Get your Wii out!
I've had mine for quite a couple of weeks now, so I should be able to give an objective answer.mamemeister wrote:So can I ask all those Wii owners a question.
You've all had your new machine for 24hrs, please be honest with yiour answer, do you see it as a genuine revolutionary step forward in video gaming or is it a pleasant novelty experience that'll fade away over time?
Come on, honestly here although I'd understand If its too early to ask that question.
First, I'm going to agree with PumaG about the split controller. It really is genius, and it really does feel great to hold. The general layout of the controller is great too. Your fingers fits comfortably over the primary buttons (A, B, Z, C, analog stick) and the secondary buttons (1,2,+,-) are accessible without too much hand jiggery. Also, the HOME and POWER buttons being ... "dug in" so that they are hard to press is another ingenius piece of design.
The next great thing about the controller is the pointer. I can honestly say I see more potential in the pointing device than I do the motion sensing controls. I don't think it was exploited enough in Zelda (as Bubba said, you can't point at someone & click A to talk to them) but the potential for it is *huge*. Aiming at things in Zelda feels great, especially since I've never been able to work the twin-analog sticks ... I've been a PC gamer for years, and the pointer on the Wii feels much closer to the mouse than an analog stick could ever hope to be.
As for the actual motion sensing controls, they're really cool, but it really depends on how they get used. Zelda uses it very simply (waving the Wiimote to attack and flicking the nunchuck to do a spin-attack). It works, and it works wonderfully. I have a feeling though, that anything more complicated than that isn't going to work for gamers both old and new. For me, I already kinda noticed the limitations in Wii Sports, where boxing didn't really feel like boxing, because once I started boxing fast enough, it wouldn't pick up all my moves.
So is it a revolutionary experience? Yes, yes it is. Every other console game I've played has left me staring/aiming at the floor!
SiN
Think that was more a limitation in the game design, even things it would pick up no problem (eg, just a forward/back punch), seemed to have a "speed limit".For me, I already kinda noticed the limitations in Wii Sports, where boxing didn't really feel like boxing, because once I started boxing fast enough, it wouldn't pick up all my moves.
I dont see any hardware reason for this...judgeing by the pc hack, the data comes in pretty fast, and that movement would have made clear spikes.
Camera, Gun, and Movement should all be controlled completely independantly.piku wrote:Does it mean we're soon at a point where FPS games won't have the gun glued to the player's chest? All joypads should have tilt sensors in them as well.
Just like in real life.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Oh, absolutely. I think the hardware is more than up for the challenge, I just don't think the programmers are.Darkflame wrote:Think that was more a limitation in the game design, even things it would pick up no problem (eg, just a forward/back punch), seemed to have a "speed limit".
I dont see any hardware reason for this...judgeing by the pc hack, the data comes in pretty fast, and that movement would have made clear spikes.
The problem with "gesture" based games is that it never picks up the gestures perfectly, and sometimes, it picks up the wrong gesture. Black & White, Darwinia and even Brain Age all suffered from this a bit. I think that if Wii games use gestures too extensively, they will suffer as well.
And I don't even think it's a programmers problem exclusively, as some of the blame lies with the user. The user "draws" these gestures out poorly and the game has to compensate for that. Pushing a button is pushing a button, so there's no way a user can screw that up ... you either push it or you don't. But with gestures, there's a huge margin of error, and it's critical that the game handles this well.
Hopefully, Flabio will be around shortly to rant about gestures in B&W2.
SiN
There's an interesting first impressions thread over at NTSC-UK where a few people think it's not so great (lack of software, some control issues, gimmicky), but most seem pretty happy with it.mamemeister wrote:So can I ask all those Wii owners a question.
You've all had your new machine for 24hrs, please be honest with yiour answer, do you see it as a genuine revolutionary step forward in video gaming or is it a pleasant novelty experience that'll fade away over time?
Come on, honestly here although I'd understand If its too early to ask that question.
- Bubba
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10013
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
- PSN: BubbaFatAs
- Location: Cambridge
As a Wii control sceptic, I must say I'm suprised. The pointer works suprisingly well. It does have a tendancy to "fall off the screen" which is rather annoying, but I guess is just part of the getting used to it stage. The nunchuk on a cord thing is just silly. *Everyone* here who picked up the controls asked why it was wired. I'd expect there to be 1st party wireless nunchuk and sensor bars within the next few months. The nunchuk is a work of ergonomic genius and fits beautifully in your hands. However, the Wiimote isn't quite as good (but a lot nicer than I thought it would be to hold for a few hours). The system is really nice, although I have had at least one crash where it just sits at a solid black screen at which point you have to unplug it from the wall as none of the buttons do anything! The net connectivity was a lot better than the DS - didn't have to do any channel hopping, although it has crashed our wireless router at least once (which is a first!).
