The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Locked
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

silent_unicorn wrote:1. Because us poor Sony fans are outnumbered on here
You're agreeing with me. YY is a fair slice of the gaming community and yes, their handheld is less popular here. Just like it is in the rest of the world. Did you see last weeks Japanese PSP sales? The DS sold 6 times more.
silent_unicorn wrote:2. Because it's not true, I know atleast 5 people who spend much more on there PSP in time and game purchases than their DSs
That's rare. Every DS vs PSP software sales chart I've seen confirms that
Last edited by gravy on Sat Apr 28, 2007 9:28 am 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
benedictw
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6012
Joined: Thu Mar 25, 2004 3:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: CoderBen
Location: Poole, UK
Contact:

Post by benedictw »

silent_unicorn wrote:Ahh here we go, another interesting trailer, for a Japanese game called Trusty Bell (??). They really do look like 3D anime cartoon characters, combat seams a bit Final Fantasy turn based, other than that get someone who speaks Japanese to translate the rest of the plot for you ;)
Eternal Sonata for the US and Europe. Its about Chopin on his deathbed. Its definately one I'll get when its released over here.
Gamertag\PSN: CoderBen
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

I honestly can't be arsed with the whole stylus thing nor can most of the 20 somethings I know or the cutesy games *meh* each to their own :)

It's a personal thing but IMO

1. Nintendo have become synonimous with the word handheld/portable gaming device just like consoles are also generically called playstations
2. You won't breaking any sales records with Silent Hill on a DS different market.
3. Because of the two above points AND the pricing of the PSP it has placed a cool 2nd place in the core youngsters market for these devices.
User avatar
Flabio
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8717
Joined: Wed Mar 03, 2004 12:37 pm 0
Location: Guildford

Post by Flabio »

Trusty Bell / Eternal Sonata is rather nice looking. Coming out on the 360 first, with the PS3 version at some unspecified future point.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

benedictw wrote:
silent_unicorn wrote:Ahh here we go, another interesting trailer, for a Japanese game called Trusty Bell (??). They really do look like 3D anime cartoon characters, combat seams a bit Final Fantasy turn based, other than that get someone who speaks Japanese to translate the rest of the plot for you ;)
Eternal Sonata for the US and Europe. Its about Chopin on his deathbed. Its definately one I'll get when its released over here.
Thanks for the info on that :) Will google for some more.
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Post by Jamesac »

And a solid second place in the adult market, too. I like the PSP as well and defend it on a regular basis, but you can't deny the market numbers just because personal experience says otherwise.

I'm looking forward to Eternal Sonata as well. It's a Tri-Ace spin-off group, so I'm feeling optimistic. The 360 version should be great. :)

As for gaming synonyms (warning, pet peeve ahead!), nothing has even come close to how Nintendo was perceived back in the 8-bit days. Game consoles are consistently referred to by title, even among people who aren't sure exactly what it is their kid has. X-Cube, Gamebox, "He's got a Sony", whatever. They may screw up the name but playstation isn't a generic title by a long shot.

Try working retail, attempting to help parents find something the kid will like, and letting that problem not become a pet peeve. "Yeah, his portable gaming system is a Nintendo one. Do you know what it could be?" Why yes, yes I do. It could be a Gameboy, GBC, GBA, or DS. At least when they said "He's got the Sony handheld." it was a no-brainer.

/rant

James
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

gravy wrote:
silent_unicorn wrote:1. Because us poor Sony fans are outnumbered on here
You're agreeing with me. YY is a fair slice of the gaming community and yes, their handheld is less popular here. Just like it is in the rest of the world. Did you see last weeks Japanese PSP sales? The DS sold 6 times more.
I'm not denying it's selling in much greater numbers, also never ever denied Nintendo where anything other than consumate masters of the portable market. More people in the world want what the DS has. I bet if we did a statistical analysis the DS sales figures would have predictably been the same if the PSP had or hadn't been released anyway, make of that what you will. They are in different markets though and there is some cross over too, depends what kind of games personaly people want "on the go". A PSP is a portable platform for PS2 games, make of that what you will but obviously 100+ million people have most of those games already I'm guessing which doesn't help Sony at all. Works for me and most of the people I know but not for the worldwide market for handheld gaming devices end of the day as the figures show.
gravy wrote:
silent_unicorn wrote:2. Because it's not true, I know atleast 5 people who spend much more on there PSP in time and game purchases than their DSs
That's rare. Every DS vs PSP software sales chart I've seen confirms that
Whilst we all had a laugh with Wii-Sports here, generally they're not a group of people who rave about either Mario games or stylus controls so its not too unlikely that would be the case for me. Probability and dispersion of overall stastic of the sales figures is an average of the whole. There will be areas and demographics that the PSP is more popular in, would improve with price drop too and the now stronger catalogue of games IMO.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Flabio wrote:Trusty Bell / Eternal Sonata is rather nice looking. Coming out on the 360 first, with the PS3 version at some unspecified future point.
Ahh was listed only as PS3 on the video link in gametrailers I swear (generally don't post them here if I'm not sure about what format it actually is) :oops:

Anyway does anyone here have NFS:Carbon on the PS3 here? Need to know how glitchy it is.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

Yeah I get your point, different people like different things. You seem to live in some magical Sony utopia that's out of kilter with the rest of the world. Fair enough.

