The Dr Who thread
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
The overnight ratings are available
1 …. 11.4 (46.6%) …. The Vicar of Dibley (21:30) BBC1
2 …. 10.7 (44.0%) …. EastEnders (21:00) BBC1
3 …. 9.6 (39.8%) …. Coronation Street (20:00) ITV
4 …. 9.2 (44.3%) …. EastEnders (18:30) BBC1
5 …. 8.7 (37.0%) …. Doctor Who (19:00) BBC1
6 …. 8.4 (37.7%) …. Little Britain Abroad (22:30) BBC1
7 …. 7.3 (30.3%) …. Strictly Come Dancing Christmas Special (20:00) BBC1
8 …. 7.2 (30.6%) …. Emmerdale (19:00) ITV
9 …. 6.8 (34.8%) …. Strictly Come Dancing (18:15) BBC1
10 … 6.7 (35.0%) …. BBC News and Weather (18:00) BBC1
11 …. 5.7 (42.3%) …. The Queen (15:00) BBC1
12 …. 5.3 (22.2%) …. Doc Martin (21:00) ITV
13 …. 5.1 (32.0%) …. Monsters, Inc (15:45) BBC1
14 …. 5.1 (29.0%) …. My Family (17:15) BBC1
15 …. 4.8 (27.2%) …. Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (16:00) ITV
16 …. 4.7 (25.4%) …. BBC News; Regional News; Weather (23:00) BBC1
17 …. 4.5 (21.3%) …. ITV News; Weather (18:45) ITV
18 …. 3.6 (25.8%) …. The Green Green Grass (15:00) BBC1
19 …. 3.3 (18.7%) …. ITV News; Weather (23:00) ITV
20 … 2.9 (27.0%) …. Top of the Pops Christmas Special (14:00) BBC1
My bag is called Mr Shitface
- matt303
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4219
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 3:37 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: matt303uk
- Location: Derbyshire
It was an ok bit of Christmas afternoon fun but as Who it was a bit lacking. The main problem for me was it felt like they'd brainstormed a lot of action TV set pieces without putting too much thought into the underlying story. So it was fun to watch but didn't leave you with anything to ponder and no urge to watch it again.
Still about a billion times better than Torchwood.
Still about a billion times better than Torchwood.
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Sure, some enormous plot-holes, but still good fun. Tate was fine - not outstanding, but fine.
Scared my 4yr old shitless - so much so, she refused to watch the last 10 minutes, and consequently has been badgering me ever since as to how the Doctor beat the baddie
For me, though, the mere mention of the word 'Torchwood' made me lose my concentration in a moment of extreme cringe. I really wish it would just go away - I mean, it's entirely possible for something never to have existed in this, isn't it?
Scared my 4yr old shitless - so much so, she refused to watch the last 10 minutes, and consequently has been badgering me ever since as to how the Doctor beat the baddie
For me, though, the mere mention of the word 'Torchwood' made me lose my concentration in a moment of extreme cringe. I really wish it would just go away - I mean, it's entirely possible for something never to have existed in this, isn't it?
I thought it was ace. ACE I tells ya.
Tate improved dramatically (in both senses) during the hour, and by the end I was genuinely wishing she'd said 'yes' when asked.
The Docs' face as he was wiping out the Children of Rachnos was another glimpse into the dark shadow of Timelord fury, and as Bog said, it's rare the mere mention of another worlds' name will send a chill up my spine. It's funny, because as a child Gallifrey was just where Timelords lived to me. Now it looms larger in my and the Who-Universe consciousness, as a serious place to be a long way away from if you were doing something that would - or even might - piss the Timelords off. It's now also associated with Something Bad Happening (i.e. the Time War) and thus any Timelord left alive (one, that we know of) is to be respected and very likely feared if you're up to no good.
The motorway scene was my least favourite part - nice FX, but definitely aimed at the kids. Overall, I enjoyed this episode a lot, and despite the odd slip-up (e.g. that 4000-mile-deep hole neither looking very deep, nor spouting magma) I was firmly in grin-mode by the end.
The S3 trailer rocked. The Torchwood trailer rocked (and I'll now be watching all the ones I recorded, as it dropped out of my 'must-see' list after about episode 4). The SJS trailer rocked. Hell, even if it sucks primetime ass, it's got Liz Sladen in it, and That's Enough For Me.
Oh, one final thought - do you think the Daleks knew about the Rachnos ship at the Earths' core when they drilled their own hole and wanted to drop a bomb down it?
EDIT:
Tate improved dramatically (in both senses) during the hour, and by the end I was genuinely wishing she'd said 'yes' when asked.
The Docs' face as he was wiping out the Children of Rachnos was another glimpse into the dark shadow of Timelord fury, and as Bog said, it's rare the mere mention of another worlds' name will send a chill up my spine. It's funny, because as a child Gallifrey was just where Timelords lived to me. Now it looms larger in my and the Who-Universe consciousness, as a serious place to be a long way away from if you were doing something that would - or even might - piss the Timelords off. It's now also associated with Something Bad Happening (i.e. the Time War) and thus any Timelord left alive (one, that we know of) is to be respected and very likely feared if you're up to no good.
The motorway scene was my least favourite part - nice FX, but definitely aimed at the kids. Overall, I enjoyed this episode a lot, and despite the odd slip-up (e.g. that 4000-mile-deep hole neither looking very deep, nor spouting magma) I was firmly in grin-mode by the end.
