Edit: Hmm, must have been lucky, I paid £14.98 for mine including postage, where as they now seem to be going for ~£22ish including postage.
Cheers
Bubba
Ohhh .... yeah, that totally makes sense. Spore would cost a fortune to make any other way. But Spore is a very unique game. Procedural methods work fine for Spore, but I'm not convinced making a typical action game would be significantly cheaper using procedural methods. It would end up being, maybe, slightly cheaper, but the media would lack the polish of "hand-made" models/textures/sounds/etc.Neither do I, but I'm sure I read something similar in one of the articles a good 12 months ago - basically saying that creating and animating the world / creatures by hand would have taken an age and cost a fortune, whereas a procedural approach was resulting in significant time (and thus money) savings.
Not really important though, is it? I mean, sure it'd be slightly cheaper to make the device, but that would be offset by the significantly more expensive costs of manufacturing the cartridges. In the long run, optical discs end up being cheaper.Darkflame wrote:I was talking about the cost of making the device itself.
Less parts normaly means cheaper.
I put UMDs in my pockets and they survive ... trying that with unprotected CDs didn't work out quite as well.If it meant a standard universal disc format, yes.
I'm sure nice little cloth sleaves or clip-cases could be made.
(also, with no case at all, "gunk" wouldnt build up, youd just get easy-to-whipe off smudges and figureprints)
Clearly, you haven't played that many PSP games. None of my games have FMVs ... apart from frivolous stuff like company logos, etc. Space is taken up by music, textures, sound fx, etc. The media used in PSP games are essentially the same as the media used in home console games. They're all high quality stuff, the only difference is that the textures are scaled down to fit into video ram, and because hi-res textures aren't noticeable on the (relatively) "tiny" screen.Why?
Gameplay dosnt take up much space.
Your argument seems to be "The PSP couldnt be the PSP without UMDS". Which is true.
But my argument is "The PSP could have been a bloody fine system without them"
Less FMV's, and purhapes more midi music, sure.
But it would be worth it.
Thats not how it works! You can't just whip up libraries and say, "oh look, use these tools to magically make media". I don't know if you what goes into procedural media. I've tried working with it ... it's a whole new way of thinking. Simply put, doing everything procedurally would (like I've been saying) take away from "the PSP experience". It's a compromise, and not one thats worth it, IMO.Not at all.
And certainly not overnight.
But I think, if sony wanted too, they could have invested in procedral libaurys and techniques too make great looking PSP games in 128MB.
Its not a question of suddenly replacing everything, it would just be another tool too get great looking stuff in a smaller size.
Bigger cartridges cost money. While the DS supports upto 128megs, it's very difficult to convince a publisher to shell out for the expensive "high-end" cartridges. The same thing would happen on the PSP.And, as I said, I think 128MB wouldnt last long either.
If sony went solid state, Im sure they would have outdid Nintendo from the off in terms of cart size, and by now I wouldnt be at all supprised if some of the biggest games were upto 512MB.
(look at how the old gameboy cart size's increased over its lifetime)
Exactly. What about being "all about the games"? Nintendo were busy trying to cover their asses, and did it at the expense of "the games". So when Ninty do something to cover their asses, thats okay, but when Sony do the same, they're all evil, horrible people, etc?Rightly or wrongly, Nintendo saw Gamecube discs as helping too prevent piracy.

Very true. But the design choices in the PSP hardware did result in a number of things that went against its favour:Bubba wrote:Part of the reason it's worth having a PSP is that it is very different from a DS, and that includes textures and audio.
I dont think Nintendo's cart-based approach isnt exactly digging into their profit margins.Not really important though, is it? I mean, sure it'd be slightly cheaper to make the device, but that would be offset by the significantly more expensive costs of manufacturing the cartridges. In the long run, optical discs end up being cheaper.Darkflame wrote:I was talking about the cost of making the device itself.
Less parts normally means cheaper.
Hence why I suggested cloths or clip-case's :-/I put UMDs in my pockets and they survive ... trying that with unprotected CDs didn't work out quite as well.If it meant a standard universal disc format, yes.
I'm sure nice little cloth sleaves or clip-cases could be made.
(also, with no case at all, "gunk" wouldnt build up, youd just get easy-to-whipe off smudges and figureprints)
Why?
Gameplay dosnt take up much space.
Your argument seems to be "The PSP couldn't be the PSP without UMDS". Which is true.
But my argument is "The PSP could have been a bloody fine system without them"
Less FMV's, and perhapes more midi music, sure.
But it would be worth it.
Midi does NOT have to mean low quality.And no, midi music wouldn't be worth it. Low quality sound fx wouldn't be worth it
If it wasnt for the vastely faster chip and more ram, then yes.Anything that takes away from that just makes the PSP a GBA with a big screen.
What part of "not at all" and "not overnight" did you not get?Thats not how it works! You can't just whip up libraries and say,"oh look, use these tools to magically make media".Not at all.
And certainly not overnight.
But I think, if Sony wanted too, they could have invested in procedural libraries and techniques too make great looking PSP games in 128MB.
Its not a question of suddenly replacing everything, it would just be another tool too get great looking stuff in a smaller size.
I don't know if you what goes into procedural media. I've tried working with it ... it's a whole new way of thinking.
You think procedurals would automatically be worse?Simply put, doing everything procedurally would (like I've been saying) take away from "the PSP experience". It's a compromise, and not one that's worth it, IMO.
