MacWorld - San Francisco 2007 : Maccies unite here.

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

fritx wrote:The 770's OK but I don't really want stylii and it is an enormously ugly thing.
Plus that Apple interface makes both Nokia's and Windows Mobile look like hairy old toss. Both rendered obsolete within two hours yesterday. I was using my 770 this week and it started to feel like Linux, ugh, horrid.

Watching the Stevenote last night it's pretty clear the phone is his baby, he was basically grinning for two hours and it's hard not to have that enthusiasm rub off. Seeing it running is pretty impressive even for a jaded cynic like me. If there is enough of OSX under the hood to make it a mini-computer then I think I'll be interested. The iPod interface was frankly amazing and for me the sensible option may be to wait for the next generation of iPods because they're obviously going to be fab. The little control overlay on video playback was dreamy too. I still don't really need a phone, but future devices are going to be very cool. What might swing this for me is a Skype client.
User avatar
Snakey
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8938
Joined: Thu May 09, 2002 4:17 pm 0
Location: Hell on Earth

Post by Snakey »

GeeZa wrote:Plus that Apple interface makes both Nokia's and Windows Mobile look like hairy old toss.
No offense mate, but I do find it odd that so many people are saying stuff like this without actually having used the thing first...
Nothing is worth the effort you put into it.
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

Snakey wrote:
GeeZa wrote:Plus that Apple interface makes both Nokia's and Windows Mobile look like hairy old toss.
No offense mate, but I do find it odd that so many people are saying stuff like this without actually having used the thing first...
Fair point. I'd be *amazed* if it's worse than my experience of Windows Mobile (a Dell Axim) or Symbian or the Nokia 770. The one thing none of these devices got right was the UI. They're just rubbish. Palm probably got it about right but then even that's got messy (I haven't used any Palm device in years).

It seems to me Apple have concentrated heavily on the interface which is the one area that they have experience in depth. The Newton still stands up today imo. I don't see how anyone who watched the keynote didn't come away thinking that the UI at least was slick as hell. If it honestly turns out to be shit in real life then of course we can all moan to high heaven. But going from what was essentially over an hours worth of demo, it looked better than anything I've used, RDF aside.
offyoutoddle
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
Location: London
Contact:

Post by offyoutoddle »

GeeZa wrote:
Snakey wrote:
GeeZa wrote:Plus that Apple interface makes both Nokia's and Windows Mobile look like hairy old toss.
No offense mate, but I do find it odd that so many people are saying stuff like this without actually having used the thing first...
Fair point. I'd be *amazed* if it's worse than my experience of Windows Mobile (a Dell Axim) or Symbian or the Nokia 770. The one thing none of these devices got right was the UI. They're just rubbish. Palm probably got it about right but then even that's got messy (I haven't used any Palm device in years).
I guess it's personal opinion. I would say that the interface on UIQ 2.0 was fantastic, and there is nothing wrong with the interface on series 60 devices, both of which are Symbian.

Windows Mobile is functional but ugly, and Palm is not so very different from UIQ 2.0 in a lot of ways. I think the apple UI looks the part, but as Snakey says, it will be interesting to see how it 'feels'.
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
User avatar
sty
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6628
Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2002 2:03 pm 0
Location: Darfield, New Sheepland

Post by sty »

Snakey wrote:
GeeZa wrote:Plus that Apple interface makes both Nokia's and Windows Mobile look like hairy old toss.
No offense mate, but I do find it odd that so many people are saying stuff like this without actually having used the thing first...
Exactly where I'm at at the moment, ie. cautious optimism.

Historically for me Apple have got it right recently, so I am assuming this is going to work but I'll be cautious up till then.

Bearing in mind the above I'm now going to assume it works.

Multi purpose devices and I just haven't got on, I've been really into handhelds etc. and experimented with a few, I still have a Microwriter Agenda at home. I've also played with various mp3 players (Rio, Sony NW-E, Nano) and I've had loads of mobile phones, culminating in my current Nokia 6230 which takes a 1G SDCard to hold mp3s etc.

I've had a good long look at various multi purpose phones in the past and recently and they just haven't worked for me.

Now this Apple iPhone looks as if it might work, I'd buy it now if it didn't actually have the phone element in it and was cheaper.

So my view is that it looks brilliant and by the time I can get one here and afford it, it will be a version 2 product (makes me feel happier) and we'll know how it's going to work ;) I'll probably try and get one as my next phone.

If this doesn't work, ie. Apple can't get it working, then I think this will be the nail in the coffin of convergent devices being Phone centric. ie. Everyone else has tried, and even Apple can't get it to work.

Speculating some futures:

Mac Tablet:
This is a no brainer now, 1280x1024 resolution, slimline device, using the same touchscreen technology, neat overlay keyboard, bluetooth mouse/keyboard/dock for desk use.

I strongly suspect if Apple had launched a Tablet now that the audience would be fairly specialised and it would do "ok". However if the iPhone is a roaring success and then Apple release the Tablet the halo effect could be phenominal and you'll see the tablet being adopted by a much wider audience.

The tablet can use all the same interfaces for playing music and movies as iPhone and AppleTV.

new iPod:
This is the one that excites me.

Exactly the same form factor as the iPhone, take out all the phone stuff and maybe slap the same drive in as the proper iPod today, up the capacity to 80G or 100G and you have a total winner.

Without the wifi, and with OSX locked down it would be a great video iPod.

Enable the wifi and OSX and no phone/mic and it's a brilliant machine.

Put a mic on the headphone lead fro Skype stuff and it's complete winner. Get the sharing of music between iPods working in the way we were all expecting zune to do and who knows where it could lead to.

So I expect the new proper (non Nano and shuffle) iPods to follow the same form factor and interface
XBoxlive -> Mr Sty
User avatar
Deckard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10747
Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK

Post by Deckard »

Apple and Nintendo rarely get their form/functions wrong.
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

offyoutoddle wrote:
GeeZa wrote:
Snakey wrote:
GeeZa wrote:Plus that Apple interface makes both Nokia's and Windows Mobile look like hairy old toss.
No offense mate, but I do find it odd that so many people are saying stuff like this without actually having used the thing first...
Fair point. I'd be *amazed* if it's worse than my experience of Windows Mobile (a Dell Axim) or Symbian or the Nokia 770. The one thing none of these devices got right was the UI. They're just rubbish. Palm probably got it about right but then even that's got messy (I haven't used any Palm device in years).
I guess it's personal opinion. I would say that the interface on UIQ 2.0 was fantastic, and there is nothing wrong with the interface on series 60 devices, both of which are Symbian.

Windows Mobile is functional but ugly, and Palm is not so very different from UIQ 2.0 in a lot of ways. I think the apple UI looks the part, but as Snakey says, it will be interesting to see how it 'feels'.
Again, that's fair enough, and I do recognise that this iPhone may end up disappointing. I am cautiously enthusiastic that Apple are developing in this area though and I think even the most rabid acolytes were quite surprised how mature the UI looked. I really don't like Symbian at all so I confess some bias on that subject.
User avatar
Molloy
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 274
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2004 10:06 pm 0
Location: Co. Clare, Ireland

Post by Molloy »

I have two concerns about this phone.

1. Despite the various battery saving aspects something with that big a screen is going to seriously sap up the juice. Are you going to have to think "I can only watch video or read e-mail for 30 minutes or else my phone will go dead before I get home tonight to charge it." If my iPod runs out of charge it doesn't bother me that much. If my phone goes dead it can be a serious inconvenience.

2. You're going to have to keep the phone in some kind of ugly carry case or protector. Something like the PSP or the iPod Video looks brilliant when it comes out of the box, but it's ridiculously easy to scratch and smudge. And a phone (at least how I use one) is going to see alot more handling. People generally keep them in their pocket with loose change and keys because you have to pick it up quickly when it rings, or turn it off if you've accidentally left the volume on in work or college. Phones tend to get dropped more often, you take them to the pub.. anything touchscreen really should be flip top as far as I'm concerned. And they need to lose that polished metal look. Again, looks good out of the box. Wears very badly.
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

I took the high res press images of the UI and resized them down to
320x480 and loaded them onto my Palm T3 which has a very similar
screen to the iPhone, slightly larger but the same resolution.

I'll tell you one thing, it looks much nicer than the Palm UI and it makes
a hell of a lot better use of the space. It's like comparing OS X and
Windows 3. If the demos, which I've watched a few times now, are any
indicator the iPhone's going to be something rather special.

You can find similar hardware with similar features but there's no-one
else doing a user interface like the iPhone. That video Acronym linked
showed ideas that are coming to market way sooner than I'd have bet.