The S3 trailer rocked. The Torchwood trailer rocked (and I'll now be watching all the ones I recorded, as it dropped out of my 'must-see' list after about episode 4). The SJS trailer rocked. Hell, even if it sucks primetime ass, it's got Liz Sladen in it, and That's Enough For Me.
Oh, one final thought - do you think the Daleks knew about the Rachnos ship at the Earths' core when they drilled their own hole and wanted to drop a bomb down it?
EDIT:
WTF? Your house - your rules, mate. Send the guests to the garden, or upstairs, or their car, or just plain fucking home. The day anyone comes into my home and tells me what I can and can't watch in their presence is the day they send my encapsulated ashes skyward.Viscount Charles wrote:Cunting fucknuts. My 4-year old daughter was in tears, and frankly I'm not much better off, because we're not allowed to watch Doctor Who. Brother- and sister-in-law are round, and don't think it's suitable for their little one.
Last edited by Istar on Tue Dec 26, 2006 2:26 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
I am one. Yeah, they're not canon, but it's an interesting question nonetheless.matt303 wrote:Istar wrote:Oh, one final thought - do you think the Daleks knew about the Rachnos ship at the Earths' core when they drilled their own hole and wanted to drop a bomb down it?
ssshhhh Best not talk about the films with Who fans around
That just about sums it up for me, I hate to say. I actually deleted the last 4 or so episodes of series 2 (apart from the finale) from the tivo without watching them. I find that very sad.I guess I'm just drifitng away from new-Who because I'm just not that interested anymore.
The only thing really **good** about the new Who have been the choices of the Doctor and the fact that it seems to have given the BBC a renewed faith that Science Fiction shows can be successful. Of course they are now flogging a dead horse with that one (I mean a Sarah-Jane spin off - come on - they tried that once before (and failed) when it would have actually meant something - you're about 20 years too late their BBC!).
There's been a couple of unequivocally good shows spread amongst the two series. There have been some great moments now and again too - usually spoiled a few minutes later by something equally as daft.
I know it's Who and we all love Who because of what it means to our Childhood but if you take off the rose (no pun intended) tinted glasses and actually look at the new Who with an unbiased eye you'd have to myopic to think it was great. The new Battlestar Galactica is "great".
I also, against my better judgement, watched the season 2 finale on Friday. It's indicative of the whole current series that they could turn a Dalek / Cyberman war (a total nerd-nirvana moment that had me smiling like a kid at Christmas with anticipation when the Daleks came out of the void ship) into a total non-event. At least they got rid of the Tyler family and f*cking Mickey. They were a theme that re-curred a little too often for my tastes. Their removal means I'll keep at least half an eye on season three. The Gallifrey development sounds interesting... But I'm a bit wary of getting my hopes up based on the last couple of seasons...
"Only way to feel the noise is when it's good and loud"
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dalek_ ... n_of_Earthmatt303 wrote:Istar wrote:Oh, one final thought - do you think the Daleks knew about the Rachnos ship at the Earths' core when they drilled their own hole and wanted to drop a bomb down it?
ssshhhh Best not talk about the films with Who fans around
No need to hide. It's all real
My bag is called Mr Shitface
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
What is it with you lot and the insults? It keeps cropping up but why is it that if you don't like something then everyone else who likes it is wrong? Can't you keep that crap over in the Dancing about forum where it belongs?Sargie wrote:I know it's Who and we all love Who because of what it means to our Childhood but if you take off the rose (no pun intended) tinted glasses and actually look at the new Who with an unbiased eye you'd have to myopic to think it was great.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
I thought the Dancing About forums were for things you liked? This is the "Doctor Who thread". Surely NOT liking the new Doctor Who is an equally valid topic of conversation as universally praising it and all of its spinoffs?What is it with you lot and the insults? It keeps cropping up but why is it that if you don't like something then everyone else who likes it is wrong? Can't you keep that crap over in the Dancing about forum where it belongs?
I am sure if I made another thread (the "I don't think the new Doctor Who is as good as it could be thread"?) I'd get directed to put my comments in this one instead.
Also - you called my comments "Crap" which, I suppose, is equally as "insulting" as saying anyone who thinks the new Doctor Who is great is myopic. You should practice what you preach. Also, Just because you like it, does that mean everyone who doesn't like it is wrong?
C'mon mate - I share your enthusiasm for Doctor Who, but are you honestly telling me that you think this new incarnation stands up to the best of what has gone before in Who or the best of contemporary television (in any genre)?
"Only way to feel the noise is when it's good and loud"
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Oh. If you can take the fact that I don't like new Doctor Who out of the equation (which is kind of hard because part of my "attitude" (whatever that means) is negative because of my feelings towards the show) I am coming across as overtly cuntish? - Because that isn't the intention.I thought he was calling your attitude crap, not your opinions...
My intention is display my disappointment in new Doctor Who - something (if you check the thread back) that I have been "dealing with" (outside of when I read this forum I think about it very little
"Only way to feel the noise is when it's good and loud"
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
I quoted again since you ignored it the first time. Have all the opinions you like just feel free to expect some flack when you decide that having other opinions makes someone "myopic". That's what I was getting at. Not the fact that you don't like Doctor Who. The little issue of insulting people who do like it.I know it's Who and we all love Who because of what it means to our Childhood but if you take off the rose (no pun intended) tinted glasses and actually look at the new Who with an unbiased eye you'd have to myopic to think it was great.
Get it now?
My bag is called Mr Shitface


