, with more artists using the web to self-publish, back catalogues and re-mastered titles and online only releases (last thing I bought from iTunes was only available there).
It's very easy to grossly over simplify this whole situation but I don't believe an industry proven to lie time and time again and only have their own capitalist interest at heart.
I'm sorry but you're buying into the story. I'll leave you with this quote made in 2005 by IFPI Chairman and CEO John Kennedypogo wrote: Meanwhile P2P reportedly accounts for most of the traffic on the Internet, a proportion of which is audio, almost entirely illegal content. You may have another explanation, but to me the only sensible one is that if people listen to more and more music but buy less and less of it at least some must be illegally copied, e.g. over the torrent networks.
GJohn Kennedy wrote:The global music market is fast becoming a mixed economy in the way fans and consumers are buying their music. It is encouraging that the markets with the strongest digital sales are also generally the best performing markets overall. In Japan digital has already made up for the decline in physical sales, and other markets should go this way. Physical music sales declined again for a combination of reasons, including digital and physical piracy, competition from other entertainment products and the shift in consumer spending to online and
mobile.â€
It's simply irrelevant noise to point out grammatical errors in what was otherwise a reasonably interesting discussion. To point out such a miniscule non-error in Acronym's much more valid and worthwhile point of discussion is simply depressing, distracting and aggravating. Trying to have a conversation with the FTFY brigade popping up is like trying to have a piss with a Jack Russell biting your ankles; it's futile and makes a mess of everything.Kamineko wrote:Could you elaborate on that? I don't get your meaning. (Unless it's just 'I disagree', in which case I offer you a Honey & Lemon flavour Locket)Jimaroid wrote:Sigh.
I wasn't pointing out a grammatical error. I was making a distinction between the singular absolute and the possessive: I think there can be more than one context. They can choose theirs. Folks can either accept that context, or search for another context. If they wish to frame a new context, then they will.
Well frankly that's tough shit. Or shouldn't I be allowed to buy a 2nd hand copy of The Laughing Gnome down at my local record shoppe?Acronym wrote:Maybe they don't want their old records in circulation any more?
As to bootlegs, I agree totally with you.
If I want it and it's available to buy then I'll buy because the acts have to earn a crust and I'll want to hear more music from them. If it's not available then I might be tempted to steal/infringe copyright on it and buy when/if it does become available.
Anyway Oink's wasn't busted because the acts were suffering, it was busted because the record companies are too lazy and stupid to find a new business model. They ripped us consumers off for years and there was nothing we could do about it. Now the boot's firmly on the other foot and I'm rather enjoying it. They should just dry their eyes and accept that things change instead of running around boo-hooing and loosing their Shylocks on 12 year old kids.
A lot of bands don't have that freedom.Acronym wrote:They get to set the context, whether that's a retail box, a download, an installation, or a gig.
Personally I think the less-well-known acts have a better chance at making it because of sites like Oink's and have a lot to gain through online distribution.
Sure, they're spinning the figures, and sure, I agree that one of the major reasons people use free downloads is simply because paid-for downloads haven't been available and/or don't do what they want to do, but I know too many people with full iPods who haven't bought a CD in three years (or done a paid download) to think that P2P downloads aren't hurting music sales at least a bit...GBH wrote:A lot of interesting stuff.
People can spout off against the RIAA as much as they want and I'll generally agree, but I really just don't get why anyone would think that Oink was really a force for good. If it explicitly disallowed anything that could be bought somehow, I might reconsider.
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
Whereas I think trying to split that particular hair *in the context of peer-to-peer* is, well, misguided at best. Considering my argument is essentially that the vast majority of music is not made for the money, though the money certainly helps the artists (and yes, I do mean that in the fine-art sense) fund the process of creating it, it's downright rude to abuse their intent.Kamineko wrote:I wasn't pointing out a grammatical error. I was making a distinction between the singular absolute and the possessive: I think there can be more than one context. They can choose theirs. Folks can either accept that context, or search for another context. If they wish to frame a new context, then they will.
And P2P does that just as much as eBaytastic collector-scum (edit: by that I mean the people who try and corner the market in rare records to drive up the price...) and ticket touts do. It's just rude.
Last edited by Acronym on Wed Oct 24, 2007 2:52 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
Yeah, of course you can, but that's much more limited in scope and spread. Sure, there'll be a small number of completists/obsessives who spend *way* too much on the artifact, and that's a shame, but...fritx wrote:Well frankly that's tough shit. Or shouldn't I be allowed to buy a 2nd hand copy of The Laughing Gnome down at my local record shoppe?Acronym wrote:Maybe they don't want their old records in circulation any more?
Basically, the Internet means you can't make mistakes any more, and I think that's going to lead to fewer risks being taken. I reckon that's a shame, personally speaking, though the genie's permanently out of the bottle now.
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
And one more point; 'the record companies' as a generalization don't exist. 'The record companies' - let's say the business members of MCPS and PRS - range from EMI to, well, people on this forum. It's hardly a homogeneous mass of oppression.
And thinking of it like that is lazy, and careless, and wrong.
And thinking of it like that is lazy, and careless, and wrong.
- MadHippo
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6529
- Joined: Mon Dec 09, 2002 11:29 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: madhippo1
- Location: Reading, more-or-less.
Going back to a previous conversation in another thread - it's all about respect again.
If you want to continue having new music made, you have to respect the process, and the artists. Buy CDs and / or downloads. Don't just rip them off. If you want to try to change the music industry's way of business, sure, that's fine - but you can't change the system by becoming an enemy of it.
edit: Acronym - totally agree with you.
If you want to continue having new music made, you have to respect the process, and the artists. Buy CDs and / or downloads. Don't just rip them off. If you want to try to change the music industry's way of business, sure, that's fine - but you can't change the system by becoming an enemy of it.
edit: Acronym - totally agree with you.
XBox Live Gamertag: MadHippo1
- Ratsoap
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6344
- Joined: Fri Dec 19, 2003 1:46 pm 0
- Location: Back in Edinburgh
- Contact:
Quite the opposite, it expressly forbade uploading stuff that could be got for free elsewhere.Dio wrote: If it explicitly disallowed anything that could be bought somehow, I might reconsider.
Because fucking marketing cunts would never call a spade anything other than a Deluxe Easi-Shift Earth Movement Solution.
My biggest issue with this is that people generally seem unable to see that there is view present that is both against piracy and for electronic distribution. Not all piracy is electronic distribution, and vice versa, but in the case of Oink there was a fundamental bias towards ripping people off. People were encouraged to "profit" through the trading of other people's assets. That's piracy, electronic or not. The issues surrounding traditional physical media and the future of electronic distribution holds no place in Oink's shutdown.
There's a big difference between casual bootlegging between mates and an orchestrated scheme to distribute and profit from the same bootleg. Oink was shutdown because of that difference and I think it's a good thing that works in favour of and for the artists, the "big bad record companies" barely factor into the moral contract between an artist and their audience.
There's a big difference between casual bootlegging between mates and an orchestrated scheme to distribute and profit from the same bootleg. Oink was shutdown because of that difference and I think it's a good thing that works in favour of and for the artists, the "big bad record companies" barely factor into the moral contract between an artist and their audience.



