Silicon Knights vs. Epic's Unreal Engine
What's the big deal about the UE3-Engine? Shouldn't companies develop their own engines instead. Yes, i know it's expensive. But so many titles are based on off-the-shelf middleware it's scary.
There's even a kind of "future-racer" using the Unreal-Engine. But is this engine really so good? I doubt, since its roots are ego-shooter-stuff.
Just my 2 cents, i don't have much technical background, BUT i know e.g. criterion developed their own engine for burnout and this simply rocks.
There's even a kind of "future-racer" using the Unreal-Engine. But is this engine really so good? I doubt, since its roots are ego-shooter-stuff.
Just my 2 cents, i don't have much technical background, BUT i know e.g. criterion developed their own engine for burnout and this simply rocks.
- Bubba
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10013
- Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
- PSN: BubbaFatAs
- Location: Cambridge
I suspect large chunks of the later burnouts use developments of Renderware as their engine - the earlier 2 certainly did. Renderware is (was, before it was snatched by EA?) a massively popular piece of middleware.asr4096 wrote:BUT i know e.g. criterion developed their own engine for burnout and this simply rocks.
Writing engines is expensive, especially when you can license a really good one. Seems strange that more people haven't complained about UE3 support, especially given Epic's track record. The Doom 3 tech from ID has hardly been popular, while everyone seems to have licensed UE3 - they must have their reasons. Looks like it might get some competition from Tech 5 (worst. name. evar!) from ID though.
Cheers
Bubba
It sounds like SK is just being really pissy.Anders wrote:Exactly.tentaclesex wrote:Yeah, breach of contract is breach of contract. Epic's performance in general isn't relevant.Darkflame wrote: Depends how much support SK were promised really.
The whole thing comes down to a contract issue, which we'd need to see to formulate any kind of opinion. There can be clauses saying this and that, which means anything goes.
So, they're basically saying that the reason Gears of War was any good was because it had a better 3D engine. Um, right..."That advantage was nowhere more evident than at E3 2006, where Gears of War was awarded 'Best Game in Show' and garnered nothing but laudatory press. By contrast, Silicon Knights – one of the only other [Unreal Engine 3] developers to publicly display a playable demonstration of its game – saw Too Human roundly criticized in the videogame press for its technical problems and generally unpolished appearance. The damage to Silicon Knights caused by Epic's misconduct was manifest, because E3 attendees were able to compare Too Human with another game running ostensibly the same game engine, Gears of War, with vastly superior results."
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
Well the Doom 3 engine and UE3 engine aren't equivalents. Id's engineBubba wrote:The Doom 3 tech from ID has hardly been popular, while everyone seems to have licensed UE3 - they must have their reasons.
will run on DX7 hardware whereas UE3 is DX9 or above. The Doom 3
engine is the best of the old style engines, but whilst it's technically very
clever it came at a time when hardware and developers were moving
away from fixed functionality to programmable graphics hardware.
- GrapeApe
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 661
- Joined: Sat May 13, 2006 12:21 pm 0
- Location: Yamshire, on the outskirts of Brummigem
Really??? If that's true then they really are idiots, cutting off their noses to spite their face. The UND is a god send for finding out what makes the engine tick, its been great for us pixel pushers making the leap into all that normal mapped bling that Johnny Gamer expects from his next-gen titleswhat I've heard through underground channels is SK have an internal policy which prevents their staff using UDN, emailing Epic, etc. Who knows but that's what I've heard.
-
Tuur
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2306
- Joined: Mon Dec 30, 2002 11:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: Tuur
- PSN: Tuur
- Location: Nearby
Even Epic confirmed it would be a challenge for other devs to ship an UE3 based game before they did. So yeah, 'right' seems the correct way to put it.Dave wrote:So, they're basically saying that the reason Gears of War was any good was because it had a better 3D engine. Um, right...
'People will forget that a great game was late, but they'll never forget that a game is bad.' - Shigeru Miyamoto
+1. "For your most important, mission critical stuff, you have to use a tool that is one level lower in abstraction than ideal." Of course, the precise example about DirectX sounds quite out of place in 2007. Or: "If it's a core business function -- do it yourself, no matter what."asr4096 wrote:What's the big deal about the UE3-Engine? Shouldn't companies develop their own engines instead. Yes, i know it's expensive. But so many titles are based on off-the-shelf middleware it's scary.
- teamonkey
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12082
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
- PSN: teamonkey_ca
- Contact:
Um, that article is about making the licensed product modifiable, which UE3 is - the licensee will get the source. Any game engine that is to be licensed out will be designed to be modified by the client.fred_zen wrote:for your most important, mission critical stuff, you have to use a tool that is one level lower in abstraction than ideal. (Of course, the precise example about DirectX sounds quite out of place in 2007)
It literally costs millions of dollars and hundred of thousands of man hours to develop an engine like UE3. If you want to make a game like Gears of War you can't just stick a few guys on it and give them free Bru and access to a library of OpenGL textbooks.
- Kemper_Boyd
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11967
- Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0
The vast majority of games companies couldn't produce a UE3 level
engine no matter how hard they tried. Even if they had the ability it
would take longer and cost more than virtually every game out there.
If you write your own X, you'd better be the best in at least one area,
such as cost, flexibility, portability or performance. Otherwise just don't.
engine no matter how hard they tried. Even if they had the ability it
would take longer and cost more than virtually every game out there.
If you write your own X, you'd better be the best in at least one area,
such as cost, flexibility, portability or performance. Otherwise just don't.



