phattslagg wrote:Peter St. John wrote:I believe tufty's point was really that the 'England of memory' didn't exist except in our heads.
My thoughts exactly. Truth is, when we were kids, our awareness of what constituted 'England' was very narrow indeed, and most likely highly-coloured with the optimism and sheer innocence of youth. IOW, it is the state-of-being that is childhood that is being missed here.
That's part of what I was aiming at, yes. Looking back on it objectively, my childhood was great, but there was a lot of stuff that was not so great about it, mainly stuff that my parents sheltered me from, as is right and good. Stuff like "the threat of being evaporated at 4 minutes notice"...
<old fart reminiscences, feel free to skip>
Although we weren't on the poverty line (probably lower middle class), we were what would now be considered to be unbelievably poor. We didn't have a TV at all until I was 7, my clothes were mostly hand-me-downs and regularly patched up by my mother. Until I was about 10 or so, we ate meat at most once a week, and most of that came via my grandfather who had a "contact" at the slaughterhouse. God alone knows if it was "fit for human consumption" or not, I dread to think. We had a few rabbits that we'd top and eat every now and then too, and eventually we ended up with goats, pigs chickens and loads of other stuff. But as a little kid, we had jack shit. I had my first bike at age 7. It was second-hand, and crappy. But it was my bike. Apart from that, I had an action man and a football, and a load of hand-me-down lego and meccano. That's about it. We lived on the edge of the fens, and power cuts were, it seems to me, pretty much a weekly occurence. My dad had Morris Traveller van, that leaked water through the floorboards if you drove it in the rain.
This is not to say that I think my childhood was in any way disadvantaged, or even unhappy (although there were aspects of it that were unhappy, unrelated to any of the above). Thing is, it's difficult to think back to stuff like that, you filter it out.
</old fart reminiscenses>
What I mean by "society has moved on" is that my childhood, in materialistic terms, would today be considered completely unacceptable. Expectations are different. That, of course, has nothing to do with immigration, and an awful lot to do with the increasing materialism of society. I can say, looking objectively, that my kids probably have a better chance of "making it" in life than I did, there are more opportunities and a lot less class-consciousness, and the demise of the "gold watch" mentality in employment has a lot to do with that. On the other hand, they are gonna have to be willing to move for work, to work at the rate given by the market, and to accept a lack of stability that the "gold watch" generation never had to worry about.
As can probably be inferred from my general political outlook (idealist, remember), there's quite a lot of things that I don't like about the way the world has moved, and the direction it's taking, but cultural mixing and the breakdown of national boundaries don't figure in the list.
There's no denying that mass immigration of new groups into one area causes tensions, and potentially over a long period; an easy example to pick is Brixton, another is the asian communities in East London. However, eventually integration does happen to some extent because, at the end of the day, you can't live in a warzone all the time. Tolerance is the only way, but it can take generations to happen rather than weeks or months.
Like it or not, the UK is part of Europe, and the advantages work both ways. There's nothing stopping you moving to Germany, France, or even Poland, having the right to work, the right to social security and hospital care, exactly the same rights as a citizen of that country. Although salaries in absolute terms might be higher in the UK, you'll probably find that, relative to the local cost of living, there's little difference between most of the Western European countries (not so sure about Eastern Europe). As a case in point, I live better now, earning minimum wage in France, than I did as a contractor for major financial institutions in the City of London.
Whilst there are certainly some big differences in our culture nowadays, particularly regarding the sense of communal belonging, I do not believe that the influx of immigrants has much to do with this at all, and the seeds of this demise were being sown right back when things were supposedly so great.
I agree entirely.
Simon