Even if it's a disappointment in the end at least Apple's not another
'me too' company, the iPhone should be good for the whole mobile
industry in the long term as our expectations have just taken a big jump.
User avatar
Snakey
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8938
Joined: Thu May 09, 2002 4:17 pm 0
Location: Hell on Earth

Post by Snakey »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:You can find similar hardware with similar features but there's no-one
else doing a user interface like the iPhone. That video Acronym linked
showed ideas that are coming to market way sooner than I'd have bet.
Absolutely, and that video is very impressive. But I'm wondering just how useful this thing is for 'one handed' use. When I'm out and about, I tend to be carrying something, and need to hold and operate my phone with one hand. I'm not sure that's going to be very easy with this thing, and in this situation 'multi-touch' is completely pointless.
Nothing is worth the effort you put into it.
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

Snakey wrote:
Kemper_Boyd wrote:You can find similar hardware with similar features but there's no-one
else doing a user interface like the iPhone. That video Acronym linked
showed ideas that are coming to market way sooner than I'd have bet.
Absolutely, and that video is very impressive. But I'm wondering just how useful this thing is for 'one handed' use. When I'm out and about, I tend to be carrying something, and need to hold and operate my phone with one hand. I'm not sure that's going to be very easy with this thing, and in this situation 'multi-touch' is completely pointless.
Try using a stylus one-handed. I have. :D
User avatar
Snakey
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8938
Joined: Thu May 09, 2002 4:17 pm 0
Location: Hell on Earth

Post by Snakey »

Respect :D
Nothing is worth the effort you put into it.
offyoutoddle
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2644
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
Location: London
Contact:

Post by offyoutoddle »

GeeZa wrote:
I really don't like Symbian at all so I confess some bias on that subject.
Symbian is the underlying OS though, not the interface. Which symbian UI do you dislike, series 60 or UIQ? Or to put it another way, which phones do you you hate?

I like the latest v3 series 60's e.g. my new N73, shows the benefit of the higher resolutions the new ones have.

I despise the UIQ 3 phones e.g. sony p990, and sony w950i.

UIQ 2.0 for me was a good as it got. Looking a little simplistic and spartan now next to the hi res v3 series 60's, but its not all about looks. Which I suppose is kind of what Snakey was getting at earlier....
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Snakey wrote:
Kemper_Boyd wrote:You can find similar hardware with similar features but there's no-one
else doing a user interface like the iPhone. That video Acronym linked
showed ideas that are coming to market way sooner than I'd have bet.
Absolutely, and that video is very impressive. But I'm wondering just how useful this thing is for 'one handed' use. When I'm out and about, I tend to be carrying something, and need to hold and operate my phone with one hand. I'm not sure that's going to be very easy with this thing, and in this situation 'multi-touch' is completely pointless.
That's a good point but because the interface is software and not tied
to any particular buttons they could have some simple thumb operated
actions for the most common uses. It's not that big a phone so it shouldn't
be too difficult to sort something out even if fancier actions like zooming
use a couple of fingers.
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

offyoutoddle wrote:
GeeZa wrote:
I really don't like Symbian at all so I confess some bias on that subject.
Symbian is the underlying OS though, not the interface. Which symbian UI do you dislike, series 60 or UIQ? Or to put it another way, which phones do you you hate?
Sure. I used to be positive about Symbian/EPOC but just don't see it any more. Maybe since Psion bailed. I just found the whole experience poor. My last two phones in the UK were a P800 which I returned after a month and a Nokia 6600. I hated both and I think they were UIQ and S60 respectively, can't be sure. I'm kinda with sty, I've not been convinced by convergence at all. Blackberry is big over here but they're also terrible.

I've reverted to the cheapest phone I could find without any sort of interface or camera or anything because I just gave up. People take the piss. :) Bottom line is that I think the European technology companies have taken too long to deliver not very much and in some cases are delivering very poor software. I worked with a guy from Ericsson for years and his stories were all x-rated. Some of their tech was complete crap. The odd thing is that out here in the US, the mobile phone industry feels like Europe did about 3 or 4 years ago and yet it's a US company that looks to be making the biggest jump. If the iPhone sells like hot-cakes in Europe (absolutely key to its success) then it's really going to set the cat loose because they could get spanked.
Post Reply