gravy wrote:If you can't accept that Nintendo have some of the best game developers on the planet your fanboyism is really causing you a problem with being objective.
Yeah, some people don't like their work but I'm at a loss to think of ANY metric you can measure a developer by that doesn't have Nintendo ranked extremely highly.
Then again look at the thread title

It's looking a little silly now
Here then I will do this in bog standard english
Four of the 20 entries are for Pokemon, wow there's a miracle in gameplay init, so many radical new ideas on their 12th iteration of that franchise keeping Ninty above the red line. Game for kids on a hand held in a monopoly and guess what they lumped THREE versions together wow that's great. Then again further down they lump TWO more Pokemon games together TWICE again to make up the numbers haha ok. Why didn't they lump all the naussiating over milked cash cow shit that saved Nintendo from bankruptcy figures together?
Pokemon = Why a lot of adults don't touch Nintendo anymore and are embarassed by the brand, people never forget the MegaCD/32x OR Pokemon if they have any class.
Also you would therefore have us believe that RARE the makers of Goldeneye STILL make the same quality games wooo yeh thats so true isn't it

Past performance in no way is an indicator of future quality. Some people wanna have Shigsys autograph, just as many want to have Yu Suzuki's too.
And how the hell is crap like Brain Age got anything to do with developer skills FFS man you really lost it there
Secondly developing simple handheld DS game like Brain Age is not the same as producing something as engaging and beautiful and complex as Lair or Lost Planet REGARDLESS OF HOW MANY THEY SELL. The Ford Escort outsold the BMW E30 probably 100 to 1, but only because there was more idiots buying more cheap tat nature of the beast really, but by your argument a Ford Escort is better than a BMW 3 Series? yeh ok mate keep going.
Ok let's have some fun with your Wiki link...
Top title of combined sales of THREE Pokemon games bought by kids or mums to shut kids up = 20m = 20m/3 = 7m average oh dear
Mario for DS sold half as much as Super Mario for NES...so does that mean Mario franchise is now 50% the quality it was on it's introduction going by the sales route
And Grand Theft Auto San Andreas complete sales for all formats not just PS2 is well over 14 million in total if you include xbox and PC sales in there (and why not it's the same game and we are judging game quality not a technical execution on a single machine)
Finally if we go the Pokemon route and add the sales of Sonic 1-4 together and get a total for the Sonic franchise how high is that?
ICO sold less than Zelda Wind Waker but I know which most people acknowledge is the better game regardless of sales, sorry it is YOU who is being the trolling fanboy today sir.
My final statistic for you then, if there were 18m copies of SMB NES sold for approx 200million consoles and 14m for 100m PS2 consoles that makes SA the greater selling game per unit bar none

(9m/100m consoles against 14m/100m consoles for the maths)
Right I'm bored with all these stats now time for a BBQ haha
*if noone else is going to be objective and compare like for like then neither will I