This has been the case _since_ the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings, which served not only to end the pacific war, but also as an object lesson as to how horrific they are as weapons. At the time the 2 bombs were dropped, they were viewed simply as things that went bang in a very big way and took cities off the map. Radiation sickness was known about, but "cancers long after the event" and birth defects weren't. The after-effects of Hiroshima and Nagasaki went some considerable way to disavowing people of the belief that global thermonuclear war was in some way "winnable", without which we would probably not still be here to bitch about it.phattslagg wrote:Thank goodness, yes.Rambozo wrote:However I am sick and tired of the Hiroshima/Nagasaki bombings being portrayed as particularly horrific just because atomic bombs were used. There's this enormous stigma surrounding them that makes any use of such devices seem unjustifiable in any circumstances,
And it cannot be ignored that Hiroshima and Nagasaki _did_ end the pacific war, in a very speedy way. It doesn't make the victims of those bombs any less dead or damaged, of course, but 400,000 dead over sisxty years is not very many in the grand scheme of things : the Japanese killed nearly that many (mostly innocent civilians) in Nanking alone, and had issued orders that all allied POWs (100,000 or more at the time) were to be executed in the event of any allied invasion.
In view of the facts known at the time, and the situation as it stood, at least Hiroshima can be seen as being as valid an act of war as many of the other barbarities that we carried out between '39 and '45. Nagasaki perhaps less so, but Japan _did_ concede defeat the very next day, so...
Indeed it could. And, apart from a few fucking maniacs, nobody has used those fucking aberrations in a 'real' war since 1918. Notch another one up for "fuck me, that's a bad idea".Exactly the same could be said of a biological or chemical warhead.but in fact they are just bombs. You drop them, people die.
Simon
