I don't know .. as it happens I watched that movie twice .. I don't think it's "totally crap" I think it's "too brutal but makes a point" I mean in one thing is really "realistic" if things should happen that way.WiteWulf wrote:Nope, nobody needs to watch Irreversible, it's a horrible, horrible gratuitous movie with no artistic redemption whatsoever.gilesgoat wrote:
.. and if you really want to see something TOO BEYOND .. .. "Irreversible" .. but you need some stomach for it ...
And Giles, please don't recommend movies like that without making it clear what it's about. Someone could watch it without knowing and be seriously traumatised/triggered.
It's about a woman who gets raped in an extremely unpleasant and graphic segment of the movie which goes on for about 10 minutes.
Admittedly the movie is somewhat notorious among fans of extreme cinema, and some may think it's impossible to /not/ know about the movie...but still...
I think it's "incredibly weird" - intentionally - the whole way the movie is done is "to make you feel completely uncomfortable" but I suppose also "make the point about that situation as much clear as it could be" .. it makes you feel "lost" "confused" "shocked" and I think that's exactly what the movie wanted, "make a point about a terrifying situation".
I would NOT say "it does not have any artistic redemption" because I think "it's probably one of the worst/best ways to represent the reality of an horrendous situation" this movie is "all weird/wrong from begin to end" starting with "the really strange 3 now 2 love relationship" with the characters and the "attachement" the other has still to his ex-lover ..
You seen some movies when they tried to represent some violence situation "in certain way" and "it's still a movie", what makes this one different is that "does not make you feel it's a movie, it makes it feels as real as it can be".
But yes "overall the story is pretty simple" .. and then again I don't know if it's "the main violence act" the worst thing OR "the whole movie as as whole" including the story with all the main characters .. "girl finds herself in the wrongest possible place at the wrongest possible moment total chaos ensues" ..
But "lookig around" all the rest of the movie "is even worse" .. the two characters speaking at the start ( or end ) of the movie, the whole story, the whole development, the people, the police, the place, the life .. "nothing has any redeeming quality" in any sense.
But speaking of "super shocking movies" .. there's worse to be seen .. then I would NOT absolutely reccomend anyone to watch "Hostel" which by itself is a totally stupid story .. but the worst of the worst I ever seen it's been an ITALIAN movie called "Salo' or the 120 days of Sodom" .. that .. DO NOT WATCH IT .. it's TOTAL INSANITY FROM BEGIN TO THE VERY END !! ..
And it's not about really "gore" or such ( well there's MUCH gore in the end of it ) but it's "the whole psychologocial de-humanization" of ALL the characters involved .. the "dukes" to start with are "completely un-human" and they end-up in totally de-humanizing all the others ( except a couple that dies as a result of not being de-humanized ).
I mean "irreversible" it's a movie about "random bad shit happens, someone wants his revenge, lot of more shit happens" .. but fundamentally "is that" ...
Salo' is .. "all another level" of things .. is "life destroyed from beginning to end arriving at something worse than death" is almost "the complete destruction of life/death itself into something much worse" .. it's LOT more psychological than gory and it's probably "one of the weirdest movies ever made".
Why I watched "Irreversible" and why Salo' ?
Because I heard about them being spoken "many times around certain places" and I was curious .. "curiosity killed the cat" but in some way "they do convey a message" that should be taken as "warning" and "what NOT to do" ..
Anyway .. "to take a step back into the real world" .. some weeks ago, and we are NOT talking about fiction AT ALL but REALITY, there was an article about some things happening in some "re-education camps" for some rohingya people that some people that managed to escape from reported ( that OF COURSE can NOT be "officially" confirmed ) .. plus not long ago there was a report of someone that managed to have a working cell phone that got undetected for quite some time and managed to post some "messages" about what was going on there for some time .. until he "vanished" NEVER to be heard again ..
Let's put it this way, what happens in those movies above happens ONCE .. what happens in reality happens N times a day every day and never stops ...
And that wasn't a movie, was the BBC News site.
Reality always surpasses any fiction
[edit] - one movie that really shocked me for the reality of things is *DO NOT WATCH IT* this one :
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pixote
This is a movie/DOCUMENTARY on the REAL life/facts of that guy in Brazil in 1980 , it's "much more realistic" than "Citade de deus" ( City of God ) and I remember around the same time watching - we were in college years - a "similar" Italian one called "Mery per sempre" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forever_Mery ) ..
As I said "Irreversible" is a FICTIONAL story that depicts some real facts, these are REAL stories on REAL facts ..
Reality surpasses fiction all the time ...




