The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Locked
User avatar
RageMatrix
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5515
Joined: Fri May 10, 2002 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Jon256
Location: East Sussex

Post by RageMatrix »

Guru-Meditation wrote:
Flabio wrote:There's video on http://www.xboxyde.com. It made me cry.
We have pretty environments!
We have new characters!
We have pretty costumes that can be customized!

We're doing everything that SCIII did 2 years ago!
SAY IT! :twisted:
XBox Gamertag: Jon256
Wii Code: 4849 1090 9042 6725
"Wrapped in metal, wrapped in ivy"
The Official UNIX/Linux Thread
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Darkflame wrote:Increased system power = able to use better codecs/compression = less space needed, not more.
Only if you are dumb enough not to want much better quality at a
high bitrate. 40 Mb/s AVC is supported and not just for bragging rights.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Not at all.
As hardware specs improve you can use better codecs that give better quality AND smaller spaces.

eg. MP4 compared to Mpeg2.

MP4 takes a higher spec to decode, but will give you better quality for the same size.

Bitrate isnt the be-all and end-all, its whats done with that datarate thats important. Less advanced codecs take more bitrate to look good.


But, aside from that, beyond a certain point you just stop seeing a difference.
You could have everything in sequenced Bitmap and claim "perfect quality", but the end result wont be noticeable unless you pause it and study it with a magifying glass.

40Mb/s is absolutely crazy, frankly, and IS just for bragging rights.

I admit, Im only viewing on a 720p here, but I get diminished returns on divx/xvid at just 10Mb/s.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

skweek wrote:
benedictw wrote:
Flabio wrote:I'd avoid looking at any Tekken 6 stuff. Looks very poor indeed.
Image
THE NEXT GEN IS HERE!
Why is it blured in random places? :-/
Is that the game, or did someone upload a 50% jpeg ?
User avatar
Guru-Meditation
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4093
Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 10:46 am 0
Location: Bellevue near Seattle
Contact:

Post by Guru-Meditation »

Darkflame wrote:40Mb/s is absolutely crazy, frankly, and IS just for bragging rights.
Oh I don't know. If you want to go up to 3840 x 2400 res and 60 fps it'd be perfect ... :P
passplay> is anyone else sitting with their balls gently nestled in a bowl of red jello?
User avatar
Stone
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14497
Joined: Thu Jun 26, 2003 6:49 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: thestony1
Location: Harpenden

Post by Stone »

Darkflame wrote:Why is it blured in random places? :-/
Is that the game, or did someone upload a 50% jpeg ?
It's clearly been JPEGed. Look at the black-haired guy's right shoulder.

Stone
User avatar
Guru-Meditation
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4093
Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 10:46 am 0
Location: Bellevue near Seattle
Contact:

Post by Guru-Meditation »

Stone wrote:
Darkflame wrote:Why is it blured in random places? :-/
Is that the game, or did someone upload a 50% jpeg ?
It's clearly been JPEGed. Look at the black-haired guy's right shoulder.
I thought the file extension was the biggest clue.

*coat*
passplay> is anyone else sitting with their balls gently nestled in a bowl of red jello?
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

MP4 takes a higher spec to decode, but will give you better quality for the same size.
Or really good quality at a higher bitrate.
Darkflame wrote:Bitrate isnt the be-all and end-all, its whats done with that datarate thats important. Less advanced codecs take more bitrate to look good.
Advanced CODECs still benefit from having more data, AVC can go way
higher than 40 Mb/s even with at 1080p.
Darkflame wrote:But, aside from that, beyond a certain point you just stop seeing a difference.
I disagree.
Darkflame wrote:I admit, Im only viewing on a 720p here, but I get diminished returns on divx/xvid at just 10Mb/s.
I don't think you've ever seen good HD then. Watch some VC1 or AVC
at 15-20 Mb/s or higher.

FWIW Microsoft are hand-holding some difficult HD-DVD encodes,
to the extent of tuning the encoders, because right now the tools
aren't up to the job of doing decent encodes at 'normal' bitrates.
Being able to use higher rates would help a a lot. HD-DVD supports
up to ~30 Mb/s, of course it can't store as much data in the first place
so how useful such rates are is questionable, but they clearly thought
when designing it that there's a place for higher bitrates.

