_TinOmen_ wrote:As you say, a good physics engine give the potential for unexpected things to happen. Perhaps that could be seen as a problem in Zelda because of its very linear nature. The game designers wants to have exact control of what the player can do.
Yes. As is often the case, the "advantage" of a physics engine is simultaneously its "disadvantage" too.
"Unexpected things happening" is good from a "varied gameplay" perspective but it's not so good from a level designer's perspective, who now has to take extra care to ensure they don't unintentionally create either an impossible situation or an accidental "cheat".
For example, on a particular level, the player has to collect a key to open a door elsewhere on the level, which is protected by a "guardian" enemy.
This could unintentionally turn into an impossible situation, when the player throws a hand grenade to kill off the "guardian" but, unintentionally, the shock wave from the explosion - which successfully kills off the guardian - also sends the key flying into the air, where it unhelpfully gets stuck amongst the decorative roof beams that the player has no way of climbing up to reach (and it gets stuck in just such a way that throwing hand grenades up to try to dislodge it doesn't work until, eventually, the player runs out of hand grenades and then runs out of options for getting the key).
Or, as an example of the opposite, the player discovers that if they jump and fire the rocket launcher straight down at the ground, the force of the rocket's explosion allows them to jump three times higher into the air than they can ordinarily (at a cost of half their health but, as long as they are stocked up on "medipacks", this isn't a problem) and using one of these "rocket jumps", the player can actually vault over the closed door - not requiring the key at all - creating an unintentional "cheat mode" in the game.
Note also that one could lead to the other: When the player exploits the "cheat mode" to vault over the closed door, they aren't killing the "guardian", which does not set off a vital "trigger" condition for something later on in the game. Thus, unintentionally setting up an "impossible condition" for completing the level later on.
Or, in short, the potential of "unexpected things happening" can unintentionally ruin the best laid plans of a level designer, screwing up all their "trigger conditions" to either make a level totally impossible or make it stupidly too easy.
Of course, this kind of problem can happen with level design without a physics engine - there are often many "exploits" in games where players discover that they can indefinitely top up their lives or score or whatever by repeatedly following a certain sequence of actions (e.g. it may be possible in, say, a platform game to collect 5 extra lives, whilst only losing one life that if you can be bothered to constantly repeat the level, you can collect up as many lives as you like).
Of course, in some games, you might consider these aspects simply an integral part of the gameplay.
For example, in the classic "Boulderdash", it was fairly easy and common to accidentally get yourself into an impossible situation (e.g. mistiming dropping a boulder on a bad guy that they didn't blow open a hole in the wall in the right place) and have to hit the "suicide" button and start again. In this case, though, it was a part of the game itself - the "puzzle" aspect of the game - that the player was supposed to use their brains to avoid accidentally creating "impossible situations".
Though, in such games, it should be made blatantly obvious to the player that they've got themselves into such a situation that they know they should hit the "suicide" button and try it again (rather than carry on for another half and hour before realising that they've been wasting their time, as the level is actually now impossible to complete).
Either that or have the game itself calculate that the mission is now impossible and end it with a "mission failed" message but one has to be careful with such an "automatic" mechanism that it never wrongly diagnoses an "impossible situation" when it is, in fact, possible - if implausible - to complete because the player might want to try anyway (or just continue playing, regardless of the fact they can't win, as some games - like Sim City or Civilization - are fun to just keep playing regardless anyway. With classic Sim City, it's basically inherently impossible to "win" in the traditional sense. You just keep going until you're bored with it).
The incorporation of some kind of "suicide" button is never a bad idea on any game where an "impossible condition" could happen. It's also a good way to "shift the blame". The truth might be that the "impossible condition" was actually just a blatant level design mistake but with the "suicide" button, you can always "shift the blame" and pretend it's a designed part of the gameplay that the player was supposed to avoid it happening, so it's their fault for not preventing it.
Basically, "unexpected things happening" is a double-edged sword. It's good because it introduces variety and extra gameplay concepts (even ones that weren't originally designed into the game at all). But it can introduce extra programming / game and level design challenges because, well, you have to make the engine / game more tolerant to all these "unexpected things happening" without it ruining the game / level.
But, really, it only requires sowing a modest amount more of being slightly more careful in the planning and design, to reap more fun, more variety, more challenge, etc. out of the game that it's usually worth the price, I'd say (in other words, my opinion would be that the Zelda games really should incorporate the physics and just use smarter level designs that can't ruin the "linear" storyline rather than not use physics at all. As long as you realise what the potential pitfalls are, it isn't that hard to design your game / levels in such a way that the "linear" part isn't jeopardized by the odd "unexpected thing happening" with the objects bouncing around a level).
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes