The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Ollie »

skip wrote:
Steve Dee wrote:Yes but
Spoiler: show
IF HE WAS IN THERE HE COULDNT HAVE GOT OUT TO TELL RORY TO LET HIM OUT, COZ HE WAS ALREADY IN THERE!! did he get out himself then? and if he perhaps had the time displacement vortex on his wrist, what did he activate it with??
I immediately thought "hmmm, that's a bit too much like Bill and Ted", but figured it would be explained properly at some point in the episode like the other paradoxes that occurred (and explained away rather well). It wasn't. Wibbly wobbly timey wimey and given the Doctor doesn't do time in a linear way notwithstanding, this was a stand out shit part...a bit lame in an otherwise decent episode.
I honestly don't see what the problem is. Nothing about that incident was self-contradictory - quite the reverse, in fact - and I can't see what was hard to understand about it. What do you think was missing from the explanation that was present with the other paradoxes?

In reply to Steve Dee's comment:
Spoiler: show
The Doctor that appeared at the start and told Rory to let him out of the Pandorica was the future Doctor, from a time after he had already been let out by Rory. Was it not clear, when they had that business in the museum with the mop and actually showed bits of that scene again, that that was what he was doing?
Why are you breaking my kayak?
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by zip accident »

Ollie wrote:I honestly don't see what the problem is.
Well, I haven't seen the episode, but from the descriptions of the event, the problem is:
Spoiler: show
How does the information that the doctor is in the box get out of the box? It gets out when the doctor gets out, and tells someone to let him out. The problem with that is, that if the information gets out when the doctor does, and he's let out because of it, then in some extra level of time, it got out before it got out. Which is illogical.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Absolute_Zero »

That the universe exists is a paradox... get animated about that. ;)
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

zip accident wrote:
Spoiler: show
How does the information that the doctor is in the box get out of the box? It gets out when the doctor gets out, and tells someone to let him out. The problem with that is, that if the information gets out when the doctor does, and he's let out because of it, then in some extra level of time, it got out before it got out. Which is illogical.
Spoiler: show
The information leak occurs because of the vortex manipulator. It was able to form a paradox that seemed stable. There might be an additional force outside of time, that allowed this change to happen in the time stream to stop it all collapsing. Or perhaps it was in the script, because Season 2 isn't going to happen with everything at an end!

The biggest issue I have with the episode is why the two Amys didn't react when they touched. The screwdrivers reacted badly when they came into contact. The universe was already on its way out, so I guess you couldn't break linear time any worse than it was in. And the Big Bang reboot fixed by wiping out the errors that had occurred and the primary cause that led to the TARDIS exploding.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Gorecki »

zip accident wrote:
Ollie wrote:I honestly don't see what the problem is.
Well, I haven't seen the episode, but from the descriptions of the event, the problem is:
Spoiler: show
How does the information that the doctor is in the box get out of the box? It gets out when the doctor gets out, and tells someone to let him out. The problem with that is, that if the information gets out when the doctor does, and he's let out because of it, then in some extra level of time, it got out before it got out. Which is illogical.
No, it got out after it got out. It also got out after it went in and went in after it got out. It really does make perfect sense. Would you like to know the time? I've got it written down on a piece of paper.

I bet James Cameron was never subjected to this level of inquisition.
Tang Sou!
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Ollie »

zip accident wrote:
Ollie wrote:I honestly don't see what the problem is.
Well, I haven't seen the episode, but from the descriptions of the event, the problem is:
Spoiler: show
How does the information that the doctor is in the box get out of the box? It gets out when the doctor gets out, and tells someone to let him out. The problem with that is, that if the information gets out when the doctor does, and he's let out because of it, then in some extra level of time, it got out before it got out. Which is illogical.
Ye Gods and little fishes. He's come from the bloody future, bringing information from the future with him. Considering that the programme very clearly showed precisely what happened and when, even providing whimsical visual cues for people who weren't paying proper attention, and that the one constant in the whole history of the programme has been that he travels in time, why is this so difficult to grasp?
Why are you breaking my kayak?
User avatar
Barney
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2131
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 7:59 pm 0
Location: UK, Broughton, Brigg

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Barney »

Ollie wrote:
zip accident wrote:
Ollie wrote:I honestly don't see what the problem is.
Well, I haven't seen the episode, but from the descriptions of the event, the problem is:
Spoiler: show
How does the information that the doctor is in the box get out of the box? It gets out when the doctor gets out, and tells someone to let him out. The problem with that is, that if the information gets out when the doctor does, and he's let out because of it, then in some extra level of time, it got out before it got out. Which is illogical.
Ye Gods and little fishes. He's come from the bloody future, bringing information from the future with him. Considering that the programme very clearly showed precisely what happened and when, even providing whimsical visual cues for people who weren't paying proper attention, and that the one constant in the whole history of the programme has been that he travels in time, why is this so difficult to grasp?
I think it's because a great many people cannot grasp anything that does not have a definite "start" and "end" point, with a logical sequence in between. It's just the way we're built. A few people can handle the non-sequential order of events in time, because for the Doctor they are in a logical sequence, but it's that lack of a starting point that they cannot grasp. Some of us have no problem accepting that some things are just circular and didn't start anywhere, and yet more things can be an open-ended sequence that didn't actually start anywhere either.

