Harlequin wrote:Let us see. I count...
28 episodes; 23 stories: 1 story set in contemporary Cardiff; 1 in period Cardiff;
Wasn't the
whole series filmed in Cardiff? I think this is where the Cardiff thing is coming from.
Harlequin wrote:4 in contemporary or near future London, of which 1.5[*][/size] were in the vicinity of the Powell Estate; 2? in alternative Londons (if Father's Day did, indeed, take place in a London); 2 in period London; 2 Christmas specials set in multiple locations including London.
I switched off shortly after series 1 so can't comment on series 2. In series 1 you're looking at half the episodes being based on a council estate in present day London (or London alike) with fucking Jackie and twatting Mickey.
Whether this is too much I guess is open to debate but this was a big factor in me switching off. This along with the repeated council houses/flat setting, the celebrity thing, Peter Kay, the Big Brother references, Weakest Link (better). It was like they were going through prime time telly, picking out popular stuff and shoehorning them in. Yeah if we make it like Eastenders with Peter Kay ad Big Brother in there too it'll be fucking great! I think all it was missing was a guest appearance from Ant and Dec!!
But y'know Dr Who is now popular, it has two spin offs so obviously they're doing something right. I think it's just I'm not too keen on primetime telly, but I guess I'm in the minority there.
I guess while we're on the topic (I'm sure this will be unpopular) but if I'm honest I also found Captain Jack rather annoying too!
Harlequin wrote:That does not seem too bad to me, especially considering all of those Pertwee years with no traveling through time or space at all.
Never really watched any Pertwee ones, presumably being base on Earth was down to lack of budget? Was it shit then?
Harlequin wrote:disciple wrote:it was like watching an episode of fucking Eastenders, not cutting edge British sci-fi!!
I certainly prefer this to the Eastenders-in-space that is
Battlestar Galactica.
To be honest I can't really see the similarities there but each to their own.
Harlequin wrote:disciple wrote:One thing though, as I say I haven't seen many of the episodes in with the new Doctor whatshisname in it. But judging from the Christmas episode Dr Who seems to be more about people and characters and emotion than sci-fi.
Yes, this is what has revitalised the series, allowing it to appeal to a wider audience than the over-30-year-old fanboys at whom the old series eventually seemed to be aimed.
Yes this is what I was getting at originally. Specifically regarding what the lack of science hints at.
Harlequin wrote:Hardly any old Who made me whoop with joy and no episode ever made me cry.
Tosh and Bollocks!
Harlequin wrote:disciple wrote:What science there is in there seem to be quickly brushed over and never really explained in any depth. Any science seems to be quickly pulled from a hat then just as quickly discarded. Not sure if this is a good thing or not, maybe it's intentional on the part of the writer, maybe it hints at why they seem to very rarely leave the East end of London.
This is not hard Science-Fiction (as if
Doctor Who ever was after 1964); it is action-adventure SciFi, fantasy with Science Fiction dressings. What matters is not the details but the emotional flow. C.f. Joss Whedon.
Give me a Western set in Space over an Eastenders set in um..... the Eastend, any day!
Regarding the science and logic in Dr Who, it kinda reminds me of those rubber snakes you get in cheapo B movies. The hero grabs hold of it, shakes it around quickly so folks can see but can't actually get a close look, then a second or two later throws it off camera where it's never seen again!
It's like the writers have a fear of it, I think
they think it puts people off (and they may be right). I think they think the science and logic is a big turn off for primetime viewers so they brush over it and instead focus on TARDIS car chases and fast paced action and more emotive stuff. It's like sci-fi without the sci!