Help to Stamp Out Piracy

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Post by HGFB »

rockwaldo wrote:
Kon-Tiki wrote:You got up to tomorrow noon for this.
Or else we come and fuck you up.

Seems a bit harsh this thread. Started off as a bit of a funny, and now we're all being policemen. Fluffy.

<contrail></contrail>
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
oddbob0
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1727
Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2004 7:43 pm 0
Location: Liverpool

Post by oddbob0 »

Kon-Tiki wrote:7/18 games down... not bad, but still breaking your law. These should be taken down as well, or you still commit intellectual property infringement:
Head Over Heels
Bruce Lee
Kung Fu
Manic Miner
Jet Set Willy 2
Flash Sonic
Rick Dangerous
Flash Zelda
Asteroids
Space Invaders
Alien Breed

Also, you wouldn't want to be associated with pirates like Noodan and the one of Blitzgamer.com, if you want to keep your integrity, so take that link off of your site too. The last one even does intellectual property infringement in their link banner! You got up to tomorrow noon for this.
Ummm...should I take them down as well before you report me too?

Isn't there something somewhere about two wrongs not making a right?
\m/
User avatar
Kon-Tiki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5594
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 9:54 pm 0
Location: Inside my BO
Contact:

Post by Kon-Tiki »

rockwaldo wrote:
Kon-Tiki wrote:You got up to tomorrow noon for this.
Or else we come and fuck you up.

Seems a bit harsh this thread. Started off as a bit of a funny, and now we're all being policemen. Fluffy.
He shouldn't be so proud of shutting other people's sites down if he doesn't live by his own word. I'm honestly only doing this to him, as he's being an utter cunt and pisses all over the indie community AND the legal system with his shit, and seems proud to do so.
User avatar
rockwaldo
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4096
Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2003 11:49 pm 0
Location: playing cricket in the street at 3am

Post by rockwaldo »

Can I just say this, If anyone forces the fantastic head over heels remake to be taken down I'm going to punch them in the throat.
So, you want to be an ARCADE champion BLOG to read. yay! [ http://www.arcadechampion.co.uk ]
User avatar
Kon-Tiki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5594
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 9:54 pm 0
Location: Inside my BO
Contact:

Post by Kon-Tiki »

oddbob0 wrote:
Kon-Tiki wrote:7/18 games down... not bad, but still breaking your law. These should be taken down as well, or you still commit intellectual property infringement:
Head Over Heels
Bruce Lee
Kung Fu
Manic Miner
Jet Set Willy 2
Flash Sonic
Rick Dangerous
Flash Zelda
Asteroids
Space Invaders
Alien Breed

Also, you wouldn't want to be associated with pirates like Noodan and the one of Blitzgamer.com, if you want to keep your integrity, so take that link off of your site too. The last one even does intellectual property infringement in their link banner! You got up to tomorrow noon for this.
Ummm...should I take them down as well before you report me too?

Isn't there something somewhere about two wrongs not making a right?
Nah, you're not shutting other people's sites down because of stuff like this, so who cares? The more people play those games, the better :P It's just self-righteous twats like Addictive, who don't live by their own words, who have to do what they preach on themselves as well.
User avatar
teamonkey
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12082
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
PSN: teamonkey_ca
Contact:

Post by teamonkey »

I'm out of the loop again it seems. Can anyone explain in simple words why Addictive247 is the spawn of the devil? I'd very much like to jump on the bandwagon.
User avatar
Kon-Tiki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5594
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 9:54 pm 0
Location: Inside my BO
Contact:

Post by Kon-Tiki »

oddbob0 wrote:
HGFB wrote:Since when did the real copyright owners matter? This is comic book style dark vigilante justice.

*sock* *kerpow* Take that vile filesharing site!

All you need to do is make a witty one liner when you get a site closed down or a link removed.

How do you know which copyrighted files the actual real owners are bothered about though? And how do you know you're not asking a site to remove a fake file uploaded by one of those companies hired by the real copyright owner to seed fear, uncertainty and binary garbage onto the net.

Basically why are you doing it?
I wrote a long post about this on another board, but sadly all the topics relating to stampoutpiracy seem to disappear into the ether somewhere for some reason after a few days. I did fancy adding a bit more, but not a lot I can do now so bear with me...

