The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Locked
User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Post by fog »

Rod_S wrote:First party PS3 games = £39.99:
That can't be right. I have been reliably informed many times over the last year that Sony would be screwing us all to the tune of £60. :wink:
User avatar
Samus
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1303
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 11:08 am 0
Location: Finland

Post by Samus »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:
Samus wrote:I have a feeling there's something more to that score than MotorStorm.
When a Sony game gets 10/10 there's cynicism. When Zelda doesn't
get 10/10 there's cynicism. *sigh*
Well, I said that strictly from what I've experienced first hand (although I'm not sure if it was a finished version back in December) and from all the forum talk around different places (GAF, etc.). Don't get me wrong, this is THE game I was / am most interested in the PS3 launch (check my post history if you want), but a 10? Sounds fishy, is all. Is there something else you're trying to say or want to say?

Edit: when Zelda TP gets a 8.8 from the same site that was totally clueless regarding Wii and the whole idea of it when it arrived to their offices in their live show and when they give Excite Truck 6.8 and say stuff like this:
GameSpot wrote:Just hitting the star limit will net you a B ranking, but you'll need to go above and beyond to earn the S rank, which is the only way to unlock the game's harder difficulty setting. Getting S rank in every track is a bit of a chore, one that's so repetitive that it doesn't feel worthwhile.
...then I think the cynicism is pretty well justified.
Justice Brothers.

"Almost! Too Relaxed!"
User avatar
Samus
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1303
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 11:08 am 0
Location: Finland

Post by Samus »

grue wrote:
Kemper_Boyd wrote:When a Sony game gets 10/10 there's cynicism. When Zelda doesn't get 10/10 there's cynicism. *sigh*
God of War deserved a 10/10.
Give me more GoW love, I'm very close to buying it tomorrow from my local game store, they have it second hand for 15e. How'd you compare it to something like RE4?
Justice Brothers.

"Almost! Too Relaxed!"
User avatar
Fuseball
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3139
Joined: Mon May 13, 2002 4:58 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: fuseball80
Location: London, Cosmos

Post by Fuseball »

Motorstorm then. It's fun. The game engine is ace. The racing is thrillingly close. It looks fantastic. Still no way on earth it's a 10/10 game though.

I found the car crashing frustratingly random. Most times it plonks you back on the track in a couple of seconds but every now and again it keeps rolling you over and over for anything up to 15-20 seconds. Meanwhile all your opponents stream past you as you helplessly mash buttons to get the thing back on track. Also had the car I was driving explode on brushing the smallest pebble of a rock. No idea why. I drove exactly the same route on the next lap with barely a twitch of the suspension. Small niggles perhaps but it made the margin between winning and losing determined more by luck than skill half the time.

The lack of achievements or the kind of awards given by Excite Truck also made it feel a bit wafer thin with little replay value.

Potentially a truly great game in there but not quite realised this time around. More a 7/10 for me.
User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Post by fog »

Samus wrote:
GameSpot wrote:Just hitting the star limit will net you a B ranking, but you'll need to go above and beyond to earn the S rank, which is the only way to unlock the game's harder difficulty setting. Getting S rank in every track is a bit of a chore, one that's so repetitive that it doesn't feel worthwhile.
...then I think the cynicism is pretty well justified.
I don't agree with their comments but I wouldn't necessarily say there is anything underhand about them. I, for example, am currently enjoying getting all S Ranks on ET but I've never had any interest in getting all the coins in Mario. I can easily see how getting S Ranks just wont appeal to many people.
User avatar
Samus
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1303
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2004 11:08 am 0
Location: Finland

Post by Samus »

fog wrote:
Samus wrote:
GameSpot wrote:Just hitting the star limit will net you a B ranking, but you'll need to go above and beyond to earn the S rank, which is the only way to unlock the game's harder difficulty setting. Getting S rank in every track is a bit of a chore, one that's so repetitive that it doesn't feel worthwhile.
...then I think the cynicism is pretty well justified.
I don't agree with their comments but I wouldn't necessarily say there is anything underhand about them. I, for example, am currently enjoying getting all S Ranks on ET but I've never had any interest in getting all the coins in Mario. I can easily see how getting S Ranks just wont appeal to many people.
Sure, looks like I was being unclear about what I meant. Kemper brought the Zelda not getting a 10/10 issue to the discussion and since GameSpot was pretty much the only site or review that gave it a "bad" (8.8) score of under 9.5 or something, I just reminded why some people didn't give much value to their opinion. I also don't think there's anything fishy about that or their Excite Truck score, lack of vision, etc. seems to be the case regarding ET.
Justice Brothers.

