The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
So what? Its for propergating of their brand name? :-/Kemper_Boyd wrote:Not Amazon losing money, Kingston or more probably Samsung who IDarkflame wrote:Why? That was just one of dozens of places. :-/
believe made the actual chips.
If you spend a billion on a fab, you'd better use it because it's not going
to be much use for anything else. So it's better to make some flash to
sell at a loss than let the fab idle and lose even more money.
I dont see how Kingston saleing at a lose makes them any money.
Even shipping, printing the labels and whatnot will be costing them.
If it was a temporary oversupply, I could understand, but its been like this a few months now, across many different brands.
It seems unlikely the price will go up again.
Perhaps more relevantly, however, if it is just an oversupply problem, why cant Sony also reap the benefits? After all, isn't it also better to sale to Sony then let the chips sit on warehouse shelves?
It seems unlikely for a consumer to be able to buy something cheaper then Sony can.
Part of that crash is newer fabs making it cheaper to build flash, but partDarkflame wrote:The simpler explanation is just that flash has crashed in price recently.
is the manufacturers dumping the stuff on the market at a loss.
There's nothing particularly unusual about component manufacturers losing money. Hell it's pretty much the norm.
How do they stay in buisness then? :-/
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
As I said it probably wasn't Kingston, though SanDisk did dump a lot of
stock recently, but Samsung who lost the money (or whoever the flash
manufacturer was).
It's got nothing to do with promotion or loss leading. It's really pretty
simple, several years ago they decide to build a fab to make flash,
lots of other semi companies make the same decision. When the fabs
start production there's so much flash available that prices fall below
costs. Most or all manufacturers lose money, but it's better to make
and sell the flash than have a literally billion dollar fab sit idle.
How do they stay in business? Debt mainly but some will sell up or close
down production. If cool heads prevail the next gen of fabs and flash won't
be oversupplied and prices will rise above costs, even though cost per GB
is very likely to decline.
Why does this happen? Well the lead time between deciding to build a fab
and entering production is years. It's very difficult to predict what the
market and supply will be like several years in advance and with thin
margins making a loss is all too easy.
This sort of thing happens a lot. It may well be happening to DRAM right
now judging by the way prices have fallen in the last few months.
If Sony are making a PSP Slim the issue is not the cost of flash now,
but the cost over the lifetime of the product. The cost today matters
the least.
stock recently, but Samsung who lost the money (or whoever the flash
manufacturer was).
It's got nothing to do with promotion or loss leading. It's really pretty
simple, several years ago they decide to build a fab to make flash,
lots of other semi companies make the same decision. When the fabs
start production there's so much flash available that prices fall below
costs. Most or all manufacturers lose money, but it's better to make
and sell the flash than have a literally billion dollar fab sit idle.
How do they stay in business? Debt mainly but some will sell up or close
down production. If cool heads prevail the next gen of fabs and flash won't
be oversupplied and prices will rise above costs, even though cost per GB
is very likely to decline.
Why does this happen? Well the lead time between deciding to build a fab
and entering production is years. It's very difficult to predict what the
market and supply will be like several years in advance and with thin
margins making a loss is all too easy.
This sort of thing happens a lot. It may well be happening to DRAM right
now judging by the way prices have fallen in the last few months.
If Sony are making a PSP Slim the issue is not the cost of flash now,
but the cost over the lifetime of the product. The cost today matters
the least.
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
*remembers the "Megaton" all around the Nintendo fansites*
But the question is, is the supply being used up faster then its being made yet?
Surely that has to happen before the price would start going up.
And judging by the shear number of cheap flash brands at the consumer end, quantity isn't much of a problem (both Kingston and Samsong are dirt cheap, with the lesser brands even cheaper)
Sony could buy, say a 5 million chips now and worry about price in a year or two if the PSPlite has been successful.
Personally, I think its quite unlikely the price will go up by the time they have used their first batch of chips up.
Upwards trends in prices are likely to be more on the scale of months rather then years no?
Of course, leaving chips in a good warehouse wont be free either, but if its the difference between getting the chips at sub $20 each and getting them at $60 each, I dont think storage costs will overwealm that.
Not to mention the added benifit of having your product on the market sooner.
Sure, makes sense.Kemper_Boyd wrote: Why does this happen? Well the lead time between deciding to build a fab
and entering production is years. It's very difficult to predict what the
market and supply will be like several years in advance and with thin
margins making a loss is all too easy.
But the question is, is the supply being used up faster then its being made yet?
Surely that has to happen before the price would start going up.
