The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Locked
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Guru-Meditation wrote:Not trying to be a defender of the DC here, but putting Okami there is a bit unfair. Okami was released in the sixth year of the PS2s lifecycle. The DC was discontinued in the PS2s second year.
That's true but the PS2 also had games like God of War 2 and Shadow of the
Colossus, the best developers have made that hardware sing.
SiN
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 850
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2004 4:25 am 0
Location: Canada
Contact:

Post by SiN »

Solid state in short term would have cost Sony more, but in the long term, they would have had a better product *and* much cheaper production costs.
Ummm, there's really no way solid state could be cheaper than optical discs. And I'm not convinced optical drives are expensive to manufacture. This isn't bluray. :)
Mini-sized dvd's, for instance?
Ahem:
b. Sony weren't so cheap and actually put the fucking shutters on them so they wouldn't fill up with grit/fluff/gunge.
People are complaining that there isn't *enough* stuff covering up the optical disc ... and you want to get rid of all of it?
Darkflame wrote:No, the reason for UMD's rather then existing disc solutions was because they wanted their disc format to become the standard for portable movie playing.
Just like they are doing with BluRay.
The extra storage space just isnt that needed.
Ummm, yes it is.

Look, you're not going to convince game developers to become demo coders all-of-a-sudden. It's just not happening. Its all well and easy to say "look at the demoscene", but it's a *completely* different kettle of fish. There simply isn't the budget to have all games coded like demos.

And why only get cynical with Sony? Can you really justify the Gamecube using it's proprietary discs? If Nintendo really cared about the games, why wouldn't they use the cheaper, existing, higher capacity standard DVD?

Using UMDs can be justified without mentioning anything other than the games. There's really no way to justify the GC discs at all ...


SiN
User avatar
Bubba
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10013
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
PSN: BubbaFatAs
Location: Cambridge

Post by Bubba »

And honestly, the PS2 internals are far more "interesting" than the Gamecube (and I include the Wii due to it's Gamecube-with-bells-on attitude). Sure, the Gamecube was easier to code, but the PS2's stance is far more interesting from a technical nature. Sony worked hard to develop the EE and the GS, where as Ninty ran to IBM and took a generic PPC chip and then to ArtX for the GPU. MS did the same with AMD/Intel and Nvidia. In the same way that Ninty have been pushing the boat out with new control methods, Sony have been pushing the boat out with new architectures. And boy have they made plenty of mistakes in taking that route!

Another thing worth mentioning is the marvel of integration that Sony have achieved with the PS2. What started out as a noisy hulk of a box is now a tiny cool running device. Sure, they've fucked up plenty of times with regard to this too, but they have completely re-written the book on Console Revisions, and you can be damn sure that Ninty and MS will be hoping to copy their success this time round. Ironically, I reckon Sony are in the worst place when it comes to it this time round.

Basically they've succeeded in combining the cool technological "wow-ness" of the PS2 with lots of custom chips with the "most powerful" attitude that Microsoft bought to the last generation, and felt this pain right the way through the lifespan on the console. Can Sony really afford the next "xbox"? So much of what I'm seeing now I remember thinking when MS released our (well, mine anyway!) big black friend on the market place and expected to instantly clean up.

And in all honesty, without Sony about to keep the games industry in tow where will we be in 6 years time? As much as I dislike certain things about the way Sony have handled this next generation, I for one hope they learn from it and move on. Maybe that means the playstation 4 will have an intel CPU in it and an nvidia GPU. Maybe it means it'll do something completely different. All I know is that, as much as it pains me to admit it, a world without Sony making games consoles would be a much less interesting one...

Cheers

Bubba
||Work || Flickr||
User avatar
Bubba
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10013
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
PSN: BubbaFatAs
Location: Cambridge

Post by Bubba »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:That's true but the PS2 also had games like God of War 2 and Shadow of the
Colossus, the best developers have made that hardware sing.
Yeah, the same goes for all of the platforms though - the Xbox had some standout games (although was killed before it's prime), as did the cubey in... erm... Resident Evil 4 :).
SiN wrote:Look, you're not going to convince game developers to become demo coders all-of-a-sudden. It's just not happening. Its all well and easy to say "look at the demoscene", but it's a *completely* different kettle of fish. There simply isn't the budget to have all games coded like demos.
Absolutely! There also quite frankly isn't the inclination. I can't wait to get started writing games, love playing games too. However, I honestly don't see the fun in demo coding - it's like the hard work of producing a game without ever getting the fun reward of having the thing playable. It's also worth mentioning that there are many poor looking demos compared to the few standout ones, just like the videogames market.