The more I think about it - the more wrong the whole thing becomes. At first it seemed like a naive idea that was a bit daft, but the tactics and tone you're using - they're not endearing to anybody and it makes the Indie scene look like cunts. (Which admittedly, some of us are)

Sorry for taking this thread back onto a serious tangent, but lets go back to the Donkey Kong example here. I think everyone here knows what site I run and what we do, and I also think everyones fully aware that its technically walking the wrong side of copyright infringement. Anyone familiar with McKenna gate will know that we were amongst his targets as well as World Of Spectrum. And whilst I still think it was misguided, its still perfectly within his rights to say "hang the fuck on, I own the IP - pull it down" and lo, we did.

Now, if Stampoutpiracy.com had been McKenna's first port of call - straight reporting to our hosts and boof, thats 5 years of peoples hard work down the pisser and all the stuff we've been granted permission for is also fucked along with the stuff we haven't.

Yet, its perfectly acceptable to on one cheek proudly display some of the games from our mob which infringe copyright because its not coming out of any of the partners pockets here, but its not ok to pirate a game from one of the stampoutpiracy.com partners? Thats bad mmk.

Vigilante justice aside, its a bit hypocritical.

If you're going to nail down on copyright infringement - better pull all those remakes off your page because I hate to break it to you, because I know which ones have got permission from the authors to be made and which haven't - and only one of them has any sort of authorisation to be made.

Case number 2, tying into JQW's comment. With this wonderful brand of justice if someones site gets hacked, overnight someone uploads a load of warez and amongst them is one of the Stampoutpiracy partners, who just happens to find the file not long after but - it happens on a weekend, or overnight before the site owner finds out about it. Too late, you've been reported.

And its not exactly an irregular occurrence. Sure, you can say "well he should look after his server better" but shit like this does happen - and with the vigilante justice service of death rushing in to protect their interests without actually thinking beyond "hey, we'll just report it to the hosts, we'll report it to FAST" you could knock out anything off the net, just by not thinking and being a spoon with it. You could be kicking someone elses life blood and earnings off the intertron because it might possibly cost you money.

And thats without even getting into the issue of hypocrisy when it comes to a large sector of the Indie scene positively feeding off cannibalising each others work and that of mainstream developers to line their own pockets, and ignoring the figures that Russ of Reflexive has thrown out there about how these people who download the games weren't actually ever going to buy it anyway *and* ignoring the issue of someone with no authority whatsoever over the internet going on a crusade to take down evil...

Wise men say, only fools rush in.

Wouldn't it be better to educate developers about better sales techniques, how to avoid casual piracy properly without resorting to donning a lycra suit, putting your y-fronts on the outside tactics or using horrendously offensive DRM? Or perhaps trying to foster a mentality where every game isn't a free for all the instant it hits the market within the Indie community? Or perhaps, and this is a bit of a longshot, concentrating your efforts and those of the indie community on raising their profiles, better customer service, press liasons - courting the customers? Or any of the other things that make or break mainstream companies?

All I see is a willful ignorance of what and where the problems really lie and you can report 1 site, you can report 100 sites, you can report 1000 sites and they'll still keep on coming. They'll still appear.

In the end, you'll achieve nothing but wasting your own time and effort and look a bit of a twat into the bargain. IMO, of course.
Kon-Tiki wrote:
Addictive 247 wrote:@Oddbob: Thanks for your post. I know some people are for the site and others are against it. I definately don't want us to come across as a vigilante group, we're not.

The whole "We're Watching" logo was/is temporary. We're going for a nicer way to represent ourselves which should be up soon.
Now, if Stampoutpiracy.com had been McKenna's first port of call - straight reporting to our hosts and boof, thats 5 years of peoples hard work down the pisser and all the stuff we've been granted permission for is also fucked along with the stuff we haven't.
We don't work like that. We don't just rush in and ask hosts to take down whole sites without looking into things first.

Some of the forums we go on (which is where we find most files) are blatant warez sites. They have forum topics like "Get Full Version of Game XYZ". The description in the post also tells you that it is an illegal pirate version. The replies to the post also show us that the link is for a pirated copy. We then inform the file sharing site that the file sits on AND we send a link to the actual developer or game company and inform them of what we're are doing.

So far we've had great support and thanks from some of the big casual gaming companies for alerting them to illegal files, as well as from Indie Developers.

