NSFW : Saddam - Only hours to go

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
supermonkeyworld
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2191
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
Location: UK

Post by supermonkeyworld »

Muphex wrote:Whats the difference then between imprisonment as a deprivition of rights and execution?
If you agree that taking away somebody's life is wrong, which Saddam is surely guilty of, then taking his life away from him in the name of justice is pure hypocrisy. By killing a murderer, the state becomes as guilty as those it attempts to bring to justice.
Muphex
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 775
Joined: Sun Oct 03, 2004 9:22 pm 0

Post by Muphex »

supermonkeyworld wrote:
Muphex wrote:Whats the difference then between imprisonment as a deprivition of rights and execution?
If you agree that taking away somebody's life is wrong, which Saddam is surely guilty of, then taking his life away from him in the name of justice is pure hypocrisy. By killing a murderer, the state becomes as guilty as those it attempts to bring to justice.
And byt he same token if you agree that false imprisonment and kidnap is wrong then how is state sanctioned imprisonment right?
"Have a good time all the time" - Spinal Tap
User avatar
supermonkeyworld
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2191
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
Location: UK

Post by supermonkeyworld »

Muphex wrote:
supermonkeyworld wrote:
Muphex wrote:Whats the difference then between imprisonment as a deprivition of rights and execution?
And byt he same token if you agree that false imprisonment and kidnap is wrong then how is state sanctioned imprisonment right?
Well imprisonment isn't always justified, but just because people serve life sentences, sometimes even for crimes they aren't guilty for, doesn't mean it gives us licence to kill somebody. To be honest I think the difference between imprisonment and execution is quite clear, one of them involves staying around on planet earth and the other doesn't.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Muphex wrote:
supermonkeyworld wrote:
Muphex wrote:Whats the difference then between imprisonment as a deprivition of rights and execution?
If you agree that taking away somebody's life is wrong, which Saddam is surely guilty of, then taking his life away from him in the name of justice is pure hypocrisy. By killing a murderer, the state becomes as guilty as those it attempts to bring to justice.
And byt he same token if you agree that false imprisonment and kidnap is wrong then how is state sanctioned imprisonment right?
Imprisonment is removing dangerous people from society to prevent repeat crimes, kidnapping is not the same as impisoning a kidnapper so SMWs comment still stands.
Muphex
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 775
Joined: Sun Oct 03, 2004 9:22 pm 0

Post by Muphex »

Old_but_still_a_kid wrote:
Muphex wrote:
supermonkeyworld wrote:
Muphex wrote:Whats the difference then between imprisonment as a deprivition of rights and execution?
If you agree that taking away somebody's life is wrong, which Saddam is surely guilty of, then taking his life away from him in the name of justice is pure hypocrisy. By killing a murderer, the state becomes as guilty as those it attempts to bring to justice.
And byt he same token if you agree that false imprisonment and kidnap is wrong then how is state sanctioned imprisonment right?
Imprisonment is removing dangerous people from society to prevent repeat crimes, kidnapping is not the same as impisoning a kidnapper so SMWs comment still stands.
No absolutely not.

From a purely semantic point of view the argument SMV's argument goes like this:

Murderer kills, killing is wrong, state killing the killer is hypocrisy (his words probably spelt wrong its late)

Following that argument to it's logical conclusion:

Kidnapper removes someones liberty and imprisons them against their will, state does the same to kidnapper, state is hypocratic in it's actions as it mimics the original crime.

I should point out at this point that I am acting as pedant in the argument, but the argument presented is flawed in it's logic.
"Have a good time all the time" - Spinal Tap
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Post by zip accident »

supermonkeyworld wrote:

then taking his life away from him in the name of justice is pure hypocrisy.
Note the time, I'm not sober. :D

Eh? What do you mean by justice?

http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loi_du_Talion I don't know why that's not available in English.

Maybe Britannica will do better:

http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-9071046/talion

That was the first time the state took justice out of the hands of the vendettaists.

If you don't think justice is about revenge, then what is it about?

Rehabilitation is a fine idea, but I think many people will tell you it's not justice.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
supermonkeyworld
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2191
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
Location: UK

Post by supermonkeyworld »

zip accident wrote:
supermonkeyworld wrote:

then taking his life away from him in the name of justice is pure hypocrisy.
Note the time, I'm not sober. :D

Eh? What do you mean by justice?
If you're going to start picking apart words and discussing semantics then this discussion will go on for a long time. The word 'justice' was used by a top Iraqi official to describe the hanging of Saddam Hussein.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle ... 221481.stm

So I completely fail to see how my original statement could fail to be incorrect.
User avatar
supermonkeyworld
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2191
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
Location: UK

Post by supermonkeyworld »

Muphex wrote:Murderer kills, killing is wrong, state killing the killer is hypocrisy (his words probably spelt wrong its late)

Following that argument to it's logical conclusion:

Kidnapper removes someones liberty and imprisons them against their will, state does the same to kidnapper, state is hypocratic in it's actions as it mimics the original crime.