Not if they can buy all they need today.If Sony are making a PSP Slim the issue is not the cost of flash now,
but the cost over the lifetime of the product. The cost today matters
the least.
And judging by the shear number of cheap flash brands at the consumer end, quantity isn't much of a problem (both Kingston and Samsong are dirt cheap, with the lesser brands even cheaper)
Sony could buy, say a 5 million chips now and worry about price in a year or two if the PSPlite has been successful.
Personally, I think its quite unlikely the price will go up by the time they have used their first batch of chips up.
Upwards trends in prices are likely to be more on the scale of months rather then years no?
Of course, leaving chips in a good warehouse wont be free either, but if its the difference between getting the chips at sub $20 each and getting them at $60 each, I dont think storage costs will overwealm that.
Not to mention the added benifit of having your product on the market sooner.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
To some extent the supply does seem to have slowed a bit as the pricesDarkflame wrote:But the question is, is the supply being used up faster then its being made yet?
Surely that has to happen before the price would start going up.
today are not quite as good as a few months back. That said I think flash
is probably a money loser for most manufacturers at the moment.
It's a very bad idea to buy vast amounts of something that you expect toDarkflame wrote:Not if they can buy all they need today.
fall in price. Buy what you need when you need it.
I suspect if you actually got prices for drives with the parts Sony wouldDarkflame wrote:And judging by the shear number of cheap flash brands at the consumer end, quantity isn't much of a problem (both Kingston and Samsong are dirt cheap, with the lesser brands even cheaper)
need that the difference between the DRAMExchange prices and say
Amazon isn't as great as you might think. Sony may need high density,
very likely, and high speed parts.
5 million chips would build just over 1 million systems. If Sony did stockpileDarkflame wrote:Sony could buy, say a 5 million chips now and worry about price in a year or two if the PSPlite has been successful.
they'd probably be looking at somewhere in the region of ten times that
and half a billion dollars of flash. You don't tie up capital like that,
particularly for a commodity whose price falls.
I made clear price per GB will likely fall, costs dropping below price mayDarkflame wrote:Personally, I think its quite unlikely the price will go up by the time they have used their first batch of chips up.
occur in future in the flash manufacturers sort their act out. The cost
per GB is not likely to rise for any sustained period of time, though there
are always blips from week to week.
Where did you get $20 from?Darkflame wrote:Of course, leaving chips in a good warehouse wont be free either, but if its the difference between getting the chips at sub $20 each and getting them at $60 each, I dont think storage costs will overwealm that.
That's roughly $10 per GB, so by your own figures Sony need $80 worth4GB of Flash is already sub-£20 in lots of online stores.
not $20.
Lets call that $8 per GB, so $64 for 8GB.Surely if, as a end consumer, I can buy 4GB of Compact Flash for that price or cheaper (£17
$6 per GB, is that a price without delivery, a common trick byAmazon is saleing GB for £3.
Amazon Marketplace sellers? Even so that's $48.
Where's the $20 from?
The best I've seen was ~$5 per GB a few months back, or $40 and
almost certainly a lower density and maybe lower speed than Sony
would need.
Sure, but you seemed to be saying price would go up.Kemper_Boyd wrote:It's a very bad idea to buy vast amounts of something that you expect toDarkflame wrote:Not if they can buy all they need today.
fall in price. Buy what you need when you need it.
If that was true, then buying now would make sense, as long as it was enough of a difference to make storage worth it.
If it isnt true, then the quesition is just are they cheap enough at the moment. Which basicaly most of my last posts redundant.
umm..so we are both agreeing it will fall5 million chips would build just over 1 million systems. If Sony did stockpileDarkflame wrote:Sony could buy, say a 5 million chips now and worry about price in a year or two if the PSPlite has been successful.
they'd probably be looking at somewhere in the region of ten times that
and half a billion dollars of flash. You don't tie up capital like that,
particularly for a commodity whose price falls.
I made clear price per GB will likely fall, costs dropping below price mayDarkflame wrote:Personally, I think its quite unlikely the price will go up by the time they have used their first batch of chips up.
occur in future in the flash manufacturers sort their act out. The cost
per GB is not likely to rise for any sustained period of time, though there
are always blips from week to week.
So what does this;
mean? :-/
If Sony are making a PSP Slim the issue is not the cost of flash now,
but the cost over the lifetime of the product.
--
Also, way 5 million chips for 1 million systems?
Only 20% are usable? really?
Or if you mean that it will take 5 seperate chips at least for 8GB, then sure. I was just thinking of the cost of the unit of storage, not the chips that would make it up.