The Supporters that are listed on the website aren't there because we just look for copies of their games. They're listed as they have decided to link back to us, that's all. StampOutPiracy.com is trying to get illegal game files removed for all indie devs and gaming portals. No one gets preference.
And its not exactly an irregular occurrence. Sure, you can say "well he should look after his server better" but shit like this does happen - and with the vigilante justice service of death rushing in to protect their interests without actually thinking beyond "hey, we'll just report it to the hosts, we'll report it to FAST" you could knock out anything off the net, just by not thinking and being a spoon with it. You could be kicking someone elses life blood and earnings off the intertron because it might possibly cost you money.
As I've said above we don't just rush in and report everyone. We've so far only reported 2 major warez sites to FAST, and they never replied! They were obvious warez sites with hundreds of game links and messages to some very big gaming companies basically saying "Fuck You, we'll carry on pirating your games and your lawyers can't do a thing". Funnily enough both sites are still operating.

I'm also hoping that the site will educate people and developers can send their potential customers/visitors to our information pages to give them the facts about piracy.
All I see is a willful ignorance of what and where the problems really lie and you can report 1 site, you can report 100 sites, you can report 1000 sites and they'll still keep on coming. They'll still appear.
You're right in that the sites will still keep coming and people will still pirate games. It's an uphill struggle from the start but one that I think is worthwhile.
That does not compute with...
Addictive 247 wrote:
What methods do you use to stop pirate software distributors? shutdown their website or something?
Initially, we'll try and shut the website down but we'll also trawl through the site, find out where the files are actually hosted (usually on a file sharing site) and then report each file to the sharing site.

Basically, if the whole site can't be shut down it will at least contain dead links
You're contradicting yourself heavily there. One moment, you say: "We first try to shut a site down" then you say "We don't try to shut a site down."

This shows your techniques, though:
Addictive 247 wrote:Stamp Out Piracy (http://www.stampoutpiracy.com) is a new initiative to crack down on game piracy across the Internet. It's there to help Indie developers, casual game portals and larger game companies in the fight against piracy.

This is a new website which was started only a week ago but already we've been sucessful in shutting a number of accounts down.

More information about how you can help can be found at http://www.stampoutpiracy.com/howtohelp.htm

The site is a working progress for now but will start to change and improve over the coming weeks.
Sounds like you're awfully proud of it!

Now then, with such an attitude, the hypocrisy goes further, as pointed out earlier:
Addictive 247 wrote:With regards to Donkey Kong . . .

I run the site Retro 247 and it was put up there when the site was first started, quite some time ago. It's never really worked and as far as I know was a bad remake. Just need to remove the file now when I get a chance this afternoon.
That's hypocrisy at maximum. "Hey, that site hosts an illegal game. We'll just shut it down. Oh, my site does too. I'll just take the game down whenever I feel like it."

Now, all your blabbering and advertising (I clearly remember you asking me to put your game OrbitZ up on my site, and I went out of my way to push all other games we had in line aside to give your game top priority, but never ever seen you here, nor on my site, unless it's for advertising your stuff) will result in this:
Addictive 247 wrote:Stamp Out Piracy (http://www.stampoutpiracy.com) is a new initiative to crack down on game piracy across the Internet. It's there to help Indie developers, casual game portals and larger game companies in the fight against piracy.

This is a new website which was started only a week ago but already we've been sucessful in shutting a number of accounts down.

More information about how you can help can be found at http://www.stampoutpiracy.com/howtohelp.htm

The site is a working progress for now but will start to change and improve over the coming weeks.
Do you feel courtous, punk? What about putting your actions where your words are?
1) Bloody well help out
2) Take those games and links off your site before Friday 13/07/2007, noon, GMT+1
Or your game goes down of my site, as we do not condone hypocrisy, nor do we want to be associated with hypocrits and I will report YOU to your ISP. Bloody cunt!

Edit: Just went through your site, and whooooo boy, about half of your games are copyright infridgement in one way or another. What do we have there... Zelda, Sonic, Jet Set Willy, Manic Miner, Head Over Heels, Kung Fu, Lunar Lander, Rick Dangerous, Asteroids, Alien Breed, Bruce Lee, Ghosts'n Goblins, Pitfall 3, Duck Hunt, Frogger, Pac Man, Space Invaders, Hurrican. Now, I'm not a lawyer, but I do know they all break intellectual property one way or another. Better take them down too, if you want to keep your integrity (and your site, Mr. Hipocryte). Also take down and harrass the sites you link to, like Noodan, as they have plenty more of such games.
oddbob0 wrote:
Addictive 247 wrote:@Oddbob: Thanks for your post. I know some people are for the site and others are against it. I definately don't want us to come across as a vigilante group, we're not.
I'm pretty loathe to do the whole wikipedia link central thing normally, but I'll make an exception this time as its late:

Vigilante : "A vigilante is someone who takes the enforcement of law or moral code into his or her own hands."