I should point out at this point that I am acting as pedant in the argument, but the argument presented is flawed in it's logic.
You're assuming that imprisoning somebody for kidnapping is perfectly analogous to executing somebody for murder, it isn't because I'm making the very important assertion that everyone has the right to live, which does not apply in the former example. I believe the right to live is an essential natural law which should not be broken regardless of the circumstances. Asserting that law to be true and then breaking it yourself is hypocrisy and makes you guilty of the same crime. In your example on kidnapping this does not apply because nobody directly loses their life as a result, therefore no natural law was broken.
offyoutoddle
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
Location: London
Contact:

Post by offyoutoddle »

In the spirit of pendantry, you could say the right to freedom is a natural law that was broken.

However, I'd just like to make it clear that this is all merely wanking with words. It seems fairly obvious to me that the difference is that if you get it wrong with the death penalty, whooops sorry isn't going to cut it. At least if you get it wrong with a life sentence, it is not quite so final (although still pretty nasty).
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
User avatar
supermonkeyworld
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2191
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2004 12:11 am 0
Location: UK

Post by supermonkeyworld »

offyoutoddle wrote:In the spirit of pendantry, you could say the right to freedom is a natural law that was broken.
Just because you are held at Her Majesty's pleasure (for example), does not mean you don't enjoy certain freedoms and rights. For example you can't be forced in to slavery or subjected to cruel or degrading punishment. These are certain freedoms which we enjoy whilst being imprisoned, 'right to freedom' does not mean you will never serve a prison sentence for an act the state finds abhorrent, it means you enjoy certain rights if you are, such as the right to live for instance.
offyoutoddle
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
Location: London
Contact:

Post by offyoutoddle »

supermonkeyworld wrote:
offyoutoddle wrote:In the spirit of pendantry, you could say the right to freedom is a natural law that was broken.
Just because you are held at Her Majesty's pleasure (for example), does not mean you don't enjoy certain freedoms and rights. For example you can't be forced in to slavery or subjected to cruel or degrading punishment. These are certain freedoms which we enjoy whilst being imprisoned, 'right to freedom' does not mean you will never serve a prison sentence for an act the state finds abhorrent, it means you enjoy certain rights if you are, such as the right to live for instance.
as I said, spirit of pedantry. Devils Advocate. Your arguements could be said to be an interpretation as some will not agree on your definition of right to freedom or crule or degrading treatment.

FWIW, I happen to agree with you SMW.
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Muphex wrote:His trial for each charge would have lasted for years and years if not decades giving him to opportunity to spout propoganda from the courtroom which as we saw previously gets lapped up and reported by the news media agencies. In my opinion this keeps him very much in the forefront for those that follow him and those that might in another generation. As long as he was alive in the minds of his followers he was still the president of the country and a prisoner of war. Now there is no doubt at least that he is no longer the leader of the country.
I see where you're coming from, but now, surely, he was the leader of a country that was illegally invaded by the evil americans, had it's government removed and its people killed by the infidel invader, and who was finally executed at the request of same to boost the polls.

I mean, that's how it looks from France, fuck knows how it's being spun in middle-eastern mosques.

As for "spouting propaganda" - don't forget that for a long time he was "our man in the middle east", someone who thought he could get away with anything as long as he kept out the mad mullahs. And we the west didn't do anything to disavow him of that thought; we kept supplying him with weapons and technology.

Simon
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Post by Absolute_Zero »

tufty wrote:
Muphex wrote:His trial for each charge would have lasted for years and years if not decades giving him to opportunity to spout propoganda from the courtroom which as we saw previously gets lapped up and reported by the news media agencies. In my opinion this keeps him very much in the forefront for those that follow him and those that might in another generation. As long as he was alive in the minds of his followers he was still the president of the country and a prisoner of war. Now there is no doubt at least that he is no longer the leader of the country.
I see where you're coming from, but now, surely, he was the leader of a country that was illegally invaded by the evil americans, had it's government removed and its people killed by the infidel invader, and who was finally executed at the request of same to boost the polls.

I mean, that's how it looks from France, fuck knows how it's being spun in middle-eastern mosques.
That would partly depend on whether the mosque is Sunni or Shiite.
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

Absolute_Zero wrote:
I mean, that's how it looks from France, fuck knows how it's being spun in middle-eastern mosques.
That would partly depend on whether the mosque is Sunni or Shiite.
That's certainly how it used to be, yes. But even the radical Shiites stood up against the invasion of Iraq; the conflict between two branches of the same religion[1] is replaced by a clash of Muslim vs Christian, of White vs Arab, of infidels and unbelievers.

Anyway, it doesn't matter if you suddenly change tack as long as the malleable fanatics don't realise. Tell any old pack of lies, but tell it convincingly, if there is some germ of truth in both you can slip it past the unquestioning, unwashed masses without even breaking a sweat.

Same deal as "Saddam is our friend, leader of a stable secular state" becoming "Saddam is a foaming-at-the-mouth genocidal maniac, funding terrorists[2] and with the ability to strike London with this WMDs at 40 minutes notice" overnight.

Simon

[1] Yes, I know that this is a gross oversimplification, and that the gaping chasm between Sunni and Shiite is extremely difficult to "paper over".
[2] See again Sunni vs Shiite and Saddam's relationships with *actual* fundamentalist terrorist groups.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
Orava
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12698
Joined: Sat Mar 13, 2004 12:13 am 0
Location: The West Country

Post by Orava »

Hmm. Not sure the title was worth the (enforced) NSFW, the picture was widely published in today's papers. Front page on Guardian actually.

Never mind, someone might have got upset or something.

My apologies for any Saddam fanciers.
Holier than thou
Post Reply