pyroxian wrote:Istar wrote:Here's the thing (and I wrote about this much earlier in this thread): I want my XBLA 'reworked' retro games to be exactly that - reworked, for the sexeh new tech the game is running on.
Hmm, but the problem with that is then you end up with a completely different game that isn't as good as the original - look at the remakes of Rainbow Islands and Bubble Bobble on the DS...
Steve
Define "isn't as good".
Yes, there's a long and sorry history of shite reworkings of classic games into feeble shadows of their older forebears. Blasteroids on the ST is one that I'll never forgive, as an example. But let's not let a few bad apples rot the whole barrel.
The only thing that will be as 'good' as the original, is the original. And I'm not saying there isn't a place for the originals on XBLA - but I
am saying that I want to see more of this (JR) kind of thing, where a game is brought to the new platform and something is added. Something more than just the same engine with some new tilesets sprayed on.
What I really, really want (zig-ah-zig-ah) is the best of both worlds - a game that packages the original, but also the new. I like playing Frogger in HD on a big screen - but I'd also love to play 'Frogger Respawned', if such existed. If JR ships as the original code in an emulator as well as the new envisioning, that'd be ideal. I haven't seen anything that implies this will be the case though.
So, as I said before, if you want to play the original Jetpac, fire up your Spectrum emulator of choice and enjoy it in it's wonderful original guise. What are we gaining by just running emulated code on the 360? Leaderboards and achievements aren't enough to justify 400 or 800 points on a game I can play just as well on my PC under emulation.
There's also a chance that JR will be better - or as good, in a different way - to the original. Is T2K not as good as Tempest, because it's not exactly like the original? Or is it better than it? Or as good, but in a different way? Would you deny that T2K is a great game in its own right, even though it is clearly 'nothing more' than a reworking of the original classic?
I reserve judgement until I've seen and played JR myself. It could be shite. But it might not be. And if it isn't, I'll consider it the first significant step in the right direction for classic games on XBLA.