Really nice UI, although it's a shame you can't multitask with it (send a message while in a game etc) and entering friendcodes without keyboard support is annoying. As will be web browsing... Still, it's a decent input method, and the pointer controls really work.
I just wish the console had a little more grunt, and the remote had another button or two. Zelda has already irked me somewhat after I managed to use all my lantern fuel by accident because of the "real time weapons change" feature to accomodate only having one "use things" button. But still, it's early days. Not convinced it represents the paradigm shift in gaming that some think it does (and honestly the sixaxis may be a better pad for some specific games because of the additional buttons and more traditional layout) but it sure is fun, and titles like Zelda show that it can do proper games too, and isn't just good for minigames. I guess it's up to gamedevs now, as it'll get pretty old pretty quickly if *every titles* is full of mini games.
Cheers
Bubba
Really nice UI, although it's a shame you can't multitask with it (send a message while in a game etc) and entering friendcodes without keyboard support is annoying. As will be web browsing... Still, it's a decent input method, and the pointer controls really work.
I just wish the console had a little more grunt, and the remote had another button or two. Zelda has already irked me somewhat after I managed to use all my lantern fuel by accident because of the "real time weapons change" feature to accomodate only having one "use things" button. But still, it's early days. Not convinced it represents the paradigm shift in gaming that some think it does (and honestly the sixaxis may be a better pad for some specific games because of the additional buttons and more traditional layout) but it sure is fun, and titles like Zelda show that it can do proper games too, and isn't just good for minigames. I guess it's up to gamedevs now, as it'll get pretty old pretty quickly if *every titles* is full of mini games.
Cheers
Bubba
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
I've had this twice now in the Wii OS, both times when entering or leaving the Mii channel, I was thinking it might be hanging on something network related. Not quite sure how the power system works (red/orange/green) but holding down the console power button for a few seconds seemed to sort it out both times for me without the need to go to the wall socket.Bubba wrote:I have had at least one crash where it just sits at a solid black screen at which point you have to unplug it from the wall as none of the buttons do anything!
Also, just been mucking around, I was wrong about the pointer thing in Zelda.
I thought it was the other way due to the early puzzle in the jail where it says something about pointing at distant people to talk to them or somesuch.
Oh and Midna's a cunt!

Last edited by disciple on Sun Dec 10, 2006 4:00 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
- benedictw
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6012
- Joined: Thu Mar 25, 2004 3:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CoderBen
- Location: Poole, UK
- Contact:
For peeps on HDTV's and composite you might find that 480i may give you a better image than 576i. YMMV etc.
I could do with a IR bar that is larger (more distance between the two IR emitters) - sitting on my sofa in the gameroom the pointer gets a bit jumpy back there. I ought to get some 'third party wireless IR emitters' (candles) and do some experimentation.
In some way, Wii Play should've been the packin - because its more tutorial based - but putting Wii Sports as the packin was genius because its lured people into a sports genre that wouldn't normally touch it with a bargepole plus its 'infected' non-gamers who might be more sports friendly.
I could do with a IR bar that is larger (more distance between the two IR emitters) - sitting on my sofa in the gameroom the pointer gets a bit jumpy back there. I ought to get some 'third party wireless IR emitters' (candles) and do some experimentation.
In some way, Wii Play should've been the packin - because its more tutorial based - but putting Wii Sports as the packin was genius because its lured people into a sports genre that wouldn't normally touch it with a bargepole plus its 'infected' non-gamers who might be more sports friendly.
Gamertag\PSN: CoderBen
How can anyone hate Midna? She's just so adorable! 
I'd complain about using the wrong item in Zelda, but I just managed to kill myself with in another game using a traditional controller by the classic method of forgetting which button does what, so I can hardly fault the Wii remote. I find Zelda has a perfectly logical layout when I remember which bit does what, and my only real complaint is lack of on-the-fly camera controls. That's a pretty big issue for me in most 3D games, I drive people nuts by how I'm constantly panning the camera around.
James
I'd complain about using the wrong item in Zelda, but I just managed to kill myself with in another game using a traditional controller by the classic method of forgetting which button does what, so I can hardly fault the Wii remote. I find Zelda has a perfectly logical layout when I remember which bit does what, and my only real complaint is lack of on-the-fly camera controls. That's a pretty big issue for me in most 3D games, I drive people nuts by how I'm constantly panning the camera around.
