The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
Which just shows how crazy it is to worry about game scoresRoobarb wrote: The only truly reliable test for whether a game really deserves 10/10 will be looking back in five years time. Not having hindsight in a bottle right now though, i think obsak's measure is as reasonable as any.
...
On the other hand, i'd give Wii Sports 10, as it is the most revolutionary thing i've seen in gaming since the PS1. It never ceases to amaze me just how many people want to buy a Wii after playing it.
By your own reasoning Wii Sports can't be a 10 because in 5 years time we'll look back on it and realise just how lacking in content it was. In truth we wont have to wait 5 years for that either because there are bound to be better, more substantial versions of those sports very soon.
Well, the problem is people dont define what they mean by the rateings.
Are you rateing the game absolutely, in terms of enjoyment it gives? ("out of time")
Or are you messureing relative to its surroundings, relative to other games at the same time?
At the moment, most "out of ten" style rateings do a bit of both.
Which is really a problem.
WiiSports is a revolutionary game by far, and at the moment it could be called a 10/10....but in 5 years time we will have better games.
Things that have the motion controll AND more content.
So, in an absolute sense, it is no longer the best compared to other games out.
But that dosnt take away from the fact it was 10/10 at the time of release, revolutionary and groundbreaking.
Same thing I feel for Twilight Princess.
Almost aspex of that game beats Ocarina for me. Story, Atmosphere,Charecters, Length, Enviroment, Sub-games, Dungeon design.
But its no where near as revolutionary, the impact when you play isnt as much because the gameing landscape has changed.
Quiting before doing goat herding means you didnt really have a go at the controlls, short of horse riding, either.
Seriously, you didnt even scratch the surface.
Its like judgeing a book by the first word.
Are you rateing the game absolutely, in terms of enjoyment it gives? ("out of time")
Or are you messureing relative to its surroundings, relative to other games at the same time?
At the moment, most "out of ten" style rateings do a bit of both.
Which is really a problem.
WiiSports is a revolutionary game by far, and at the moment it could be called a 10/10....but in 5 years time we will have better games.
Things that have the motion controll AND more content.
So, in an absolute sense, it is no longer the best compared to other games out.
But that dosnt take away from the fact it was 10/10 at the time of release, revolutionary and groundbreaking.
Same thing I feel for Twilight Princess.
Almost aspex of that game beats Ocarina for me. Story, Atmosphere,Charecters, Length, Enviroment, Sub-games, Dungeon design.
But its no where near as revolutionary, the impact when you play isnt as much because the gameing landscape has changed.
But you DIDNT play it.Zelda TP just didn't grab me peronally, neither control utilisation on the Wii, graphically or playability wise
Quiting before doing goat herding means you didnt really have a go at the controlls, short of horse riding, either.
Seriously, you didnt even scratch the surface.
Its like judgeing a book by the first word.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
If you really must score something then you need to ask yourself was it the best it could have been at the time and on that score Wii Sports fails. However revolutionary the controls or enjoyable the gameplay the gameplay in many areas could certainly have been improved upon.Darkflame wrote: WiiSports is a revolutionary game by far, and at the moment it could be called a 10/10....but in 5 years time we will have better games.
Things that have the motion controll AND more content.
So, in an absolute sense, it is no longer the best compared to other games out.
But that dosnt take away from the fact it was 10/10 at the time of release, revolutionary and groundbreaking.
I love Wii Sports far more than I ever thought I would but not by any stretch of the imagination is it the best the game could have been at that time which is what 10/10 implies.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
No I haven't, I was just judging from that video. You have a chap there giggling away as his vehicle bounces over the landscape, it just struck me that he'd really enjoy Excite Truck since that's what it does but more-so.rockwaldo wrote:Well i was there, and we played Excite Truck literally 10 minutes after that clip was taken.disciple wrote:He obviously hasn't played Excite Truck.teamonkey wrote:Forget the realism, listen to Russ turning into Harry Secombe. Motorstorm is fun!Deckard wrote:Aye the realism is astonishing
To be fair it was no contest, and that comes from someone who actually quite likes excite truck.
Obviously you haven't played motorstorm...
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Well i was primarily basing my assessment on obsak's comment, which i thought was as good a measure as any as to what the special sauce needs to be for a game to earn 10/10:fog wrote:Which just shows how crazy it is to worry about game scoresRoobarb wrote: The only truly reliable test for whether a game really deserves 10/10 will be looking back in five years time. Not having hindsight in a bottle right now though, i think obsak's measure is as reasonable as any.
...
On the other hand, i'd give Wii Sports 10, as it is the most revolutionary thing i've seen in gaming since the PS1. It never ceases to amaze me just how many people want to buy a Wii after playing it.
By your own reasoning Wii Sports can't be a 10 because in 5 years time we'll look back on it and realise just how lacking in content it was. In truth we wont have to wait 5 years for that either because there are bound to be better, more substantial versions of those sports very soon.
Wii Sports does that in spades; not just appealing to people who prefer other video game genres, but most impressively appealing to a whole new crowd of people who wouldn't normally give video games the time of day. I think that's very special, and thoroughly deserving of a 10/10.lucid obsak wrote:10/10 should be reserved for a game that's so good in it's class it will convert people to that genre who wouldn't normally try it IMHO
I appreciate your point about content, but the first rule of usability applies here i believe: less is more. The experience of playing Wii Tennis with a Wiimote is *the* seminal moment of the 'next generation' as far i'm concerned, not HD or ultra-mega-realistic physics.
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
I couldn't agree more but IMHO that's justification for the Wiimote getting 10/10 and not Wii Sports.Roobarb wrote:Wii Sports does that in spades; not just appealing to people who prefer other video game genres, but most impressively appealing to a whole new crowd of people who wouldn't normally give video games the time of day. I think that's very special, and thoroughly deserving of a 10/10.
I appreciate your point about content, but the first rule of usability applies here i believe: less is more. The experience of playing Wii Tennis with a Wiimote is *the* seminal moment of the 'next generation' as far i'm concerned, not HD or ultra-mega-realistic physics.
-
Kronos
Exactly Wii Sports was obviously designed and fits perfectly into the ethos of the Wii-mote, and it's fun so it converted me to those kind of games, and it's tennis game is a little more playable than VT2 on my DC which is my all time fave tennis game so kinda does deserve 10/10 for it's time.
Sure maybe there will be more sophisticated Wii controls in games in the future but at it's launch Wii-Sports was a stroke of genius by Nintendo on the level of bundling Tetris with the brick sized original Gameboy
Sure maybe there will be more sophisticated Wii controls in games in the future but at it's launch Wii-Sports was a stroke of genius by Nintendo on the level of bundling Tetris with the brick sized original Gameboy
- Crystal_sword
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1397
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2005 7:09 pm 0
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
For me, its worth the price of the console - no question about it.Roobarb wrote: I appreciate your point about content, but the first rule of usability applies here i believe: less is more. The experience of playing Wii Tennis with a Wiimote is *the* seminal moment of the 'next generation' as far i'm concerned, not HD or ultra-mega-realistic physics.
- Duck Turkin
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
- Location: Down South
Wii Sports was fun with a friend and a few beers, but it also left we cold when playing alone.
I can't speak much about Zelda TP as I only played it a little (and didn't think much of it), but I always get caught up with the fanboys and have bought the other Zeldas, and frankly they just don't "do it" for me (excepting the last one rereleased on the GB Colour).
I can't speak much about Zelda TP as I only played it a little (and didn't think much of it), but I always get caught up with the fanboys and have bought the other Zeldas, and frankly they just don't "do it" for me (excepting the last one rereleased on the GB Colour).

