I think less bad will come from his swift execution.Yak wrote:
Would more good (or less bad) have come from letting him languish in prison rather than be executed?
NSFW : Saddam - Only hours to go
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
I think the problem is that someone like Saddam could have worked ill from prison - rallying family and other supporters to continue Bastardy in the outside world, and all the cockamamie cheap-airport-thriller crap that he always seemed to be a fan of.Yak wrote:But did his death achieve anything *good*?
Death engenders death, and to some he'll now be a martyr.
Would more good (or less bad) have come from letting him languish in prison rather than be executed?
I worry that you have a point. There are days when I'm very glad to be just a pixel-pusher, of no relative import in this sort of thing.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
That Saddam used chemical weapons in 1988 doesn't mean they existed in 2003.mattley wrote:This is where I'm still puzzled about the "Anti war because Saddam never had WMD" lobby. We might not have found them, but we sure as hell know he had them, for two reasons.gravy wrote:it brings up awkward questions about who supplied the expertise and weapons used in the atrocity.
Among other countries that'd be us and the US.
1. He used them.
2. We have copies of the delivery notes.
Years of weapons inspectors crawling all over Iraq, a huge effort by the US to find illegal weapons subsequent to the invasion... pretty conclusive, no?
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
Well, no. He used 'em all. As Mattley quite rightly said, we knew he had chem and bio weapons because we sold them to him. He didn't have any left because he murdered so many of his own people with 'em.Absolute_Zero wrote:That Saddam used chemical weapons in 1988 doesn't mean they existed in 2003.
Years of weapons inspectors crawling all over Iraq, a huge effort by the US to find illegal weapons subsequent to the invasion... pretty conclusive, no?
*sighs*
The reasons given for invading Iraq were utterly, utterly suprious. They made zero sense, none whatsoever. It was utterly criminal that Blair and Bush did what they did. Did Saddam Hussein deserve to be toppled, tried and hanged? Well, I think so. Was the post-September 11th period callously used as an excuse for Dubya to shout "I'll git 'im for ya, Daddy!" and go kick off our very own little Viet Nam? Absolutely. Was it immoral the way it was done? Without a shadow of a doubt.
As someone said - shit sandwich. And as Dio quite rightly says, we're at 50% Grey and Holding. :/
However, all the complexity and fucktardery aside... It leaves the world a tiny bit cleaner that someone so loathsome's stopped using the same O2 as the rest of us. That's my particular opinion, I think I've expressed it enough for one day.
Peace to us all, this turbulent New Year's Eve Eve.
That was one sad piece of film. Yes he was a nasty brutal dictator, but could they, at least, have done it in open air, maybe a drum-roll or something too.Matrixxx wrote:![]()
This looked just undignified and crap, a bunch of masked men in a dank cell somewhere underground. No-one seemed to be in charge, just a mess like the whole war.
Hrmph.
Last edited by Orava on Sat Dec 30, 2006 10:50 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Holier than thou
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
I hope you're right.mattley wrote:I think less bad will come from his swift execution.Yak wrote:
Would more good (or less bad) have come from letting him languish in prison rather than be executed?
Whilst I'm no fan of capital punishment, I won't be shedding any tears over Saddam, that's for sure.
And to be frank - I don't think things could be any worse with regard to our standing in the Arab world right now, regardless.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
It's worth noting that UNMOVIC wasn't satisfied with Iraq's response lateAbsolute_Zero wrote:That Saddam used chemical weapons in 1988 doesn't mean they existed in 2003.mattley wrote:This is where I'm still puzzled about the "Anti war because Saddam never had WMD" lobby. We might not have found them, but we sure as hell know he had them, for two reasons.gravy wrote:it brings up awkward questions about who supplied the expertise and weapons used in the atrocity.
Among other countries that'd be us and the US.
1. He used them.
2. We have copies of the delivery notes.
in 2002. They believed that Iraq hadn't properly accounted for its stock
of VX, that Iraq had a discrepancy of 6,500 chemical bombs from the Iran
Iraq war, several thousand chemical rockets were found which weren't
accounted for, 8,500 litres of a biological warfare agent, 650 kg of
bacterial growth media, and missile programmes testing beyond the
permitted range.
If Saddam's regime had truly committed to verifiable disarmament in
the first place he may not have avoided war but it'd have left the US
and UK without any plausible justification.
Saddam and the Iraqi government did have questions that needed
answering. Quite why the fucked around through to the start of the
war until it was too late I've never understood, unless Saddam was
betting on the Iraqi army defeating the US army. An even worse
possibility is that Saddam wanted an outcome like current events all
along. i.e. He couldn't win but a Baathist government may rule the
Sunni third of a post civil war Iraq.