My point is Sony have made something that's not as desireable as it's competitors to the world as a whole.

And I suspect the PSP is a business that still hasn't made a profit for Sony. Like the PS3 it's financial success depends bringing in cash from high software sales and losing cash on the HW.

Some of the analyst comment I've seen about Kutaragi's "departure" have highlighted the PSP's performance and poor PSP 1st party software support as issues as important as the PS3's lack lustre launch for him getting the heave ho.

On top of that my experience is that there's a decline in PSP titles that publishers are commisioning developers to make from last year. That was the death knell for the NGC a few years ago.

My prediction is we'll see dwindling software support and the in turn declining HW sales. It's not a pretty picture for the machine right now and I don't think it's going to get better.

Yeah it does look like it's an ace little box for emulation and some of the titles are good but there's not a lot of them and as I say I reckon they're going to get rarer.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Jamesac wrote:
As for gaming synonyms (warning, pet peeve ahead!), nothing has even come close to how Nintendo was perceived back in the 8-bit days. Game consoles are consistently referred to by title, even among people who aren't sure exactly what it is their kid has. X-Cube, Gamebox, "He's got a Sony", whatever. They may screw up the name but playstation isn't a generic title by a long shot.
Here in the UK the NES was almost trounced by the SMS so we're still a nation of Atari and Playstationers, the SNES did much better vs the Megadrive due to sacking of Mattel as distributor and promoter IIRC after that fiasco :)
User avatar
aureole
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7150
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 12:35 pm 0

Post by aureole »

gravy wrote: That's rare. Every DS vs PSP software sales chart I've seen confirms that
I was going to contest this, but scratching around, the closest territory is the US, which has 7m PSP to 10m DS. Oddly, the PSP sales figures aren't up on wikipedia, but the DS ones are...
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

aureole wrote:
gravy wrote: That's rare. Every DS vs PSP software sales chart I've seen confirms that
I was going to contest this, but scratching around, the closest territory is the US, which has 7m PSP to 10m DS. Oddly, the PSP sales figures aren't up on wikipedia, but the DS ones are...
I think you're talking about HW sales there, I'm saying software sales on each platform.

Generally when you see a chart there'll be a healthy representation of DS games in the top 20 but very little in the way of PSP.

And like the PS3 Sony's model for making money is wholly dependant on selling lots of games for every PSP sold.
User avatar
radio
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1076
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 11:34 am 0
Location: Brighton
Contact:

Post by radio »

Darkflame wrote:
radio wrote:
Darkflame wrote:How does the device tell were you are looking if the resolution isn't high enough to see your pupil clearly?
640x480 seems to me cutting it fine if people are a decent distant from the tv. Doesnt seem nearly enough too do it reliably anyway. (given the Wiimotes 1024x1024 sensing of simple UV hotspots isn't 100% accurate 640x480 of visible light seems much harder to process)
And how can Z-depth sensing work in software?
...

see: this video for a bit of a demonstration of what cell+camera can do. It's not a PS3, but it's close enough:p...
That isn't a video, that's a jpeg ;)
woops: http://www.xb360info.com/Toshiba-Cell-Demo.avi
Darkflame wrote: And the bits of what I said tha are unquoted, I praised what could be done with clever skill and coding. If the question was "can the PS3 do facial recognition with that camera", I would have said yes.
I used facial recognition as an example because I know enough about that to talk with *some* authority on how it is/can be done, specifically, using pretty terrible cameras.
Darkflame wrote: But the original statements I remember over the PS3 camera were it could do Z-depth and it would be good enough to see where your eye is looking.
I am highly skeptical these can be done reliably in software.
Its not that I dought the skill of the coders, its that I am skeptical the information is even going to be in the image to start with!

I am no image-processing expert, correct.
Yes.
All 'mainstream' CV that you will see in day to day life [i.e. eyetoy] is is miles behind what can be done when you have a beast of a machine behind you, so to base your assumptions on what can be done on experience with a tiny, tiny, subset of what is being done at the moment isn't good, which is what I was saying.

Darkflame wrote: But I can still look at a typical Hollywood movie showing images being "enhanced" and see that its bullshit.
When you have a digital image, there's a finite amount of information in it. Sometimes, no mater how much processing you can do, you wont be able too get the information you want out of it.

With the specs for the PS3 camera, I think it is very borderline if it can do either of those things. And if it can, it wont be very well.

