Kalmar wrote:At the end of the day, when it's causing the product to fail, it doesn't matter who made the component in question. If it's caused a significant proportion of product to fall over inside the warranty period then it's a major fuckup and shows that they're lacking in quality control or have rushed it out without sufficient testing, or have been extremely unlucky.
Absolutely. But in this case, this is not happening. I'd never heard or read anywhere of a DVD drive failing other than at this place. There are probably others, drives do fail, and are very easy to put out of alignment or worse during shipping. But maybe you don't hear about it as often because people understand this.
If, however, the drives were causing major problems, then MS could just go to a different drive manufacturer (which, incidentally, they did recently, and now use a quieter, but slightly slower, drive.)
Solving problems due to overheating etc. is not quite as easy to fix...
GeeZa wrote:PVB wrote:Well it isn't.
But some of us are just annoyed if their console has any sort of fault that stops it working, whether it's a design problem, poor quality control or anything else.
Amen. Rod's image was far too close to the truth it's now ceased to be funny.
Ahem.
When you're trying to prove that a device has a design fault, as this thread set out to do - it's probably best to stick to the design fault.
Nothing is worth the effort you put into it.