MacWorld - San Francisco 2007 : Maccies unite here.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
You have a choice of:
1. An underpowered Mac mini. Nice and small. Decent CPU,
low end in every other way. It would be better if it was big
enough to have a 3.5" drive.
2. iMac, good but the disadvantages of a desktop combined
with the disadvantages of a laptop. If it's a good idea why are
there so few PC AIOs? It would be better if it was big enough
to take the higher power of Conroe.
3. Mac Pro, dual Woodcrest FB-DIMM, the upgradable machine.
Great hardware but at a price level that is above what most
people will pay to be able to upgrade or tinker.
It's odd that Apple have given up on a sector that used to be a
big part of their product range.
Few are asking for a beige tower. I'd like something pizza box sized,
easy to open, upgradable with desktop components. Stick Conroe
in it. It doesn't have to be cheap, just sensibly priced for what you get.
I think Apple should carry on making the other machines but there
is a demand for an xMac, read some Mac forums if you doubt this.
If it kills sales of the other models so be it, in the long run it's better
to make what people want than not. I think many Mini users would
trade up, some iMac users would trade down, overall I think it would
balance out. The Mac Pro would probably lose the most sales, but it's
not a big seller anyway. Better to lose some Mac Pro sales and have a
machine that the average Windows user can buy to replace their current
PC.
Mac laptops sell well in part because they are similar to and competitively
priced with PC laptops. Apple's desktop line-up is quite different from
most PC desktops offered, and it has a gaping hole. Fix it.
1. An underpowered Mac mini. Nice and small. Decent CPU,
low end in every other way. It would be better if it was big
enough to have a 3.5" drive.
2. iMac, good but the disadvantages of a desktop combined
with the disadvantages of a laptop. If it's a good idea why are
there so few PC AIOs? It would be better if it was big enough
to take the higher power of Conroe.
3. Mac Pro, dual Woodcrest FB-DIMM, the upgradable machine.
Great hardware but at a price level that is above what most
people will pay to be able to upgrade or tinker.
It's odd that Apple have given up on a sector that used to be a
big part of their product range.
Few are asking for a beige tower. I'd like something pizza box sized,
easy to open, upgradable with desktop components. Stick Conroe
in it. It doesn't have to be cheap, just sensibly priced for what you get.
I think Apple should carry on making the other machines but there
is a demand for an xMac, read some Mac forums if you doubt this.
If it kills sales of the other models so be it, in the long run it's better
to make what people want than not. I think many Mini users would
trade up, some iMac users would trade down, overall I think it would
balance out. The Mac Pro would probably lose the most sales, but it's
not a big seller anyway. Better to lose some Mac Pro sales and have a
machine that the average Windows user can buy to replace their current
PC.
Mac laptops sell well in part because they are similar to and competitively
priced with PC laptops. Apple's desktop line-up is quite different from
most PC desktops offered, and it has a gaping hole. Fix it.
LC-Mac...Kemper_Boyd wrote:It's odd that Apple have given up on a sector that used to be a big part of their product range.
I'd buy whatever came out, but would prefer something cubey with a smaller footprint. Pizza box was good when there was a CRT to shove on top of it, but these days, anything with depth would be annoying.
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
LCs were quite popular if I recall correctly. 
Anyway my pet theory about why Apple isn't worrying about xMacs and
other geek things is that they think we are moving into a post-PC world.
One where applications and data should be available and synchronised
across all the computers you use, and as transparently as possible.
The Mac may well cease to be but live on within future iPods, iTVs, iPhones
and any other device that will have tens of billions of transistors.
For example if the iTV does run OS X embedded and takes off like the iPod
then soon the majority of 'Macs' would be iTVs. All the other forms would be
small niches in comparison. If you are planning on that you probably wouldn't
be worrying about xMacs.
Anyway my pet theory about why Apple isn't worrying about xMacs and
other geek things is that they think we are moving into a post-PC world.
One where applications and data should be available and synchronised
across all the computers you use, and as transparently as possible.
The Mac may well cease to be but live on within future iPods, iTVs, iPhones
and any other device that will have tens of billions of transistors.
For example if the iTV does run OS X embedded and takes off like the iPod
then soon the majority of 'Macs' would be iTVs. All the other forms would be
small niches in comparison. If you are planning on that you probably wouldn't
be worrying about xMacs.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
Ignoring the details this is the form factor I'd like to see. I've a Razr
and the two bits are about as thin as a Nano but the hinge is on the top,
when opening it up I've thought for a long while that they could stick a
usable screen and thumb-board in it if the hinge was on the side.
The external screen and a few keys would serve well enough for day
to day music listening or making calls. When you want to text or surf
you'd flip it open and use the big screen and thumb-board.
Nice to see a render of this idea. It'd be right up my street assuming
it's not OMFG expensive.

and the two bits are about as thin as a Nano but the hinge is on the top,
when opening it up I've thought for a long while that they could stick a
usable screen and thumb-board in it if the hinge was on the side.
The external screen and a few keys would serve well enough for day
to day music listening or making calls. When you want to text or surf
you'd flip it open and use the big screen and thumb-board.
Nice to see a render of this idea. It'd be right up my street assuming
it's not OMFG expensive.

- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10448
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
That would be lovely and exactly what I want. But no one has solved the form factor and a qwerty keyboard yet and they have been trying for a while.Kemper_Boyd wrote:Ignoring the details this is the form factor I'd like to see. I've a Razr
and the two bits are about as thin as a Nano but the hinge is on the top,
when opening it up I've thought for a long while that they could stick a
usable screen and thumb-board in it if the hinge was on the side.
The external screen and a few keys would serve well enough for day
to day music listening or making calls. When you want to text or surf
you'd flip it open and use the big screen and thumb-board.
Nice to see a render of this idea. It'd be right up my street assuming
it's not OMFG expensive.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10448
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Apple's current range is what is stopping me buying a Mac.
The mini is underpowered for it's price, and getting an iMac to me is a waste of a monitor. If I want the best iMac I have to get a 23" Monitor. A lot of the cost is tied up in the monitor. Don't mind that too much, but the fact it is useless if I upgrade makes me mind very much indeed!
A mini, with 1GB of RAM and a Core 2 at the current base price could tip me over the edge.
The mini is underpowered for it's price, and getting an iMac to me is a waste of a monitor. If I want the best iMac I have to get a 23" Monitor. A lot of the cost is tied up in the monitor. Don't mind that too much, but the fact it is useless if I upgrade makes me mind very much indeed!
A mini, with 1GB of RAM and a Core 2 at the current base price could tip me over the edge.
- skip
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2455
- Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2002 1:23 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: oz_skip
- Location: Adelaide, South Australia
http://www.macrumorslive.com/
I usually find a few IRC channels (macrumors have one, mactalk.com.au as well), but have no idea how to go about it on a PC....something else to learn tonight I guess.
There seems to be a number of web based IRC clients about...any recommendations?
I usually find a few IRC channels (macrumors have one, mactalk.com.au as well), but have no idea how to go about it on a PC....something else to learn tonight I guess.
There seems to be a number of web based IRC clients about...any recommendations?
Problem IMHO is that Apple makes more money by selling iMacs with inbuilt screen, if customer wants a new iMac the customer needs to pay for new mac+monitor = more cash goes to Apple.... And Apple is firsthand about making big money, not about doing some favor to the world.
I also would dig a mid-range tower-or-whatever-cased machine, which is flexible, has mid-range gfx-card, swapable CPU, standard 3,5" HD, 5,25" FULL HEIGHT optical drive bay and all that for a reasonable price.
Well, we'll see...

Another option would be a mini, C2D CPU, with space for 3,5" HD, *real* graphics chipset and maybe a normal optical drive. Downside is, it would lose its nice form factor, and would be still lacking some decent PCIe-Slots... So i would prefer the midrange-tower.
I also would dig a mid-range tower-or-whatever-cased machine, which is flexible, has mid-range gfx-card, swapable CPU, standard 3,5" HD, 5,25" FULL HEIGHT optical drive bay and all that for a reasonable price.
Well, we'll see...
Another option would be a mini, C2D CPU, with space for 3,5" HD, *real* graphics chipset and maybe a normal optical drive. Downside is, it would lose its nice form factor, and would be still lacking some decent PCIe-Slots... So i would prefer the midrange-tower.
It makes less money with no sale at all.asr4096 wrote:Problem IMHO is that Apple makes more money by selling iMacs with inbuilt screen, if customer wants a new iMac the customer needs to pay for new mac+monitor = more cash goes to Apple.... And Apple is firsthand about making big money, not about doing some favor to the world.
Headless Mac = more sales, as the audience for a headless Mac is different to the audience for an iMac.
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10448
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Exactly. I already have a Pair of lovely monitors on my desk. One of which is already 24" widescreen meaning I'd never buy iMac yet alone the best one, which is probably the spec I'd choose in a tower.goldfish wrote:It makes less money with no sale at all.asr4096 wrote:Problem IMHO is that Apple makes more money by selling iMacs with inbuilt screen, if customer wants a new iMac the customer needs to pay for new mac+monitor = more cash goes to Apple.... And Apple is firsthand about making big money, not about doing some favor to the world.