The price would still fall and thus space would go up. (if the device lasted long enough)Bigger cartridges cost money. While the DS supports upto 128megs, it's very difficult to convince a publisher to shell out for the expensive "high-end" cartridges. The same thing would happen on the PSP.And, as I said, I think 128MB wouldn't last long either.
If sony went solid state, Im sure they would have outdid Nintendo from the off in terms of cart size, and by now I wouldn't be at all surprised if some of the biggest games were upto 512MB.
(look at how the old gameboy cart size's increased over its lifetime)
That IS about the games.Exactly. What about being "all about the games"?Rightly or wrongly, Nintendo saw Gamecube discs as helping too prevent piracy.
I don't see anything wrong with it either. Does it make any difference at all to the end user what format their games come on? No.Darkflame wrote:I dont think it maters if Nintendo was right or wrong with GC discs preventing piracy.
They thought it would help, and thats why they did it.
Dont see anything wrong with that.
You think? It's, like, 80% screen, and personally, I think that's what sold it to a lot of people.Roobarb wrote:But the design choices in the PSP hardware did result in a number of things that went against its favour:
. larger form-factor (this really kicked in with introduction of the DS Lite)
Well, I'm glad it's 'higher spec', as I'm sure are most of the people that bought the thing - and therefore it's going to cost higher... As for 'battery life', as I said before, and as a few others have said - honestly, it's not a problem.Roobarb wrote:. higher cost (higher spec hw)
. lower battery life
Huh? There might have been a few of those, but I don't think you can say 'many'. Wipeout wasn't a port and certainly wasn't lazy, and all the other games I've bought for the damn thing are pretty much PSP exclusive. (Pretty much, because stuff like Lumines has since been released on other platforms.)Roobarb wrote:. at least in its early life, many of the games were lazy home console ports.
I pretty much agree with most of that though there is another issue with UMD.Snakey wrote:I don't see anything wrong with it either. Does it make any difference at all to the end user what format their games come on? No.Darkflame wrote:I dont think it maters if Nintendo was right or wrong with GC discs preventing piracy.
They thought it would help, and thats why they did it.
Dont see anything wrong with that.
But along similar lines - I don't see anything wrong with UMD either.
Sure, it'd be nice if they had the little metal slidey thing that Minidisc has to protect the disc, although to date I've never had a problem. But apart from that? Seems that it's fashionable to rip on UMD when there's actually nothing wrong with it at all.
Yeah, so there are some games that have bloody stupid load times. But I haven't bought any of those, because - well - they're shite anyway. It's all down to badly optimised loading code, which funnily enough tends to go along with bad code everywhere else in the game tooThe UMD itself isn't particularly slow, as can be witnessed by quite a few games where you don't even notice the loading going on. I've also not noticed any particular impact in battery life while playing games off UMD.
Sure, it's probably going to hit your battery a bit more if you're watching a movie off UMD. But I can count the number of times I've done that on zero hands
But, yeah. Nothing really wrong with UMD. Certainly nothing that using MiniDVD instead would have 'improved'.
Because thats just silly. It would be like asking, "why not have DS games sold on SD cards, and have a cradle to hook it up to the DS?" I'm not sure the general public wants to assemble their discs before playing a game.Darkflame wrote:Or, worst-case, why not even have mini-dvds that you put inside a cradle?
Hypothetically, if it wasn't a gaming decision, has it harmed the games in anyway? Not really. So it's not a big deal to me. Like Snakey, "I can count the number of times I've [watched UMD movies] on zero hands". Seriously, I didn't even watch the Spiderman2 UMD that came free with the damn thing!The decision was not a gaming one.
Lumines wouldn't be possible with midi. 'Nuff said.Midi does NOT have to mean low quality.
Put a decent sized wave table on the device with a good sound card and you can have some very nice tunes.
You're missing the point. What incentives does a developer have to even look at procedural tools? It's more work (ie, more money, longer dev times) and staffing a different kinds of artists. Nobody would bother. They'd just make games the way they always have with crappier media.What part of "not at all" and "not overnight" did you not get?
Gezz.
And Sony make their money from movies and games ... what's the problem again?That IS about the games.
Thats were Nintendo make their money.
I don't agree that price sensitivity is the reason the PSP hasn't been overly succesful and I do think Nintendo got form factor, functionality and battery life right with the DS.silent_unicorn wrote:Like Snakey said the PSP is 80% [+] screen and what a screen it is too. Watching BSG on it is a very watchable experienceThat screen is to die for, especially mine with ZERO dead pixels! I can't say I've seen a better screen this side of a Sony Picturebook (£800+) or any other laptop I use like Librettos etc. So making it smaller will make it into a toy IMO and the weight isn't really an issue, if you can't handle the weight of it you're probably too young to play most of the games on it for it's intended adult demographic
I personally have had some pretty battered UMDs from 2nd hand games and you know what they all worked too, as for sticking a HD in it, that will make it even more expensive which would be financial suicide. Nope the PSP only needs one thing to go ballistic in the market place amongst the younger Nintendo core market, that is price. If it hits £99 then it will sell a lot more IMO. The DS has a cheap and chearful Fischer Price style image both on price and the kind of cutesy games you get on it and PSP only has Loco Roco really. Oh well that's a personal thing and I guess more people in the market for a handheld want that (and if they didn't Nintendo wouldn't keep releasing cheap consoles with cute games)
Finally battery life, seriously how long do you need to play games on the toilet/in a field/on a desert island??? If you can't get to a land based socket to charge it or a USB port on tech surely you can get to a ciggy lighter in a car?