The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)
The difference between 60 and 30fps is clearly noticeable (and is the major reason Sky quote for having gone with 1080i rather than 1080p, because 30fps on sport looks just plain rubbish). We all know medium speed pan shots on film look dreadful, because 24fps just isn't fast enough. Film directors, of course, tend to avoid these shots for that reason, but it's absolutely essential in any sports footage.
There are several pathological MPEG artifacts which there is currently no adequate solution to at any bitrate or on any codec. Watch any scene with a light that steadily brightens and dims over the course of about a second, or any game of football where the camera follows a player in close-up with a background shot of the crowd. There is also the critical dark portion issue (where a mostly light scene has dark areas which lose detail). That one does largely disappear at high bitrates, but that's one that MPEG-4 doesn't really address any better than MPEG-2 given roughly equal quality elsewhere.
Also, note that the IQ difference between an MPEG-4 class codec and MPEG2 is dramatically lower at higher bitrates, as the artifacts that MPEG-4 addresses (by deblocking, etc.) are less common.
In contrast, note that the compression ratio tends to increase somewhat as the resolution rises in typical scenes.
MPEG-4 is a really clever technology, but it's not magic.
There are several pathological MPEG artifacts which there is currently no adequate solution to at any bitrate or on any codec. Watch any scene with a light that steadily brightens and dims over the course of about a second, or any game of football where the camera follows a player in close-up with a background shot of the crowd. There is also the critical dark portion issue (where a mostly light scene has dark areas which lose detail). That one does largely disappear at high bitrates, but that's one that MPEG-4 doesn't really address any better than MPEG-2 given roughly equal quality elsewhere.
Also, note that the IQ difference between an MPEG-4 class codec and MPEG2 is dramatically lower at higher bitrates, as the artifacts that MPEG-4 addresses (by deblocking, etc.) are less common.
In contrast, note that the compression ratio tends to increase somewhat as the resolution rises in typical scenes.
MPEG-4 is a really clever technology, but it's not magic.
Oh yeah, definitely. If you're going to go with higher bitrates, I'd rather it was because you're going with 60fps rather than anything else. If anything that should actually improve the quality anyway, because there's going to be less difference between frames at a higher framerateDio wrote:The difference between 60 and 30fps is clearly noticeable
Nothing is worth the effort you put into it.
- Guru-Meditation
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4093
- Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 10:46 am 0
- Location: Bellevue near Seattle
- Contact:
No, anything short of 2000fps won't be good enough!Snakey wrote:Oh yeah, definitely. If you're going to go with higher bitrates, I'd rather it was because you're going with 60fps rather than anything else. If anything that should actually improve the quality anyway, because there's going to be less difference between frames at a higher framerateDio wrote:The difference between 60 and 30fps is clearly noticeable
http://broadcastingcable.com/article/CA ... ay=Feature
passplay> is anyone else sitting with their balls gently nestled in a bowl of red jello?
http://technology.guardian.co.uk/games/ ... 43,00.html
Oh.
If only a week could elapse without another PlayStation 3 controversy. This time, Sony has announced that, unlike the versions being sold in the US and Japan, in Europe its next-generation console will lack the Emotion Engine - the chip that powered the PlayStation 2. Which means that European gamers, unlike their American and Japanese counterparts, have no guarantee that the PS3 will play their favourite PS2 games.
Oh.
(just show, no stabby stabby)
- rockwaldo
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4096
- Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2003 11:49 pm 0
- Location: playing cricket in the street at 3am
That was last weekkalmar wrote:http://technology.guardian.co.uk/games/story/0,,2023443,00.html
If only a week could elapse without another PlayStation 3 controversy. This time, Sony has announced that, unlike the versions being sold in the US and Japan, in Europe its next-generation console will lack the Emotion Engine - the chip that powered the PlayStation 2. Which means that European gamers, unlike their American and Japanese counterparts, have no guarantee that the PS3 will play their favourite PS2 games.
Oh.
So, you want to be an ARCADE champion BLOG to read. yay! [ http://www.arcadechampion.co.uk ]
Harrison to announce "Ground breaking" news at GDC -
http://www.1up.com/do/newsStory?cId=3157573
Prediction - Mario Galaxy to be PS3 exclusive.
http://www.1up.com/do/newsStory?cId=3157573
Prediction - Mario Galaxy to be PS3 exclusive.
But the Guardian Tech supplement only comes out every Thursday.rockwaldo wrote:That was last weekkalmar wrote:http://technology.guardian.co.uk/games/story/0,,2023443,00.html
If only a week could elapse without another PlayStation 3 controversy. This time, Sony has announced that, unlike the versions being sold in the US and Japan, in Europe its next-generation console will lack the Emotion Engine - the chip that powered the PlayStation 2. Which means that European gamers, unlike their American and Japanese counterparts, have no guarantee that the PS3 will play their favourite PS2 games.
Oh.
Sit down you little bastard
I used to really get excited about big announcements at game expos. Now I know I'm going to be disappointed so I get angry in advance.Rod_S wrote:Harrison to announce "Ground breaking" news at GDC -
http://www.1up.com/do/newsStory?cId=3157573
Prediction - Mario Galaxy to be PS3 exclusive.
I think the thing that broke me was the Wii price announcement and associated Wii hype - remember when it was rumoured there'd be a 3d display projector or god knows what else in it.
My guess - Getaway 3.
- rockwaldo
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4096
- Joined: Sun Mar 09, 2003 11:49 pm 0
- Location: playing cricket in the street at 3am
Yeah, but this thread doesnt...TFO wrote:But the Guardian Tech supplement only comes out every Thursday.rockwaldo wrote:That was last weekkalmar wrote:http://technology.guardian.co.uk/games/story/0,,2023443,00.html
If only a week could elapse without another PlayStation 3 controversy. This time, Sony has announced that, unlike the versions being sold in the US and Japan, in Europe its next-generation console will lack the Emotion Engine - the chip that powered the PlayStation 2. Which means that European gamers, unlike their American and Japanese counterparts, have no guarantee that the PS3 will play their favourite PS2 games.
Oh.
So, you want to be an ARCADE champion BLOG to read. yay! [ http://www.arcadechampion.co.uk ]