Lets call that $8 per GB, so $64 for 8GB.[/quote]Surely if, as a end consumer, I can buy 4GB of Compact Flash for that price or cheaper (£17
Well, I thought it was safe to assume the chip cost would be fraction of the cost of a typical compact flash card.
Not to mention the bulk buying power of a huge Sony order.
Surely thats going to at least alf it?
(manufactor of the rest of the card, putting the chips in, shipment, delivery, retailer cut, packaging, labeling ect...printing chips is only one stage in the process)
Sony just needs the Nand chip, not the rest of the gunk.
I'm certain buying directly the chips in bulk will give a heafty discount.
Speeds an issue, but surely all sony "needs" is fast enough to emulate a ps1 drive?a few months back, or $40 and
almost certainly a lower density and maybe lower speed than Sony
would need.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
Not in the long run, it clearly has edged up a little recently. But newDarkflame wrote:Sure, but you seemed to be saying price would go up.
fabs and new processes will lead to much lower prices.
Darkflame wrote:If that was true, then buying now would make sense, as long as it was enough of a difference to make storage worth it.
My point it that they probably aren't cheap enough to make a profit today,Darkflame wrote:If it isnt true, then the quesition is just are they cheap enough at the moment. Which basicaly most of my last posts redundant.
but Sony should care more about 6 months, 12 months and so on. It's
the future that matters not the present, So just because $60 is 'too much'
today it doesn't mean they won't do it when the same parts will be say
$30 and $15 a year or two ahead.
I think we are talking about two different things. There's been a recentDarkflame wrote:umm..so we are both agreeing it will fall
glut of flash and prices have edged up a little as that seems to be ending
but in the long term flash will fall in price. So any stockpiling you'd want
to do would only be for covering the current blip, not hedging against the
long term trend. i.e. You'd stockpile to smooth current prices but no more
than absolutely necessary.
What I meant by that is that with today's 16 Gb parts you need four chips.Darkflame wrote:Or if you mean that it will take 5 seperate chips at least for 8GB, then sure. I was just thinking of the cost of the unit of storage, not the chips that would make it up.
So 5 million would build 1.25 million systems.
No everything else is pennies compared to the flash chip. If those pricesDarkflame wrote:Well, I thought it was safe to assume the chip cost would be fraction of the cost of a typical compact flash card.
from DRAMexchange are correct flash drives and cards are sold at prices
very close to that of the flash itself. In some cases below that cost.
Flash has some funny performance characteristics. I think they'd wantDarkflame wrote:Speeds an issue, but surely all sony "needs" is fast enough to emulate a ps1 drive?
to be as fast as the UMD in all cases, and ideally faster, and if the
premium is low why not make the PSP loading much faster? The cost
of the SLC parts looks quite reasonable to me.
DRAMexchange track spot and contract prices, based on information from their clients. It's as accurate a reflection of the actual spot and contract prices OEMs and integrators are paying flash/DRAM chip manufacturers as you will find.Kemper_Boyd wrote:No everything else is pennies compared to the flash chip. If those pricesDarkflame wrote:Well, I thought it was safe to assume the chip cost would be fraction of the cost of a typical compact flash card.
from DRAMexchange are correct flash drives and cards are sold at prices
very close to that of the flash itself. In some cases below that cost.
£17 for a 4GB compact flash card (which doesn't include VAT, at least from 7dayshop) is ~$33.50, whilst the low contract price of 4GB MLC flash on June 8th was $27.2 (at today's exchange rate). As KB pointed out, the cost of the controller chip, packaging, and manufacture is pennies, and since Flash is a commodity there is very little markup for such items. The overheads of producing are compact flash card from its components are nowhere near the same as when developing, manufacturing, selling and warranting a sophisticated piece of consumer electronics.
If the commodity price of flash was a little lower a few months ago, then a 4GB compact flash part, of who knows what grade, being sold for £17 ex-VAT from a low-overhead reseller like 7dayshop is perfectly likely.
As for stocking up on flash, that would be a rather expensive mistake considering the stuff pretty much halves in price every 12months. As with all sorts of commodities trading however, i'm sure you can play games like with futures contracts, and options, to try and get a better deal.
edit: BTW, the Wii includes a 4Gbit SLC part from Samsung, which could be bought for $4.50 low-point contract price on June 8th.
PS3 backups via PS1 titles?
This could be interesting if true
http://ps3mods.blogspot.com/2007/06/ps3 ... ploit.html
This could be interesting if true
http://ps3mods.blogspot.com/2007/06/ps3 ... ploit.html