But as Kemper says, the solution to everything is procedural this that and the other. I seem to remember everyone exclaiming how wonderful Spore was because it only cost about £5 to develop. Well? Where the shit is it?! Has anyone heard anything since E3 / EDC last year? It certainly hasn't been mentioned much otherwise... Ironically for poor old Darkflame, the Wii is really very poorly suited to doing anything procedurally as far as I can tell - it's GPU lacks and kind of meaningful grunt (read: shaders), and the CPU being a single threaded single core design is also far from ideal. No guesses needed for which would be best at it - the snippets from the Lair dev interview were very interesting in this respect.

Cheers

Bubba
||Work || Flickr||
User avatar
Firefox
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11412
Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2002 6:15 pm 0
Location: Sheffield

Post by Firefox »

SiN wrote:
b. Sony weren't so cheap and actually put the fucking shutters on them so they wouldn't fill up with grit/fluff/gunge.
People are complaining that there isn't *enough* stuff covering up the optical disc ... and you want to get rid of all of it?
Eh? No, I want them to put the slidely metal shutters on them like they're supposed to have; like mini discs and floppies have. That way you wouldn't get crap getting between the disc and the plastic shell.
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
User avatar
fro
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2593
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 10:44 pm 0

Post by fro »

Firefox wrote:
SiN wrote:
b. Sony weren't so cheap and actually put the fucking shutters on them so they wouldn't fill up with grit/fluff/gunge.
People are complaining that there isn't *enough* stuff covering up the optical disc ... and you want to get rid of all of it?
Eh? No, I want them to put the slidely metal shutters on them like they're supposed to have; like mini discs and floppies have. That way you wouldn't get crap getting between the disc and the plastic shell.
He was using what you said to illustrate a counter-point to what Darkflame posted I think :)
YOUR IMAGINARY FRIEND
User avatar
Bubba
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10013
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
PSN: BubbaFatAs
Location: Cambridge

Post by Bubba »

Yes, leaving the disc exposed like that was a mighty fuckup of the highest order, although I have found 3rd party umd covers to be pretty good actually, they certainly keep mine in one piece.

Annoyingly my PSP demo disc (woo, big deal) has broken though - the middle spindle has become detached from the disc, so it no longer reads now. As annoying as UMDs are though, there really was no other choice at the time the PS3 was released. Things are of course very different now, but I remember 1gb memory sticks costing upwards of £130 when I first got my PSP (I put up with the included 32mb stick). I recently got a (genuine Sony) 4gb one for less than £15. Bargaintastic, but still mightily expensive compared to the costs involved in duping optical media.

Cheers

Bubba
||Work || Flickr||
User avatar
teamonkey
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12082
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
PSN: teamonkey_ca
Contact:

Post by teamonkey »

Bubba wrote:I seem to remember everyone exclaiming how wonderful Spore was because it only cost about £5 to develop.
8O
User avatar
Firefox
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11412
Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2002 6:15 pm 0
Location: Sheffield

Post by Firefox »

fro wrote:He was using what you said to illustrate a counter-point to what Darkflame posted I think :)
Oh, right you are. When I look at Darkflame's posts I just see Image so I hadn't realised. :wink:
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
User avatar
fro
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2593
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 10:44 pm 0

Post by fro »

Bubba wrote:Things are of course very different now, but I remember 1gb memory sticks costing upwards of £130 when I first got my PSP (I put up with the included 32mb stick). I recently got a (genuine Sony) 4gb one for less than £15.
Cripes, what happened to cause the prices to crash like that? Did they discover huge deposits of the memory ICs in the North Sea or something? 8O
YOUR IMAGINARY FRIEND
SiN
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 850
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2004 4:25 am 0
Location: Canada
Contact:

Post by SiN »

Bubba wrote:I seem to remember everyone exclaiming how wonderful Spore was because it only cost about £5 to develop.
I don't think that's quite right. :wink:

Seriously though, where did you pick that up from? I'm not convinced Spore was cheaper to develop than normal games ... quite the opposite infact. The problem with doing it all procedurally is that its a bitch to balance, and a bitch to get it working. With non-procedural methods you make a couple of nice models, make a couple of nice levels, and call it a day. (It's just that simple! :wink:) With procedural methods, it takes ages of tinkering to make sure algorithms are well balanced, and look proper. Much harder, and takes much more time to test ...

... which is why we haven't heard much about Spore lately. The game has been in good, playable shape for ages, but Maxis have been spending their time balancing and tweaking the crap out of it.

