I've been a bit late to this thread, and being in a very different timezone to most of the posters I haven't had much of an opportunity to post.
I was going to leave off posting, but this quote from Giles is worth commenting on
Giles wrote:
I think we are going into a bit of "clash" between "Old School vs The Big Today" but the
thing is we are not at all fighting "the real big corporations" but
"the mentality of the people" that are not even the people in the corps
but are "the people on the streets".
Llamasoft aren't actually fighting against the big boys, after all they have Microsofts backing to release this, I don't persobally think it's even an old school versus todays epics.
I just think they're forging a slightly different path than the others but using a full on modern artillary.
As such it's bound to start noising some people up the wrong way, and some folks simply aren't going to get it. In the long run I genuinely believe that Space Giraffe and other Llamasoft games are going to establish themselves as a vibrant vein of gaming in the mainstream, but it could be tough mining for a while.
There are two things that upset me about this review though:
1) It was the first one that was published, this is unfortunate from a timing perspective as it sours what should be a time of Euphoria for Jeff and Giles, ie. the calm before the storm - after all until it's out in the wild it can't upset anybody.
2) if I'd written a review and felt the need to give it a 2.0, or I was the editor and such a review had been submitted to me, it would have raised alarm bells and I would have felt the need to sanity check my decision. Even if I was going to stick to my guns or back my journalist, I think I'd be looking for a sidebar or "2nd opinion" box to balance things out, because it would seem that there isn't anything technically or fundamentally wrong with the game, it's just not an individuals cup of tea. Lets see if there is a breakout box or balanced opinion in the final piece (otherwise I may have to side with those pointing out that this is a piece of cuntery)
(400points at the ready BTW)