Technically, you are. It doesn't matter how you spin it morally, we're in textbook definition territory. I don't remember anyone actually appointing stampoutpiracy as legal or moral guardians of the internet or as a law enforcement group in any sort of official sponsored and supported capacity. Therefor, I claim vigilante as a perfectly accurate description.
The whole "We're Watching" logo was/is temporary. We're going for a nicer way to represent ourselves which should be up soon.
I recommend Gravy's slogan. Its rather sterling. Perhaps you could add it over a picture of a kitten in a lolcat style, that'd get the kids interested.

In fact, you could have a picture of Santa giving presents to all the kids at christmas and it still wouldn't get away from the fact that this is an attempt to take the law into your own hands and its behaviour thats garnered immense disrespect towards certain commercially sponsored bodies.

In a time when Indie games are starting to break through into the mainstream, when publishers are sitting up and taking note of the talent on show in certain quarters of the indienets, magazines are finally reviewing our games, interviewing us and we're generating headlines, our games are getting out there and into the public consciousness - we're supposed to join a crusade against piracy that makes the RIAA seem sane?

Christ, we're meant to learn from the mistakes of the industry. We're supposed to be different, an alternative to all the marketing bullshit and pressures that come with parts of the industry. I don't see how this is going to help paint a prettier picture of the Indie scene. If anything, it makes us look like possessive money grabbing lunatics who haven't a fucking clue how the world and the internet works.
Some of the forums we go on (which is where we find most files) are blatant warez sites. They have forum topics like "Get Full Version of Game XYZ". The description in the post also tells you that it is an illegal pirate version. The replies to the post also show us that the link is for a pirated copy. We then inform the file sharing site that the file sits on AND we send a link to the actual developer or game company and inform them of what we're are doing.
Right, and the people frequenting these forums were going to buy the game anyway? Christ, I've seen big warez forums and they're mostly populated by kids unless you're heading into Chilean, Russian, Chinese or crackteam forums. In the same way I didn't give two fucks about copying a c90 full of Speccy games when I was a kid, they don't give a toss either about ripping a game off. But the clincher here is - they're not going to hand over their cash *anyway*.

If you start thinking of everything as a lost sale, then you're chasing your tail from here to kingdom come when you could be doing something more productive instead and you'll live a happier life with less frustration too.

Leave the heavyweight tactics, strong arming, moralising and pressure to the authorities and concentrate on doing what we do best. Making games.
StampOutPiracy.com is trying to get illegal game files removed for all indie devs and gaming portals. No one gets preference.
Y'see, thats what makes me really uncomfortable because I don't want you acting on my behalf, and I bet I'm not alone on this one. You don't represent the Indie community or all Indie devs, you represent a minute subset of developers and nothing more. It doesn't matter if you eventually get the backing of any of the major portals either - you still won't represent me and others like me. You only represent those that buy into the madness.
They were obvious warez sites with hundreds of game links and messages to some very big gaming companies basically saying "Fuck You, we'll carry on pirating your games and your lawyers can't do a thing". Funnily enough both sites are still operating.
And this is going to change with a moral strong arming campaign?
I'm also hoping that the site will educate people and developers can send their potential customers/visitors to our information pages to give them the facts about piracy.
I'd rather send any potential customers/visitors to a shop page where they can hand over some cash than foist some holier than thou information upon them. I'd rather work to give customers the incentive to buy a product, make them feel like their money was well spent. Make them think "hey, I'd buy from him again his game/service/attitude was great".

If my customers want to know the facts about piracy, they can watch an unskippable intro on a DVD or just roll up at the cinema or turn on ITV, or read the paper, or look at the internet. I have no intentions of ever trying to lay a guilt trip on them because thats as low as it gets.

Let your product be thy guide.


These pretty much sum it all up.
User avatar
oddbob0
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1727
Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2004 7:43 pm 0
Location: Liverpool

Post by oddbob0 »

Woah nelly!