"Almost! Too Relaxed!"
User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Post by fog »

Samus wrote:
fog wrote:
Samus wrote:
GameSpot wrote:Just hitting the star limit will net you a B ranking, but you'll need to go above and beyond to earn the S rank, which is the only way to unlock the game's harder difficulty setting. Getting S rank in every track is a bit of a chore, one that's so repetitive that it doesn't feel worthwhile.
...then I think the cynicism is pretty well justified.
I don't agree with their comments but I wouldn't necessarily say there is anything underhand about them. I, for example, am currently enjoying getting all S Ranks on ET but I've never had any interest in getting all the coins in Mario. I can easily see how getting S Ranks just wont appeal to many people.
Sure, looks like I was being unclear about what I meant. Kemper brought the Zelda not getting a 10/10 issue to the discussion and since GameSpot was pretty much the only site or review that gave it a "bad" (8.8) score of under 9.5 or something, I just reminded why some people didn't give much value to their opinion. I also don't think there's anything fishy about that or their Excite Truck score, lack of vision, etc. seems to be the case regarding ET.
Yeah that's fair. Must say ET has really grown on me but only after a change in attitude. I loved it at first but after quickly "finishing" all the Excite levels I wouldn't have marked it very highly either. It's only after forcing myself to go back and try and S everything that I've really grown to enjoy it. And to be honest with so many other great games vying for my time right now, that so nearly didn't happen.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

IMO for a game to be worth 10/10 it would have to convert someone who hated previous installations of that genre/franchise aswell as the fanboys/fangirls.

Zelda TP is NOT a 10/10 game for me because I dumped the controller after about 1/2 an hour of play never to return to it again, and actually there is one Zelda game I loved so what does that say? :roll:

Reviews are personal, not often unbiased 100% so take them all with a pinch of salt. If you want a racing game, I suppose what they're saying is it hits all the right buttons ITO but whether it does in your opinion is another matter :)
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Says your foolish and lazy, speaks more of you then the game ;)
Half hour = Equilivelent to not playing it at all.
(imho, the first 5 hours are effictively a nicely blended tutorial. By the time you get to the end you will have forgotten the pains of the first fishing, and will enjoy doing the "proper" fishing side game)

Not all games have "instant gratification", some games, just like a good book or noval, build up steadly.

Besides, even games I hate I can still see why they are worthy of getting high marks. Its not purely taste.
I cant stand FPS games, but I can still see one some are better the others.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Darkflame wrote:Says your foolish and lazy, speaks more of you then the game ;)
Half hour = Equilivelent to not playing it at all.
(imho, the first 5 hours are effictively a nicely blended tutorial. By the time you get to the end you will have forgotten the pains of the first fishing, and will enjoy doing the "proper" fishing side game)

Not all games have "instant gratification", some games, just like a good book or noval, build up steadly.

Besides, even games I hate I can still see why they are worthy of getting high marks. Its not purely taste.
I cant stand FPS games, but I can still see one some are better the others.
Not the fishing, got fed up with the herding bit tried it for 15 minutes and then decided it wasn't that revolutionary. OOT is still the only Zelda game I would complete, it was perfect :)

Interesting point about FPS games, before Battlefield2 I was totally MEH about online shooty games of anykind, but that was and still is the best of it's kind and is a classic example of a 10/10 game everyone should try*, high marks fair enough but 10/10 should be reserved for *perfect games*

*unless you're a tree hugging pacifist who would puke at the thought of letting off 12 stinger missiles from the choppers :lol:
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

I thought you were jokeing when you said that earlier O_O
Seriously, herding is like 5 minutes out of 65 hours.

You gota give it a bit longer dude ;)
high marks fair enough but 10/10 should be reserved for *perfect games*
Well, thats the slight problem.
Theres no such thing as a perfect game. If nothing else, you could always say the game should be longer, and it would be even more perfect.

I think its better to rate a game as 10/10 if its as best they could possibly do in the time and resources they had.

So a 100 person team spending 5 years over "Tetris" is hardly worth 10/10.
Yet a loan, unpaid, Russian chap coding what would be one of the great icons of gaming, probably is worth 10/10.

Likewise, Id give 10/10 to Twilight Princess as its as close to perfect as I think Nintendo could have got with their team size and resources.
I could list a few of changes to the game Id like in places, but very little that would be "free" in terms of manpower.

