Here is a list of all review scores by OXM:
http://forums.xbox.com/8875539/ShowPost.aspx
Search for this to get to the 360 section, listing games by score:
DC: The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Spell Tomes (#64)
The lowest scoring game so far has been
Totem Ball for XBLA, which got a 3.0 (it's basically a tech-demo for their web cam, and it's free). So, per the 2.0 review, Space Giraffe would be the worst Xbox 360 game ever made, per their ratings system.
You'll notice a trend that virtually all XBLA games get really low scores, and tend to stick close to the bottom of the ratings range. Well, not all of them...
To understand how shit their XBLA reviews are, lets look at one of the odd-balls:
They gave
Feeding Frenzy, an XBLA game, an 8.0 / 10.0. It's a children's game that's not revolutionary one bit, and is essentially just a remake of
Odell Lake, which was released on the Commodore 64 in 1986. You can even play Feeding Frenzy online right now for free:
http://www.shockwave.com/gamelanding/feedingfrenzy.jsp
Granted the game isn't bad for what it is, but it's not new or revolutionary in any way. If the game is still worth an 8.0 by now, Odell Lake would have been the best video game EVER made in 1986, and people should still be raving about how much fun they had with it even today. You wouldn't see a top-ten list of "best games of all time" without it being somewhere on there.