It's true that killing Saddam will prevent him from doing the same to anyone else in the future - as it would for anyone else, but it's not inevitable that he would kill again if he was kept alive. In fact there's always the possibility that he would help become part of the solution instead of the problem.Muphex wrote:Even if letting a guilty man live will lead to the loss of innocent life? (not being an arse just looking for some philosophical nourishment).
NSFW : Saddam - Only hours to go
- supermonkeyworld
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2191
- Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
- Location: UK
- supermonkeyworld
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2191
- Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
- Location: UK
I disagree (and both arguments are valid).tufty wrote:But letting Saddam live, banged up for life, as opposed to killing him would be unlikely to cause deaths; indeed, it would stop him being a martyr for those that still follow him. And it wouldn't look like a US-staged election of another country's ex-leader, either. You know, the sort of thing that is likely to be used by other sick fuckers to cause kids to want to strap dynamite to themselves and set it off in crowded places. Not that they wouldn't do that anyway, but hey.Muphex wrote:Even if letting a guilty man live will lead to the loss of innocent life? (not being an arse just looking for some philosophical nourishment).
Saddam as of 24 hours ago had as much potential for causing massive death (or even minor death) as I do, probably much less. The same can't be said for, for example, George Bush.
Simon
His trial for each charge would have lasted for years and years if not decades giving him to opportunity to spout propoganda from the courtroom which as we saw previously gets lapped up and reported by the news media agencies. In my opinion this keeps him very much in the forefront for those that follow him and those that might in another generation. As long as he was alive in the minds of his followers he was still the president of the country and a prisoner of war. Now there is no doubt at least that he is no longer the leader of the country.
Yes the trial was a complete American lead sham and everyone knows it but far if he lived we would have had him in the worlds faces for years and years and that would have aggrivated the whole arab/western thing seeing his face everyday.
Don't get me wrong in general I am opposed to the death penalty I just think this is an extenuating case(and I know philosophically you'd need to define a line between a suspected and convicted serial killer (who could be innocent) and Saddam (who I suppose could theoretically be innocent in some way) but hey I can't).
"Have a good time all the time" - Spinal Tap
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
Optimism's great. I love optimism. If it wasn't for my own innate optimism that we, as a species, will eventually make things better rather than worse I wouldn't bother getting out of bed in the morning, let alone working my nipples off 28 hours a day.supermonkeyworld wrote:But whilst there's still a possibility it's better to be optimistic than not, isn't it?Bog wrote:Yeah, and I might split a hydrogen atom by waving a knife around - not very bloody likely, mind.
Gotta balance it with a jot of realism, mind.
- supermonkeyworld
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2191
- Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
- Location: UK
- supermonkeyworld
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2191
- Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
- Location: UK
- Darth Bungle
- Baaa!

- Posts: 437
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 1:17 pm 0
- Location: Chicago
I think this quote sums up how I feel about the event.
"Saddam's execution was no victory for people outside the Washington D.C. imperial elite. There is no doubt that Saddam was guilty of great crimes, and any truly independent tribunal would have found him undeserving of retaining his liberty. A victory for the world public would have been a judgment requiring Saddam to reveal all the details of his career, during the course of a lifetime imprisonment. Historians and prosecutors in many countries would work from this record to winnow the truth from the lies, and to then enable the many agencies making up our international system of justice to pursue other perpetrators implicated in the tale.
"The quick execution of Saddam Hussein is not simply "victor's justice," it is a demotion in a Mafia-style re-organization, the elimination of capo fallen from grace, to protect the power elite from any exposures that would threaten its control."
http://www.counterpunch.org/garcia12302006.html
"Saddam's execution was no victory for people outside the Washington D.C. imperial elite. There is no doubt that Saddam was guilty of great crimes, and any truly independent tribunal would have found him undeserving of retaining his liberty. A victory for the world public would have been a judgment requiring Saddam to reveal all the details of his career, during the course of a lifetime imprisonment. Historians and prosecutors in many countries would work from this record to winnow the truth from the lies, and to then enable the many agencies making up our international system of justice to pursue other perpetrators implicated in the tale.
"The quick execution of Saddam Hussein is not simply "victor's justice," it is a demotion in a Mafia-style re-organization, the elimination of capo fallen from grace, to protect the power elite from any exposures that would threaten its control."
http://www.counterpunch.org/garcia12302006.html
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
I do my best, and stick by what I've deduced from my senses and best available intelligence until I've got a convincing reason to change my mind, at which point I like to think I change my mind and let go of the old theory with proper scientific detatchment.supermonkeyworld wrote:Can you trust yourself as an objective judge of reality? I certainly can't with mine.Bog wrote:Gotta balance it with a jot of realism, mind.
It might be hubris, but at least I'm open to the possibility that it will be hubris.
Then again, I push pixels and design apps for a living. What I do has little to no effect on the wellbeing of anyone.
