Darkflame wrote:Why is it ok for Nintendo too come 3rd place for two generations, but it will be so terrible for Sony too be in the same position?
Because Nintendo aren't loss leading, and because Nintendo's in-house IP is very strong so they aren't as reliant on third party exclusives. They didn't acheive critical mass with the Gamecube (or, if they did, not for very long), but the project made a profit anyway.
So what?
Why should the industary be built on the idea of lose-leading?
It leads too less risk's in software development, imo.
Its not a healthy practice really, despite the fact that as consumers we get things cheaper at first.
The fact that Sony has lost loads of money dosnt mean they "deserve" to not come last.
You're missing the point. If the PS3 comes third by a significant margin it will, almost certainly, lose money. There's no middle ground here - it's either a winner or a loser. In contrast, the early exit of the Gamecube didn't
harm Nintendo, except possibly in the brand value, because it was already well into profit. Therefore, that's the answer to your original question.
That might not be 'bad' from several points of view, but from Sony's point of view, it's an utter disaster. They are not in this industry to hand out cash, and unlike Microsoft they don't have the resources or desire to do it just as a hedge bet on consoles replacing PC's.
If you ask me, loss leading should be illegal, but I know there are all sorts of arguments that it shouldn't be (the most obvious being 'why should we stop you giving money away?').