Compression isn't magic, throw some noise in, film shake, lots of pans
and zooms, flickering lighting and even AVC and VC1 will be screaming
for more data.
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Guru-Meditation wrote:
Darkflame wrote:40Mb/s is absolutely crazy, frankly, and IS just for bragging rights.
Oh I don't know. If you want to go up to 3840 x 2400 res and 60 fps it'd be perfect ... :P
That would take in the region of 160-200 Mb/s, but apparently all we
need is crappy 10 Mb/s DIVX, no-one can tell the difference. :lol:
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Not on 720p at 24fps.
(I admit, I forgot I was looking at normal film framerates with good motion-bluring. That, of course, makes a lot of difference.)
Guru-Meditation wrote:
Stone wrote:
Darkflame wrote:Why is it blured in random places? :-/
Is that the game, or did someone upload a 50% jpeg ?
It's clearly been JPEGed. Look at the black-haired guy's right shoulder.
I thought the file extension was the biggest clue.

*coat*
Not all jpegs are the same quality.
I generaly leave mine set to 99% on PSP, but many people have it lower.
Or really good quality at a higher bitrate.
Its normaly logical to compare like for like.

MP4, just like other modern compression systems that are only now possible on the latest hardware, allows you to have much better quality for a smaller filesize.
My point was this is a notch against the argument that BluRay is needed.
I disagree.
Your wrong.
Human eye has finite limits.

Especialy when your talking about moving images, rather then static ones.
Seriously.
Youd have to really struggle to make a piece of film footage that looks different enough between 20Mb/s and 40Mb/s so that people could spot the difference. Even then, I bet most couldnt.


(unless, of course, the video is very very high res, or a higher framerate...but,even then, if the image is motion blured correctly, the human eye dosnt really notice framerate changes over a 30fps).
I don't think you've ever seen good HD then. Watch some VC1 or AVC
at 15-20 Mb/s or higher.
This is a snapshot of HotFuzz trailer;

Image

Its streamed from Stage6 on a 4Mb/s connection.

http://stage6.divx.com/members/3915/videos/1100084

Its not perfect, but remember this has been transcoded from the quicktime 1080p source, and then jpeg compressed a bit too.
(A few other bits of the trailer, if you pause, compresion is more noticeable.)
Looking at what videolan tells me, it seems to be a variable bitrate of between 3000-4000kb/s.

So, I guess the stream above is "ultra crappy" if 10Mb/s Divx is "crappy".

With my own footage, at 10Mb/s it stops looking better.
I dont see how watching a 20M/s stream can prove to be its suppiour if at 10Mb/s things already look perfect compared to my own raw files.

Even if a tiny bit of footage had enough noise/shaking for the compresion to be noticeable....why does the whole film need to be at that bitrate?
Its just wastefull for no reason. For the sake of 10 seconds, you dont need to double the size of the movie.

As the bitrate goes up, the number of visible differences goes down, and if you "need" 30Mb/s for something at todays HD res's,imo, then your not doing a very good job with the compresion.

Your underestimateing the quality you can get with good codecs even at ""low"" bitrates.

I havnt had much expirence with AVC, as I normaly work with Divx or good-old Soreson3. Still, from what your saying, its actualy making AVC sound much worse then divx.
but they clearly thought
when designing it that there's a place for higher bitrates.
Not careing about disc formats, I havnt followed too closely what they are designed too support.
But might it not be an issue with High Dynamic Range?

I can surely see higher bitrates being essiental if at some stage we are getting more colours.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

oh, and this is all besides the point anyway...


...with the power of the ps3, what the hell are they doing pre-rendering stuff anyway ;)
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Darkflame wrote:
I disagree.
Your wrong.
Human eye has finite limits.
Yes which video and film are still not matching, unless you are thinking
Imax, and I shudder to think what that would need for compression.
Darkflame wrote:(unless, of course, the video is very very high res, or a higher framerate...but,even then, if the image is motion blured correctly, the human eye dosnt really notice framerate changes over a 30fps).
I disagree with that as well. 60 fps film looks much nicer.

Darkflame wrote:Its not perfect
You're not kidding.
Darkflame wrote:Even if a tiny bit of footage had enough noise/shaking for the compresion to be noticeable....why does the whole film need to be at that bitrate?
Its just wastefull for no reason. For the sake of 10 seconds, you dont need to double the size of the movie.
Because some material will deviate from the norm. Concert footage is
a real-world example needing extra work from Microsoft today. Sports
is another problematic area.
Darkflame wrote:As the bitrate goes up, the number of visible differences goes down, and if you "need" 30Mb/s for something at todays HD res's,imo, then your not doing a very good job with the compresion.
I'm not saying you need it all the time, or that all footage needs it, but
you can find footage that kills even the best CODECs at low bitrates.
Darkflame wrote:Your underestimateing the quality you can get with good codecs even at ""low"" bitrates.
Judging by your example I'd say you are overestimating. ;)
User avatar
Guru-Meditation
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4093
Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 10:46 am 0
Location: Bellevue near Seattle
Contact:

