Gorecki wrote:Darkflame wrote:Still, both better then Dpad for strategy's, imo.
The touch screen controls in AW:DS are incredibly tacked on and offer no benefits over the original system at all. If you're faster at using the stylus than the d-pad then you need a bit more practice using the d-pad. It's faster.
I repeat:
HOW IS IT FASTER?
I can click anywhere on the screen, and
instantly effect a command for that unit/location.
I dont have too navigate around with the Dpad before selection, I can go
right there.
I can understand if people are playing it on trains and stuff, and cant use a stylus, and yes, the Dpad commands are very well done like I said earlier.
But how is it faster to move too a location, rather then just click it
You think I am moving my hand 1-2cm in an arch slower then you press the Dpad half a dozen times or waiting for the cursor to move to the right location
But its the very definition of NOT tacked on controls.
Let alone "incredibly tacked on"
You have a gridbased playfield X/Y
You have an input device that can give X/Y selection of gridsquares without going ver other gridsquares.
Thats exactly what a touchscreen,
any touchscreen, is
for.
Also, the touchscreen is just as
"brisk and responsive" as the buttons. There is no special delay or lag with the touchscreen.
The touchscreen isn't always great: Mario64DS just didn't work, and can imagine i wouldn't get on with Starfox either. On the other hand it's a perfect fit for all manner of puzzle games, and has been mentioned it's a key part of games like Nintendogs, Trauma Centre, and Yoshi Touch & Go. Phoenix Wright also made nice use of it in evidence analysis. In general, it's just one of those things that make the DS that bit easier to use and more approachable. I'd miss it a lot if it was gone.
Exactly.
Allthough, Id still say
Mario64 + Thumbstrap is better then Dpad.
At least you have some degree of speed controll then.
Both infinitely inferiour to analogue, of course.
The DS and Wii, and even the tilt functions in the PS3's controller, are just controll methods to consider when designing a game.
You dont design a game around the controlls, you choose the controlls that best fit your game, and make your game work with them as best as possible.
Of course, you shouldn't dismiss controls either.
Just because your game use's 90% traditional controlls, if a new thing is useful you shouldn't ignore it. Or visa versa.