At least, that's what I reckon :)
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

Your right. The its not that people don't understand what was presented, its that its a self-causing event.

didn't bother me as-such.
"negative" paradoxes I don't like, but positive ones I can live with.

I would have liked some mention perhaps of those time-creature things we saw in the RTD era that pop up if you try to mess with your past though.
User avatar
arron
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7047
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 11:42 pm 0
Location: Here and Now

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by arron »

Barney wrote:
Spoiler: show
I think it's because a great many people cannot grasp anything that does not have a definite "start" and "end" point, with a logical sequence in between. It's just the way we're built. A few people can handle the non-sequential order of events in time, because for the Doctor they are in a logical sequence, but it's that lack of a starting point that they cannot grasp. Some of us have no problem accepting that some things are just circular and didn't start anywhere, and yet more things can be an open-ended sequence that didn't actually start anywhere either.
Spoiler: show
Someone with a lot more knowledge on the subject described time as a white board. Most people will write on the white board from left to right, because that's how most people see a white board from working, but it can develop content in any direction who understands how to use a whiteboard properly. And some people have a board cleaner, so they can rub bits out and then replace them with new scribblings. Some people use a permanent marker by mistake, so you can't change what has been written on it, but you might be able to write around it.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
User avatar
Kelloggs
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1859
Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 11:38 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: TheAntiKelloggs
Location: Widnes or Altrincham. Take your pick.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Kelloggs »

Darkflame wrote:I would have liked some mention perhaps of those time-creature things we saw in the RTD era that pop up if you try to mess with your past though.
Reapers. Possibly they (will have) no longer existed by that point.

I liked it, and I think we've now got a slightly more capable helmsman that RTD was (and, incidentally, one who it appears is on no way afraid of actually using Time Travel as part of a story - for a series about a time traveller, I think that's a Good Thing) but I have to admit to a small concern.

The ends of the last three seasons have all seen reality destroyed-but-for-the-Doctor. The Daleks' Reality Bomb; the Time Lords' plan for ascension to beings of pure intellect (accidentally destroying Time in the process) and now a TARDIS on overload. (And I'm still not convinced that we've discovered what actually caused the cracks, if the TARDIS' exploding fixed them, and we've been explicitly told that we don't know why the TARDIS exploded in the first place. The crack/TARDIS interaction is the only paradox I can spot, and it didn't carry over into Universe 2 anyway.) So I think the message I would send down the timeline to next year's finale is... can we blow up something slightly smaller than existence, please? Because, plot-wise, that's a very small corner to have got ourselves painted into.

As I say, other than that (and it's a really minor niggle, in the scheme of things) and the Amelia/Amy contact not destroying the universe all on its own, I'm perfectly happy with the hithertofore-undiscovered realization of a thing for certain Scottish redheads...
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

For those familiar with the (first two) Terminator films, think of it like this:
Someone wrote:The Future Is Not Set, There Is No Fate But What We Make For Ourselves.
Who, in the universe of those films, first made that statement?

(With thanks to Gorecki).
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by phattslagg »

It always amuses me to see people complaining about time-based paradoxes, having been perfectly happy to accept the whole premise of time-travel as a story device; a concept which has paradox at its very core. The Doctor travels through time and space in a box which is bigger on the inside, for goodness sake - half the fun of this kind of thing is in trying to get your head around the unresolvable paradoxes :)
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

phattslagg wrote:It always amuses me to see people complaining about time-based paradoxes, having been perfectly happy to accept the whole premise of time-travel as a story device; a concept which has paradox at its very core.
Not really.
Time Travel does not require paradoxes, and you see excuses developed in other films to avoid them. (Parralle universe's being created, or "solid" pasts which can not change, or self-correcting timelines wheres its all the same in the end, etc).
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

Darkflame wrote:
phattslagg wrote:It always amuses me to see people complaining about time-based paradoxes, having been perfectly happy to accept the whole premise of time-travel as a story device; a concept which has paradox at its very core.
Not really.
Time Travel does not require paradoxes, and you see excuses developed in other films to avoid them. (Parralle universe's being created, or "solid" pasts which can not change, or self-correcting timelines wheres its all the same in the end, etc).
That would depend upon one's definition of a 'paradox'. Time travel involves seeming paradoxes which nonetheless can be logically possible. Predestination is just one example.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Cloudane »

Anyone remember that thing with David out of Eastenders and Kochanski out of Red Dwarf?

That was a good way of handling time travel. Cannot change the past, no matter how hard you try, and they demonstrated it pretty well in some places.

Who has always been about the ride though. Stop taking it so seriously ;)
Post Reply