Post by Guru-Meditation »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:Yes which video and film are still not matching, unless you are thinking Imax, and I shudder to think what that would need for compression.
After making a hard copy of the latest IMax release, Justin decided it was time to invest in something better than a CD burner.
Image
passplay> is anyone else sitting with their balls gently nestled in a bowl of red jello?
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:
Darkflame wrote:
I disagree.
Your wrong.
Human eye has finite limits.
Yes which video and film are still not matching, unless you are thinking
Imax, and I shudder to think what that would need for compression.
[/quote]

Imax is 70mm, which is probably around 7megapixals raw res if your projector is good. (cinema res is normaly much lower then what it should be due too all sorts of lose's in the production and projection).

But still, we are matching the human eye in terms of quality for the resolution way before we hit 30Mb/s.

Im not saying we are matching human eye quality at all, only that the bitrate stops effecting it in 99% of case's before that stage.

Viewing area, res, and colourdepth, as well as any any distortions and errors caused by our output devices (lattency ect), effect the image a lot more, imo.
Darkflame wrote:(unless, of course, the video is very very high res, or a higher framerate...but,even then, if the image is motion blured correctly, the human eye dosnt really notice framerate changes over a 30fps).
I disagree with that as well. 60 fps film looks much nicer.
Doughtfull.
Are you -sure- your not talking about CG stuff here?

Having stuff motion blured correctly makes a huge difference to the visual smoothness. A 60fps CG film can still look less smooth then a 24fps real life footage for this reason.

The difference between two live action shots at 30fps and 60fps I dont think most people would notice the difference with.

Thinking about it, I guess there would be some advantages, but not directly rately to eye speed. Computer screens, or helicopter blades and such would look different.
Darkflame wrote:Its not perfect
You're not kidding.
4Mb/s

Thats 4Mb/s! (and without transcodeing, it could probably have been half that)

THAT IS 1/10th the bitrate you are claiming is needed.
1/10th!

As a percentage, how much divations from the source do you think there are in that frame?
More importantly, how many divations from the source do you think are noticeable in that frame if the footage was moving?

Given 1Mb or 2Mb more data that frame would be 100% perfect compared to the source. (assumeing the codec is good enough to handel that extra info correctly).

The only big error in that pic is a few of the blacks, but I suspect thats due to transcodeing as divx normaly handels blacks ok. The bits of his cheak go a bit weird too...but then, I dont think its at all noticeable in motion.
Darkflame wrote:Even if a tiny bit of footage had enough noise/shaking for the compresion to be noticeable....why does the whole film need to be at that bitrate?
Its just wastefull for no reason. For the sake of 10 seconds, you dont need to double the size of the movie.
Because some material will deviate from the norm. Concert footage is
a real-world example needing extra work from Microsoft today. Sports
is another problematic area.
That dosnt answer the question.
Deviation from norm is precisely why a variable bitrate is sensible.

Unless something is live, you only put high bitrate areas where it will be noticeable. And in any typical footage you would get a bell-curve falloff of bitrate needed to get a "perfect" look.
The center of that bellcurve would be 10Mb/s or maybe even 7Mb/s.
(Bits with high detail more, bits will less detail, less.
obviously).
Darkflame wrote:As the bitrate goes up, the number of visible differences goes down, and if you "need" 30Mb/s for something at todays HD res's,imo, then your not doing a very good job with the compresion.
I'm not saying you need it all the time, or that all footage needs it, but
you can find footage that kills even the best CODECs at low bitrates.
Sure.
I dont denigh there will be some.
But the amount of footage that needs it will be tiny.
As you increase the bitrate the amount of footage that "needs" that bitrate will get smaller and smaller.

I really think youd have to deliberately make footage designed to show the difference between 20Mb/s and 40Mb/s. It would be extremely rare in a film or tv for it tooccor naturaly.
Darkflame wrote:Your underestimateing the quality you can get with good codecs even at ""low"" bitrates.
Judging by your example I'd say you are overestimating. ;)
[/quote]

I repeat;
Thats a 4Mb/s transcoded stream.

In motion, what errors can you really see?
User avatar
Snakey
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8938
Joined: Thu May 09, 2002 4:17 pm 0
Location: Hell on Earth

Post by Snakey »

Have to say Darkflame, I agree with you here. That pic you posted, even with it's "problems", at a silly low bitrate of 4mbit,
with extra transcoding problems and JPEG artifacts on top? If I'm sat 6 feet from my TV (as I will be)
I'm not going to be able to see a single problem even with all that. I would need a much bigger TV
than I even want before it became a problem.
Nothing is worth the effort you put into it.
Locked