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
A lot of mobile phones have video capability these days. As to "how was someone able to bring such a device to the proceedings".... well, nobody really seemed to give a shit as long as he went up the long ladder and down the short rope.Sir_LANs-a-lot wrote:Can someone tell me how a mobile phone was able to film the execution?
- supermonkeyworld
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2191
- Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
- Location: UK
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
That's a conversation I've had a thousand times, and it comes down to one thing - either you accept complete personal responsibility for your life and your actions, or you declare that you're not capable of taking that responsibility. Every person is capable of ending life - whether through drunk driving or deliberately wreaking havoc on another. That, my dear chap, is an objective fact. You can either 'fess up and say "Yeah, I guess I'm human after all" or subscribe to some other sort of doctrine where you pretend the last 20 million years of evolution, of humanity clawing it's bloody-toothed way up the food-chain, didn't happen.supermonkeyworld wrote:So I guess what you're saying is you know enough, and consider yourself rational enough to make a judgement call over whether a person dies if they have committed acts which violate certain natural laws?
*shrugs*
I believe that it is wrong to ever initiate force, but that if force has been inflicted on one by some immoral or incompetent other that it is wrong to merely curl up into a ball and hope the force-inflictor goes away.
- supermonkeyworld
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2191
- Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
- Location: UK
Absolutely, we all have the potential to kill, and I don't think any evolutionary biologist would disagree that Homo sapiens sapiens success of mastering it's environment is due to it's fantastic ability of exercising force with extreme prejudice. But just because our own natural history is littered with the corpses of those who who didn't make the grade, this doesn't give us licence to take away another persons life - even in the name of "justice". You can either accept that it is wrong to murder or not, if you accept this simple truth then there is no 'grey area' open for debate because the right to live is an essential natural law which applies to everyone, if it isn't then the world isn't a fit place to live.Bog wrote:Every person is capable of ending life - whether through drunk driving or deliberately wreaking havoc on another. That, my dear chap, is an objective fact. You can either 'fess up and say "Yeah, I guess I'm human after all" or subscribe to some other sort of doctrine where you pretend the last 20 million years of evolution, of humanity clawing it's bloody-toothed way up the food-chain, didn't happen.
I'm can fairly confidently say that Islamic fundamentalists see things in exactly the same way.Bog wrote:I believe that it is wrong to ever initiate force, but that if force has been inflicted on one by some immoral or incompetent other that it is wrong to merely curl up into a ball and hope the force-inflictor goes away.
I feel I absolutely can argue that point of view. Not every argument has to be based in hard evidence for it to be valid indeed we have a whole art form based on informed supposition it's called philosophy (of which I am pleased to say I was a pupil at university).supermonkeyworld wrote:I honestly don't think you can argue that keeping him alive will cause more people to die as a result, apart from the moral objection there's no evidence to support that would be the case.Muphex wrote:I disagree (and both arguments are valid).
How the hell could you ever make a decision on any future event if there was no historical evidence of an exactly similar situation together with the consequences of making a decision both one way or the other. All we can do is look at the current situation and make a decision based on what we know NOW.
Is Saddam guilty of the crimes for which he was sentenced (lets say yes to this for the purpose of the this argument - we could argue this point but I think most rational people will accept that he is indeed responsible). Two are Saddamms supporters currently murdering forces and innocents in protest at his arrest - yes.
Saddam is still seen as the deposed leader of the country (which in fairness he is if we are being pedantic) but more importantly he is seen by these people as still being the countries rightful leader, just a prisoner of war. As long as he is given a soapbox to stand on in court as he slowly gets tried over the next couple of decades the less chance Iraq has for peace and the more vitriol he is allowed to spew stirring up what is already and extremely delicate position between the west and the Arabic nations. Lets face it this is why he has been got rid of after the first trial. He's been found guilty by jury (satifies most nations notion of justice) for a crime punishable by death in the country that tried him lets get rid of him pronto.
As far as the whole whats the difference between the state murdering one person versus one person murdering another goes I've always thought it a ridiculous argument. Do you acept that it is wrong for me to detain you against your will in my cellar? Yes I think most people would but that's what the state does everytime it sentences someone to a period in jail. Just as everyman has the right to life doesn't everyone have the right to their freedom? Where do you draw the line exactly, should the state not have the right to imprison someone for murder because it deprives them of a god-given right?
Whats the difference then between imprisonment as a deprivition of rights and execution? Because you are depriving them of more? If we accept that the term in prison reflects the seriousness of the crime then surely this should apply to all crimes. Well under current British Law if you murdered say 20 people you'd be unlikely to ever get out so as Saddam'regime was responsible for about 600k deaths he gets the other 599980 foc does he? When does the scale stop being applied?
Sorry had a few beers thi sevening already so a lot fo this might not be very joined up and there are probably large holes in a few arguments that i might patch up tomorrow when I am a little clearer of mind.
"Have a good time all the time" - Spinal Tap