Hey, I disagree with him and think its a misguided campaign (as you might have guessed by the overly verbose reply) but shit on a bike, I'm not going to go vigilante back on his ass because its something I disagree strongly over.

It doesn't make him Satan incarnate y'know. Just not a campaign I agree with. I'm not angry with the guy (just in case it came across that way), and certainly I don't think a character assassination is in order.

I don't think going psycho at him solves anything really, does it? It certainly doesn't help the discussion.
\m/
User avatar
CharlieF
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3020
Joined: Sun Mar 30, 2003 9:46 pm 0
Location: Lancashire, UK

Post by CharlieF »

I'd like to report the Llamasoft Lleague for promoting the misuse of copyrighted game images in their competitions and also http://www.llamascores.org for the distribution of said ROMS.

We need locking up - the lot of us.

Sorry for using your site as an example Muttley, but this really winds me up.

Incidentially I'm completely against piracy that would leave software developers, indie or otherwise losing revenue, but old ROMS?

Common sense must prevail.

/nips off for a game of Thrust to calm down...
User avatar
teamonkey
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12082
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
PSN: teamonkey_ca
Contact:

Post by teamonkey »

Kon-Tiki wrote:guff
Simple words please.
User avatar
HGFB
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 23575
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.

Post by HGFB »

teamonkey wrote:
Kon-Tiki wrote:guff
Simple words please.
He's Batman.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
User avatar
rockwaldo
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4096
Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2003 11:49 pm 0
Location: playing cricket in the street at 3am

Post by rockwaldo »

teamonkey wrote:
Kon-Tiki wrote:guff
Simple words please.
Kon-Tiki doesn't like the guy's aproach, twinned with what seems like a bit of a financial struggle to keep his free games site running means a rather angry Kon-Tiki.

It's all over nothing

The piracy site isn't targetting roms, it's targetting Warez forums and the like, which is a complete waste of time, but hey, it's his time.

That's how I see it anyway
So, you want to be an ARCADE champion BLOG to read. yay! [ http://www.arcadechampion.co.uk ]
User avatar
Kon-Tiki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5594
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 9:54 pm 0
Location: Inside my BO
Contact:

Post by Kon-Tiki »

1) He's proud of shutting other people's sites down, because they're offering pirated software or, and more importantly, unauthorized remakes of games
2) He puts unauthorized remakes on his site himself, but doesn't do snot about that
3) He claims he's trying to help the developers and gaming portals, but so far, he's been asking favours and forcing people to do stuff, while not giving anything in return.

I personally don't mind nr. 3 if it weren't for nr. 1 and 2, and I don't mind nr. 2 if it weren't for nr. 1. The fact that he's contradicting himself all the time in order to make himself seem like an innocent little angel only makes things worse. We seriously don't need another mobster like the RIAA, FAST, BREIN, SABAM or all the others. The only one of those I don't mind, is the ESA (former IDSA), as they actually tackle these things the right way: through conversation instead of bullying. We also don't need hypocrites. A combination of the two is about as bad as it can get, in my eyes. Best way to stop these is to hit them on the head as soon as possible, I think.

Edit: Oh, and there's no financial struggle for the site at the moment. It's just the principle of it all. Also, he's not just targeting warez, but also unauthorized remakes, as said before. That'll only damage indie games and sites like mine, and nobody'll gain anything from this.
User avatar
rockwaldo
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4096
Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2003 11:49 pm 0
Location: playing cricket in the street at 3am

Post by rockwaldo »

Kon-Tiki wrote:Edit: Oh, and there's no financial struggle for the site at the moment. It's just the principle of it all. Also, he's not just targeting warez, but also unauthorized remakes, as said before. That'll only damage indie games and sites like mine, and nobody'll gain anything from this.
Yeah, didn't mean that as a slur or anything - I just remember you posting a while back saying that you were looking for ways to make your free game site pay for itself as it was proving expensive.

The reason I mentioned it was in your defense by suggesting that you are angry at this guy because your site is exactly the sort of thing he professes to be helping.
So, you want to be an ARCADE champion BLOG to read. yay! [ http://www.arcadechampion.co.uk ]
User avatar
kalmar
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8293
Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2005 2:46 pm 0
Location: Fife

Post by kalmar »

Kon-Tiki is always angry. But, he does seem to have a point in this case :)
(just show, no stabby stabby)
Post Reply