Of course the exact composition, funding and support of the insurgency
is not clear, it'll be a long time if ever before we know how much the
old regime is responsible for current events.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Just to keep this factual, like, most of his chemical arsenal was deployed in the Iraq/Iran war... not against the poor citizens of Halabja.Bog wrote:Well, no. He used 'em all. As Mattley quite rightly said, we knew he had chem and bio weapons because we sold them to him. He didn't have any left because he murdered so many of his own people with 'em.Absolute_Zero wrote:That Saddam used chemical weapons in 1988 doesn't mean they existed in 2003.
Years of weapons inspectors crawling all over Iraq, a huge effort by the US to find illegal weapons subsequent to the invasion... pretty conclusive, no?
*sighs*
Daddy was against.The reasons given for invading Iraq were utterly, utterly suprious. They made zero sense, none whatsoever. It was utterly criminal that Blair and Bush did what they did. Did Saddam Hussein deserve to be toppled, tried and hanged? Well, I think so. Was the post-September 11th period callously used as an excuse for Dubya to shout "I'll git 'im for ya, Daddy!"
and go kick off our very own little Viet Nam? Absolutely. Was it immoral the way it was done? Without a shadow of a doubt.
As someone said - shit sandwich. And as Dio quite rightly says, we're at 50% Grey and Holding. :/
However, all the complexity and fucktardery aside... It leaves the world a tiny bit cleaner that someone so loathsome's stopped using the same O2 as the rest of us. That's my particular opinion, I think I've expressed it enough for one day.
Peace to us all, this turbulent New Year's Eve Eve.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
I'm not questioning the doubts, virtually every western agency thought that Saddam was in possession. But, if a US that was desperate to locate 'em for justification sakes, couldn't find 'em, then it's fairly safe to assume that they didn't in fact exist... at that time, any more.Kemper_Boyd wrote: It's worth noting that UNMOVIC wasn't satisfied with Iraq's response late
in 2002. They believed that Iraq hadn't properly accounted for its stock
of VX, that Iraq had a discrepancy of 6,500 chemical bombs from the Iran
Iraq war, several thousand chemical rockets were found which weren't
accounted for, 8,500 litres of a biological warfare agent, 650 kg of
bacterial growth media, and missile programmes testing beyond the
permitted range.
If Saddam's regime had truly committed to verifiable disarmament in
the first place he may not have avoided war but it'd have left the US
and UK without any plausible justification.
Saddam and the Iraqi government did have questions that needed
answering. Quite why the fucked around through to the start of the
war until it was too late I've never understood, unless Saddam was
betting on the Iraqi army defeating the US army. An even worse
possibility is that Saddam wanted an outcome like current events all
along. i.e. He couldn't win but a Baathist government may rule the
Sunni third of a post civil war Iraq.
Of course the exact composition, funding and support of the insurgency
is not clear, it'll be a long time if ever before we know how much the
old regime is responsible for current events.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
That's very probably correct, though it can't entirely be dismissed thatAbsolute_Zero wrote:I'm not questioning the doubts, virtually every western agency thought that he had them... in fact comically, Saddam thought that he did possess a small number of chemical weapons. But, if a US that was desperate to locate 'em for justification sakes, couldn't find 'em, then it's fairly safe to assume that they didn't in fact exist.
what remained was hidden for later use, but it still doesn't explain what
motivated Iraq or more precisely Saddam to screw around with the
inspections. Why would you give your enemy an excuse to attack?
Unless you wanted them to do so. Did Saddam really want a place in
history as having died fighting the US, or amidst a civil war?
Gadaffi on the other hand after 9/11 opened up discrete contacts with
the UK, reveals a nuclear programme, agrees to disarm and is now
off the US goverment's shit list. You can argue about the rights and
wrongs but I bet the average Libyan isn't worrying about a US invasion
or attack.
Another thing Iraq has shown is that intelligence about WMD programmes
is far more difficult than previously believed. Who knows what we don't
know about...
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
If I had to guess: pride.Kemper_Boyd wrote: That's very probably correct, though it can't entirely be dismissed that
what remained was hidden for later use, but it still doesn't explain what
motivated Iraq or more precisely Saddam to screw around with the
inspections. Why would you give your enemy an excuse to attack?
[...]
Well, you probably don't want to pay heed to drunks known as curveball, or anyone that may be telling you what you want to hear, for their own self-served interests.Another thing Iraq has shown is that intelligence about WMD programmes is far more difficult than previously believed. Who knows what we don't know about...
Yeah. He is gone to see Elvis.snaff wrote:I think killing is wrong, especially of a foe who is already subdued and the whole thing is sad, but I also believe that he is in a better place now where life's veil of confusion has dropped away and we are all perfect souls, united in oneness with God.
?
Holier than thou
Saddam is dead. Probably a good thing for Iraq. The fact that he was toppled, not by Iraqis, but by US+UK+miniscule insignificant others is definitely not a good thing.
Yes, it was an Iraqi court. Might as well have been a kangaroo court for what we saw of the proceedings.
Oh well, it's done now. We'll see what happens.
Yes, it was an Iraqi court. Might as well have been a kangaroo court for what we saw of the proceedings.
Oh well, it's done now. We'll see what happens.



