merman wrote:1. The Coldplay comparisons are not fair on a band who have been around as long as Coldplay - the implication that a lot of writers make is that Athlete (and Snow Patrol) were trying to cash in Coldplay's success.
2. There's a lot of depth in that particular song, and it's very relevant.
Take all your chances while you can
You never know when they'll pass you by
Like a sum the mathematician cannot solve
Like me trying my hardest to explain
It's all about your cries and kisses
Those first steps that I can't calculate
I need some more of you to take me over
3. Richard Curtis is the one who chose to use the song, the first time a song has been used in that way in Who.
Coldplay have been around for 3 years longer.
Plenty of time for Athlete to appropriate their Radiohead lite stream of bland shite.
juice wrote:Without wanting to be critical of the band, the lyrics may have been relevant, but the switch from standard Dr Who background muzak to a pop-song stuck out like a sore thumb and was distracting enough to detract from the emotional impact of the scene...
mm... typical Merkin tactic, currently employed by Holby Casualty whatever.
I *was* dearly hoping I wouldn't hear Donovan at any point - that would have been too obvious - although some instrumental hint here and there would have done. But I'm with Juice n Captain on this one: if it's a genuinely moving scene, it shouldn't rely on music to create atmosphere.
(I don't remember music in Fireplace or the end of Library, yet they moved me).
Dungeon-Dave wrote:if it's a genuinely moving scene, it shouldn't rely on music to create atmosphere.
Sorry, what? Are you really implying that 'genuinely moving scenes' shouldn't have music?
Both of the scenes you allude to are drenched in music that runs continuously right until the end credits. Ah, I hear you say, but that's orchestral music composed specifically for that scene and not just some pop song slapped over the top, that's the difference. Well I think you'll find that the Englishman Danny Boyle may take umbrage with you on that point.
Personally, though I can't stand Athlete I think the song worked well enough in this context to add to the scene. For music, context is often key.
I may be wrong, but I think Dungeon Dave might be trying to convey that the scene was dominated by the song, rather than being complemented by it. I think there's a world of difference between specially composed music, a carefully chosen piece of non-original music and a song slapped over the top. For me, this particular instance was jarring, as the song itself was dominant - it didn't fit, for me personally. It was more like the laissez-faire attitude of Doctor Who Confidential where they slap a load of ill-fitting contemporary shite over the on-screen action.
You are right, for music context is often key. A masterly example of this, for me, is the use of Putting Out Fires by David Bowie in Inglourious Basterds. It should be jarring, but it isn't. It overscores the scene in a really surprising, brilliant way. I didn't know the song before I saw the film and I was actually astonished by its application. I'm sure some people probably thought that it was shit, though. I'm sure some people found the Athlete thing moving or elative but to me it is clinically depressing torpor, and not in a demented genius way either, which at least would have been fitting. All the subtlety and joy of the scene was drained by the insipid, dreary nature of the song. It was a cheap shot, rather like dubbing Phil Collins' Another Day In Paradise over the gassing scene in Schindler's List.
Murray Gold was not my favourite composer by a long chalk, but he's been largely brilliant this season and his score for Vincent and The Doctor was nicely subdued and moving. This is just the sort of scene he's very good at, and he should have been left to it.
And I couldn't care less what Danny Boyle may think, he's vastly overrated...
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.
Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
Dungeon-Dave wrote:if it's a genuinely moving scene, it shouldn't rely on music to create atmosphere.
Sorry, what? Are you really implying that 'genuinely moving scenes' shouldn't have music?
As The Captain said basically. I believe DD's saying that they shouldn't rely on music, certainly not that they shouldn't have it at all, and that's a crucial difference. Moving scenes and music are a sort of "team effort" I find.
And it should never get in the way of a good scene that stands up so extremely well on its own. Much like with the directing, sometimes it just has to get out of the way, be subtle, and complement the scene rather than dominating it. I would agree that it fell a bit too far into the dominating category. It was still an awesome scene though.
I actually thought the music fit quite well. Better than RTD's efforts at introducing pop music into the show, which really did stick out like sore thumbs. In this case tbh I probably wouldn't even have noticed it if I hadn't already read a review that complained about it.
The Captain wrote:It was a cheap shot, rather like dubbing Phil Collins' Another Day In Paradise over the gassing scene in Schindler's List.
Indeed, using Auschwitz to belittle of one of the worst atrocities in human history really would not sit right.
Lost half my morning cuppa to the keyboard because of this.
Zoot wrote:This. FFS - the first decent episode all series and you lot spend two or three pages arguing about music
Yes, it would be far more productive just to post 'that was good' or, more likely in your case 'that wasn't very good'. FFS sake right back at you. It's a discussion thread, if it doesn't matter to you move on, or at least post what you thought, don't have a go at people for chewing the fat on a forum, especially when you can't be bothered contributing properly yourself.
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.
Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
Yeah, that was rather good. Tyres screech on the corner that gets them into the plot in the first place, and a bit with the monster of the week too, but the rest was great.
Whatever crimes Curtis may have committed against filmanity, his deft humour showed through wonderfully here. I particularly loved the line about the suitcase and the screwdriver even though I now can't remember exactly what it was, very Blackadder-ish it seems (now I know who wrote it!)
Not been much mention of it, but I thought that the space chicken monster looked rather excellent - some nifty CGI, and it was reminiscent of Terry Gilliam's Jabberwock.
Does anyone know where this was filmed? It was entrancing snapshot into Van Gogh's world, realised with a lot of care.
Factory's no place for me, boss man leave me be.
Xbox Live Gamertag/PSN ID: Barbellion
Wii Console Number: 7017 0974 8271 2157
Dio wrote:Yeah, that was rather good. Tyres screech on the corner that gets them into the plot in the first place, and a bit with the monster of the week too, but the rest was great.
Whatever crimes Curtis may have committed against filmanity, his deft humour showed through wonderfully here. I particularly loved the line about the suitcase and the screwdriver even though I now can't remember exactly what it was, very Blackadder-ish it seems (now I know who wrote it!)
There was also the contrafibulator switch in the Tardis...