Oh, and remember, this is a Will Wright game ... in a post-"The Sims" world he can take all the time he wants, and EA isn't going to say a damn thing about it. :)


SiN
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

SiN wrote:With Hirai at the throne, tech like the PSP isn't going to happen. And hell, tech like the PS3 isn't going to happen either. You can bet that if Sony do come out with another console, none of it will be designed internally, and I'm guessing it'll be worse because of it.
I think that's a very interesting point of view and not one I necessarily disagree with. One could view the PS3 as being either technically brave (Cell, Blu-ray) or very very stupid (Cell, Blu-ray). The one thing that's hard to dispute is that it's a technically impressive device. Initiatives like Folding@Home are unusual and innovative and are generally to be applauded. As a piece of forward-looking technology the PS3 is ahead of the pack, the only question mark, as Dio has pointed out (historically with Sony), is with the RSX graphics system which doesn't look hugely amazing. But otherwise it's pretty much "high-end".

The problem with our Ken is that all of it doesn't quite resonate with grass-roots gamers. The retail cost of that technical advantage looks to have relegated the Playstation brand to third spot, and that's going to hurt. As exclusives ebb away this looks increasingly likely to be a long-term problem, we'll see. Microsoft have got away with it because they didn't burden themselves with expensive drive systems, just deflationary silicon, and they had the market all to themselves for a good while. But the sales continue to speak for themselves, mainstream gamers are not interested. Sales of the PS2 have been very robust since both the 360 and PS3 launch. I'm not sure if I'm just jaded or not, but I think this is quite an unexciting time for gaming despite the tech, there just doesn't appear to be the anticipation or enthusiasm that was part of the Gamecube/Xbox/PS2 era. Some franchises are looking tired, and yet there's plenty of new IP (mostly from the PS2) that should be mind-blowing in HD. It's just that the "here and now" looks a bit dull.

I'm not sure what I'm trying to say here but maybe gaming is genuinely coming of age. The sort of thing a few internet nerds have been predicting but perhaps really looks to be taking place. I think technically you have to give Sony credit, the PS2, PSP and PS3 are incredible works of engineering. I agree that the PSP has blossomed into pretty much must-have gaming kit when it looked almost dead not so long ago. The PS3 may well take the same slow-burn approach. It's just that given how uber-successful the last round was, playing the waiting game for new gaming fixes isn't sitting easily. I'm already seeing people selling Wiis because of a perceived lack of games, it makes no sense. I always said that Nintendo's exit from the high-end was a smart move and I think this is being proven out. It makes me wonder what people actually want and whether there is a degree of dissatisfaction and impatience creeping in. The video games industry is certainly looking a bit weird right now.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Honestly, I love the DC too, but playing DC games, even some of the best technically (Like LeMans 24 hour) they're not really as good as the PS2 average and it's all a bit rose tinted glasses kinda thing going on. The DC could never have done Colin McRae 3 and that's a 4 year old game (and forget anything like WRC 05!).

As for complex architecture, the PS3 carries on where the PS2 left off. Sure the ATI chip in the 360 is better than the RSX BUT they left the door open to allow the SPUs of Cell to improve beyond the spec' sheet of what the RSX should allow the PS3 to produce. Same thing with the PS2, not the simplest machine to wring 100% performance out of but hell I have more respect for that kind of talented coding.

Don't get me wrong I'm not stupid enough to say that JSRF/Panzer Dragoon would have been as good on the PS2 as on the xbox, and clearly the GC version of Resi 4 looks better (which is why I paid 4x as much for it rather than lumping myself with the PS2 version, anyway my GC was desperate for another good game on the shelf :) )

As for UMD, well it works fine, is quiet and does the job. As for movies on the PSP, well they're damned amazing in quality thanks to both the bitrate AND having the best LCD by a long shot. To break the Nintendo monopoly on the handheld market is pretty damned difficult, everyone else has died trying already. ANY company would struggle, and handhelds are a lower aged demographic perfect for the plinky plonk Mario type games no offence.

Getting onto the crux of the matter really IMO anything above £325 is not going to go mass market. Microsoft were pushing it @ £280+£50/60 for Live gold subs as it is. Catch 22 until they massively ramp up production and lower manufacturing costs Sony will be stuck in this situation still. The popularity of HD movies in general will also need to increase too in order for the sales to go ballistic a la PS2. Who knows what will happen, what I do know is that just as the PSX was selling to it's own huge market outside the Sega/Nintendo nerdy market the Wii has tapped a huge potential of family friendly gaming, I can see parent being a lot more happy letting little Johny play Mario Galaxy than killing people ad-infinitum on Resistance, and it's almost a steal at £180 although that's £40 for the GC+ inside and £140 for some woolly motion controller system ;)
SiN
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 850
Joined: Sat Dec 11, 2004 4:25 am 0
Location: Canada
Contact:

Post by SiN »

Nice post.
I think that's a very interesting point of view and not one I necessarily disagree with. One could view the PS3 as being either technically brave (Cell, Blu-ray) or very very stupid (Cell, Blu-ray).
I'd view it as both. I mean, it's quite brave (and very ambitious) to launch a console with two unproven technologies. And it's quite awesome from a tech point of view. But ultimately, I'm not convinced it's going to add much to the gaming experience which, in the end, is what it's all about.

