Mark wrote:
I found it dull. I thought the characters were often lovely (Alyx is ace, and despite having a small part, Dog stole the show), but the background graphics were generally bland. They recreated the reality of large parts of a run-down Eastern Europe as best they could. Great. I've always wanted to wander around starkly realistic Polish slums. Oh hang about - no I haven't.
It's really not my week for graphics debates is it?
Damn, the Eastern European flavoured sections were stunning I thought, it was like exploring Chernobyl.
I'd really like to do that - only for real . I guess I just don't go for the recreation of reality in videogames.
My most common problem is that a large number of videogames look like they could be set in Catford, or Hull, or Slough - and that just bores me. A shedload of games feature places that look like locations within a ten-minute walk of me - only not as good obviously. I live there already - why recreate it?
HL2 at least moved that to Eastern Europe, but still - a crap hotel or garbage-strewn back alley out there is much like one over here. As I said - I loved the entrance to the city it had a definite "militarised zone" feel to it. But beyond that it generally became way too functional for me. Rusty pipes in a drainage ditch - again! Woo hoo! Now we're partying!
Having re-read my original post though I think it didn't come across quite as I'd intended. I think the graphics are very accomplished for the most part - they just accomplish something I'm not too fussed about. It just seems so sober, for the most part. I've taken pictures out of the window of my flat that look more visually interesting than a lot of HL2 screenshots (and I live opposite an old folk's home).
My abiding memory of the look of the game is of concrete and rust and greyness, and that's just not what I want in a game, basically.
Heh heh - I wish I saw that out of my window - much more my kinda thing.
As an aside though - after posting my last post I tried to think of my favourite game visually, and I haven't come up with an answer yet. Rez springs to mind (specifically the boss of level 1, or maybe level 4 - the greeeny-orangish one), but I'm not sure that would be my answer. Hmmm - tricky.
I know what you're saying Mark and I think you're being honest rather than deliberately awkward. The whole 'realism' thing runs and runs and for me it *only* works if the team behind it is world class. Valve undoubtedly are. I absolutely loved HL2 visually, every part of it and I was pleased to see that the Episodic content if anything improved on it slightly. It's really all about the small details for me, City17 reminded me of Minsk in its bleak and oppressed decay. Fantastic.
If it comes out on the PS3 or 360 and runs like a monster PC then I'm going to be very tempted to play it all over again. Especially if the Episodes will be available too. Then we get into the KBAM debate, hurrah!