James
- Atty
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2289
- Joined: Thu Oct 03, 2002 10:11 am 0
- Location: Currently sitting on my arse.
I assume they didn't go with a wireless nunchuck because you'd then have to put batteries in both the wiimote and the 'chuck (plus any other addons that happen along), which would be a bit of a nightmare in something like Zelda if your 'chuck batteries died but the wiimote batteries kept going. Not to mention that you'd effectively double the amount of bluetoothington wavesly that would be floating through the air to your Wii, which seems to have enough problems with interference as it is.
Ever since I saw that seperate product that company was making that was like the wiimote, but instead of using IR it used ultrasonic wossname for figuring out it's relative position onscreen (out at the end of '07, I've heard), I've been wondering if, assuming the technology could be reimplemented without breaking whatever copyright they have, or maybe if Nintendo could strike up a deal or something, there's nothing to stop a Wii lite coming out at some point that used Ultrasound instead of IR. Since it's just used to tell the position of the pointer, the Wii would be none the wiser and Ultrasound wouldn't have the problem of interference of sunlight, reflections, pointing too low, etc.
Ever since I saw that seperate product that company was making that was like the wiimote, but instead of using IR it used ultrasonic wossname for figuring out it's relative position onscreen (out at the end of '07, I've heard), I've been wondering if, assuming the technology could be reimplemented without breaking whatever copyright they have, or maybe if Nintendo could strike up a deal or something, there's nothing to stop a Wii lite coming out at some point that used Ultrasound instead of IR. Since it's just used to tell the position of the pointer, the Wii would be none the wiser and Ultrasound wouldn't have the problem of interference of sunlight, reflections, pointing too low, etc.
Last edited by Atty on Sun Dec 10, 2006 12:36 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Straight Outta Trumpton.
- PVB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 32542
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 10:16 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: PVBuk
- PSN: PVBuk
- Location: Medway, U.K.
It's not been started yet, but here's a report about it:oxo wrote:Did I read somewhere you can exchange Nintendo Stars for Virtual
Console points? Because I can't for the life of me figure out where
that is on the Ninty site or how to do it
When you first log on to the Wii Shop with your new console, you'll be asked to "link your account" to the one you have with Nintendo-Europe.com.
"By linking your Wii Shop Channel account to your online Nintendo membership, you will be able to enjoy additional benefits in the near future," the website explains.
"Not only will you then be able to purchase Wii points in the Stars Catalogue, you will also get Stars for your Virtual Console purchases upon completing a small survey."
Stars are points redeemed by using codes included with Nintendo software sold in the UK. You get some with the Wii itself, too.
You do realise you can map 3 items/weapons to the d-pad don't you?Bubba wrote:I just wish the console had a little more grunt, and the remote had another button or two. Zelda has already irked me somewhat after I managed to use all my lantern fuel by accident because of the "real time weapons change" feature to accomodate only having one "use things" button.
I'm guessing you've tried setting the sensitivity on the Wii console settings? My pointer was pretty jerky on the lowest setting but is solid as a rock since when sensitivity is turned up a bit.benedictw wrote:I could do with a IR bar that is larger (more distance between the two IR emitters) - sitting on my sofa in the gameroom the pointer gets a bit jumpy back there. I ought to get some 'third party wireless IR emitters' (candles) and do some experimentation.
I like it but getting the feeling I have only brought a party only console though. Amazing fun in multilayer , a bit boring on your own.
Zelda is quite disappointing me at the moment not exactly revolutionary and the motion sensitive is not really adding much to the game in terms of game play fun.
After playing a good bout on the wii I played gears of war on 360 then rr on the ps3. Both was a far more rewarding solo experience.
Glad I have a wii for kids and party stuff , but for a console I would play on my own I'll stick with the other generation.
Really looking forward to the second wii generation to see what Nintendo can really do.
Zelda is quite disappointing me at the moment not exactly revolutionary and the motion sensitive is not really adding much to the game in terms of game play fun.
After playing a good bout on the wii I played gears of war on 360 then rr on the ps3. Both was a far more rewarding solo experience.
Glad I have a wii for kids and party stuff , but for a console I would play on my own I'll stick with the other generation.
Really looking forward to the second wii generation to see what Nintendo can really do.
"Don't move, you're surrounded by armed bastards " DCI Gene Hunt. 