I mean, optical discs on the PS1 changed gaming. The PS2 was a nice console all-round, despite it not being as powerful as the competition. The processor/graphics/UMD in the PSP all adds up to make an amazing gaming experience. But ... Cell+Bluray doesn't do anything that PPC/x86+DVD couldn't do. So my point is that all the technologies that Sony have previously developed have added to the gaming experience. I don't see that with the PS3.
I'm not sure if I'm just jaded or not, but I think this is quite an unexciting time for gaming despite the tech, there just doesn't appear to be the anticipation or enthusiasm that was part of the Gamecube/Xbox/PS2 era. Some franchises are looking tired, and yet there's plenty of new IP (mostly from the PS2) that should be mind-blowing in HD. It's just that the "here and now" looks a bit dull.
I see what you're saying. I'm feeling a bit underwhelmed by the "HD-era". Lair was a game that I was getting really excited about, but after watching those videos, I'm not excited anymore. A while back my friend showed me a video of Dark Sector ... he was all excited about it, but it looked bland to me. I mean, it looked gorgeous, but ultimately uninteresting. GTA4 I'm still very excited about, but the GTA formula is stale in my mind. After I played LCS on the PSP, I realised that I've been playing the same game for the past, what, 5 years? Graphics backed up with no new gameplay just won't cut it.

But I'm not entirely convinced. Nintendo first-party looks better than it's ever been. God Of War on the PSP looks ace. The indy developer will be in full force this gen. The DS is still spawning all sorts of crazy games.

Most importantly, we've got ... five, FIVE different consoles (ps3, 360, wii, ds, psp) that are all unique systems. Okay, the ps3/360 are interchangeable, but I can't remember the last time there were this many ways to play games. Each console brings something unique to the table, which is more than I can say about the ps2/xbox/gc.
I agree that the PSP has blossomed into pretty much must-have gaming kit when it looked almost dead not so long ago. The PS3 may well take the same slow-burn approach.
I don't think it can ... I don't think Sony can afford it! And theres a difference. The PSP & DS can co-exist peacefully in a household ... but once little Jonny decides to buy a 360 over a PS3, there isn't as much incentive to go off and buy a PS3 as well.
It's just that given how uber-successful the last round was, playing the waiting game for new gaming fixes isn't sitting easily. I'm already seeing people selling Wiis because of a perceived lack of games, it makes no sense.
I think there's too much impatience. Like come on now, there are lots of solid games on the Wii! Zelda, Elebits, Excite Truck, SSX, Sonic, etc, etc. It's the same situation on the PSP ... people *still* go on about how there aren't any games for it, which is crap!
It makes me wonder what people actually want and whether there is a degree of dissatisfaction and impatience creeping in. The video games industry is certainly looking a bit weird right now.
I think people want too much, all the time. If a good game comes out on a platform, the internet raves on about it for a couple of days, and then forgets about it. This just cements the idea that video games are disposable entertainment, and I'm not very happy with that notion.


SiN
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Plus PS2 had DVD playability out of the box and a remote control that looked smarter and more expensive than a £1000+ Sony TV after a year or so which was the clincher in most ways. DC died over DVD playback ultimately, it seamed "not as advanced" to little johnny, GC was seen as a toy and xbox was more, from a geeky OS company with fidly bits to buy to play DVDs.

I guess they went all out and did what they thought was the best no expense spared, however 360 @ £199 fucked that up for them (no it's not a fair comparison when you add a HDD/Wireless controls/HD-DVD/Live subs for a few years to it!) but there is no way in hell a £425 machine or even a £375 machine will go ballistic in the market place. It's just too high a price point and until they sell more they can't cut prices much ergo catch 22. Blu-Ray is a problem, Cell is not a problem though, if anything Cell claws back the advantage 360s GPU has over RSX on PS3 so damned lucky they did it that way if you ask me, which helped most launch titles on PS3 look as good/better than anything 2nd gen on 360 ;) Still we're not made of money and it's not yet an essential lifestyle purchase using the Blu-Ray Trojan horse tactic :twisted:
Locked