I think its far more likely the original plans for the PS3 camera were more advanced, but were scaled back for budget reasons.
But that's not to say its useless.
640x480 @ 30fps is more than fast enough. All the bottlenecks will be in software. And as with every game ever written, it just has to make you think that what's happening is actually what's happening.
e.g. Rendering anything isn't 100% physically accurate, it's usually close enough to make you go "GOOD GOLLY, THAT LOOKS LIKE MY ACTUAL HOUSE" or whatever, but until we have machines fast enough to do stuff like lighting by using photon mapping or whatever, it's all cheating.
So if you play a next gen eyetoy game and it looks like it's tracking where you're looking, then that's good enough, even if it's not tracking your pupils to the closest mm, and instead taking cues from the direction of your body/nose and then your pupils to the nearest 2cm, will you care? probably not, because as far as you know it IS tracking where you look.

excellent, longest post from me in ages!:)
Planting a flag in the moon doesn't make it yours, 'makes a hole in the moon.
//!
User avatar
Roobarb
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1451
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 2:37 pm 0
Location: Blighty

Post by Roobarb »

Snakey wrote:
Roobarb wrote:But the design choices in the PSP hardware did result in a number of things that went against its favour:

. larger form-factor (this really kicked in with introduction of the DS Lite)
You think? It's, like, 80% screen, and personally, I think that's what sold it to a lot of people.
Roobarb wrote:. higher cost (higher spec hw)
. lower battery life
Well, I'm glad it's 'higher spec', as I'm sure are most of the people that bought the thing - and therefore it's going to cost higher... As for 'battery life', as I said before, and as a few others have said - honestly, it's not a problem.
I was just doing a SWOT analysis of the product and highlighting its weaknesses. On the other side, yes it has strengths such as a nice big screen, big game data cartridges, and better performance. The more you improve those strengths, the worse you make the weaknesses. Nintendo found a sweet-spot that has been very successful for them, Sony less so.
Snakey wrote:
Roobarb wrote:. at least in its early life, many of the games were lazy home console ports.
Huh? There might have been a few of those, but I don't think you can say 'many'. Wipeout wasn't a port and certainly wasn't lazy, and all the other games I've bought for the damn thing are pretty much PSP exclusive. (Pretty much, because stuff like Lumines has since been released on other platforms.). Either way, this isn't a design choice issue, is it?
It's more a marketing issue. If you have a powerful platform that you hype up to be 'a PS2 in your (big) pocket' you're going to encourage developers to think home console 'home console games', and stick home console style games on it. The quickest way to do that is to port a home console game, so you'll tend to get a more lazy ports. The DS on the other hand challenged developers to think of completely new games, so it tended to get more fresh ideas. Again, it looks like Nintendo found the sweetspot in the market.

And again, there's room for both: they offer different things. Sony have to rethink their loss-leading hardware business model though.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

The PSP software sales are probably suffering because it can do other things too.
Not to mention piracy issues, and playing games off memory sticks
"because they load faster" :p
Thanks for the link, interesting video :)

Another step towards our AR future :twisted:
In a generation or two's time we will all be wearing nothing but Jedi-like robes in real life,but fantastical and bezire designs around us on the augmented layer of reality.
Darkflame wrote: But I can still look at a typical Hollywood movie showing images being "enhanced" and see that its bullshit.
When you have a digital image, there's a finite amount of information in it. Sometimes, no mater how much processing you can do, you wont be able too get the information you want out of it.

With the specs for the PS3 camera, I think it is very borderline if it can do either of those things. And if it can, it wont be very well.

I think its far more likely the original plans for the PS3 camera were more advanced, but were scaled back for budget reasons.
But that's not to say its useless.
640x480 @ 30fps is more than fast enough
.

Well, I was thinking resolution was the issue, not speed.
Allthough with pointing out extra resolution can be gained from interpolenating frames inteligently then maybe speed does become an issue.
e.g. Rendering anything isn't 100% physically accurate, it's usually close enough to make you go "GOOD GOLLY, THAT LOOKS LIKE MY ACTUAL HOUSE" or whatever, but until we have machines fast enough to do stuff like lighting by using photon mapping or whatever, it's all cheating.
Absolutely. The end result is all that maters, not how you get there.
So if you play a next gen eyetoy game and it looks like it's tracking where you're looking, then that's good enough, even if it's not tracking your pupils to the closest mm, and instead taking cues from the direction of your body/nose and then your pupils to the nearest 2cm, will you care? probably not, because as far as you know it IS tracking where you look.
Good point.
But it would be hard to, say, do a mouse that way. (which, imo, would be one of the coolest things to do with it).

I think youd more likely get a system were the "where your looking at" is only sensative to a certain amount of degree intervals.
The higher res the camera, the smaller the intervals.
With 640x480 I think the intervals would be too big for many functions they could have done at higher-the-webcam spec. (specificaly, 1080p res camera would have seemed most logical given the system).
Locked