Wind Waker I heavily rate down as it seemed rushed, and very repetitive. Despite the superb art-style, it was not the best they could have done. Zelda:TWW (as well as Mario Sunshine), was a clear result of Nintendo rushing games to try to boast the Gamecube. They wernt using their resources in the best way for the game.

Games should imo, be rated in the context with which they are made.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

It's just that 9/10 is fine for a game that is going to sell to people who like that genre even if it is amazing, but 10/10 should be reserved for a game that's so good in it's class it will convert people to that genre who wouldn't normally try it IMHO

Classic example is Mario 64, not really a Mario fan, not really a 3D platformer kinda person, but this game won me over totally and deserved all of its 10/10 100% etc etc that's all I'm trying to say. Zelda TP just didn't grab me peronally, neither control utilisation on the Wii, graphically or playability wise...it just left me cold but that's just me, sure loads of Zelda fans are loving it and it's all good :) No slur on the Wii it's a well put together machine and Wii Sports was the most gaming fun my whole family have had in ages. Just a shame not all of my friends have had the pleasure sadly.

But yes reviews are meant to be a guide only, those published in magazines are rarely 100% unbiased, and they are at the end of the day personal opinion. My only response to people who say a game isn't worth 10/10 is to write your own constructive review so people can see the other side of the coin. This will get people past the "No FPS/Driving Game/Beat em up is worth 10/10". That's kinda like saying you can get high quality steak but chicken is just cheap meat for the masses so there is no such thing as high quality chicken. It's all just a matter of perception and within seconds of playing Motorstorm,Resistance or VF5 I will personally know if these are special in their genres or just very very good, but at the same time as I love those genres I can't tell you if it is going to win over someone who hates driving/beat em up/FPS games etc.
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Post by Jamesac »

I don't care who likes a game or doesn't. If I truly love a game and think it's been executed with amazing skill to deliver a fun (or memorable) experience, with no big issues bogging it down, it's getting a 5 out of 5. When I write a review I'm not saying what I think others will think of it, I'm giving my opinion.

LocoRoco? 5
Gunstar Heroes (Wii Virtual Console)? 5
Guitar Hero? 5
Gitaroo Man PSP (and PS2)? 5

(If it's not obvious, when I write reviews it's on the 1-5 scale, with half-points for good measure.)

Motorstorm? Well, no idea really, but I suspect it's closer to 3.5. Only way to know is to play, of course, and I'm always more than happy to be pleasantly surprised. But reports like Fuseball's and what I've played of the demo don't strike me as the basis for a great game. Pretty, sure, and maybe kind of fun, but not great. There's too much time spent taking control away from the player as the car bounces over the terrain, and that's always aggravating. My idea of a great offroader is Rallisport Challenge 2 on the original Xbox, and Excite Truck was loads of fun as well.

James
User avatar
Fuseball
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3139
Joined: Mon May 13, 2002 4:58 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: fuseball80
Location: London, Cosmos

Post by Fuseball »

Motorstorm is so frustratingly close to greatness, which makes the faults it has all the more annoying. It's an amazing early showcase of the potential for the PS3 but it feels like a tech demo with a game hastily grafted onto it. Not a bad game at all but not as rich and full a gaming experience as it could have been, and not as accomplished in gameplay terms and structure as many racers already out there.

Despite being a Zelda fan, TP hasn't grabbed me as much as I had hoped. I actually prefer the control scheme of the Gamecube version.

If we're talking 10/10 games then the only one I've played recently is Okami.
User avatar
Roobarb
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1451
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 2:37 pm 0
Location: Blighty

Post by Roobarb »

Crikey. You turns your back for a just a couple of months and obsak is posting well reasoned arguments in his own ps3 fanboy thread. It's a topsy-turvy world, i tells ye. :)

The only truly reliable test for whether a game really deserves 10/10 will be looking back in five years time. Not having hindsight in a bottle right now though, i think obsak's measure is as reasonable as any.

Zelda:TP, as good as it is, i don't think is worth a 10: they haven't really pushed the franchise forwards enough imo.

On the other hand, i'd give Wii Sports 10, as it is the most revolutionary thing i've seen in gaming since the PS1. It never ceases to amaze me just how many people want to buy a Wii after playing it.

Motorstorm: it's a solid 8, but 10/10 is just crazy talk. I don't see it converting many people who aren't already into racing games, but it's a good game.
Locked