Apologies for jumping to conclusions then, but it certainly didn't read that way.GeeZa wrote:I was actually very calm when I wrote that, almost zen-like in my peace with the world.
This comment was unfair, but I was excited having just had a blinding experience with the Wii, far better than I had initially expected. And in the 10 minutes that I gave it during this time, all I saw was a few beginning scenes and more than a little in common with Shadow of the Colossus (I'm particularly thinking of the bridge scenes here). We probably played through to the goat herding bit but no further because it's not much of a party game, and when there's 10 or so people waiting to play Tennis or boxing then it has to take a sideline.GeeZa wrote:If someone wades in and describes a key game as being ;very very ugly"
Ok, I'll cover both of these but it'll have to wait - I've got an awful lot of work on at the moment, so me time is somewhat limitedGeeZa wrote:or "souless" or "decidedly average"
Ok, I'll sit down and write a detailed evaluation of what I see as the graphical strengths and weaknesses, both in art direction and technical implementation. But it'll be a "watch this space" affair as I simply don't have the time to start writing this until other deadlines have been met, and personal stuff at home dealt with. I'm more than willing to engage in discussion on this matter, and am equally pleased that you are. As long as it doesn't deteriorate into personal attacks (which whether intended or not was what your post felt like), then hopefully this will be constructive for both of us.GeeZa wrote:So come on Bubba, let's end this and let's see your articulation and comparisons for your dislike of the visual direction. Be as flowery with language and as lengthy as you want to be, I'm intruiged why your opinion is at variance with many others. Go for it!
Cheers
Andrew



