To be honest at the moment the review doesn't seem to have hit the net in any significant way apart from a couple of forums. I'd just leave it. At least until more reviews start coming out. Like I said earlier most people posting to the OXM threads elsewhere are only interested in new Halo 3 info.Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
The definitive Space Giraffe thread
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
- The Caffeine Kid
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5691
- Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2004 9:24 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: TheCaffeineKid
- PSN: caffeinekid
- Yahoo Messenger: caffeinekid
- Location: Wakefield
- Contact:
n0 bioshock reveiw = teh l0se!HGFB wrote:To be honest at the moment the review doesn't seem to have hit the net in any significant way apart from a couple of forums. I'd just leave it. At least until more reviews start coming out. Like I said earlier most people posting to the OXM threads elsewhere are only interested in new Halo 3 info.Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
Mmm... probably not wise - at least until someone digs out the actual content of the article. At the moment, everything's based on extrapolation (the review score, his highscore, a single excerpt from the article); better by far to wait until there's something concrete to use as a basis.Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
Even then, it may be better to hold back further comment, as there's a risk of being tagged as petty. Once more reviews have come in (which I'd hope will generally be much more positive), it'll be possible to highlight the review's failings - and the reviewer's failings, if such there are.
In the meantime, hopefully this will cheer people up (assuming Picasa lets you view the image - if not, go for the click!
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
I wouldn't comment on perceived performances. It's guesswork, and whilst could well be correct, it could also be horribly wrong. Often people play on the first account that's available, and with dev kits prone to being borrowed you'll often use someone else's machine if need be. What you're looking at could be someone else's game, with him using a different account entirely. If you looked at my one of my friends accounts you'd think he's doing mildly-OKish at the game, when in truth he's played it very little, and you'd be judging mostly my performances.Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
I might be tempted to comment on the review on the blog (after reading it obviously), but simply stating the facts - that you knew it was never going to be everyone's NCoT, but you're surprised and disappointed (both by the score and that he didn't like the game), and (if the review doesn't make it clear) that you'd like to know the thinking behind the score. IMO, it'll come across a lot better if you take it on the chin, roll with the punch, and then leave it in the past. It might be hard to ignore, but there's nothing to be gained from getting personal - it'll only get messy.
Perhaps write what you'd like to post first to get it out of your system, then delete it and write something that you can post afterwards. It helps for me.
But as others have said - it may be better to just leave it.
Last edited by Mark on Sat Aug 18, 2007 8:17 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Personally, I'd hold off until you have other reviews available to compare OXM against. If OXM is way off from other reviews, you've got ample permission to smash their review to bits on the blog. Plus having the full text is critical - nobody seems to have that yet.Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
Right now, I don't think anyone outside of YakYak really cares about that OXM review at the moment, and everyone in here is going to buy the game anyway because we trust your experience (both Giles and Jeff), along with the bits beta-testers have fed us (OMFG).
i think thats what i was driving at slightly with my (oblique) comments about you doing an edge column about the whole affair, but yeah, forgetting to actually send it to them after you've written it would cause much less shitMark wrote: Perhaps write what you'd like to post first to get it out of your system, then delete it and write something that you can post afterwards. It helps for me.
in any case given the power of google i expect the man himself'll be along in a bit to explain himself, or i suppose you could drop him an email like you did that other guy, i thought that turned out alright in the end...
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Isn't it anyway quite wrong that someone somewhere can just throwDave wrote:Personally, I'd hold off until you have other reviews available to compare OXM against. If OXM is way off from other reviews, you've got ample permission to smash their review to bits on the blog. Plus having the full text is critical - nobody seems to have that yet.Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
Right now, I don't think anyone outside of YakYak really cares about that OXM review at the moment, and everyone in here is going to buy the game anyway because we trust your experience (both Giles and Jeff), along with the bits beta-testers have fed us (OMFG).
"a shite score" in quite a visible place without being backed up by any
explanation leaving all the people just making assumptions and not having
anything "solid" to compare/discuss about.
If they can do so "and put us in the shite" why then can't we say anything.
Should it be then better even for them "not to say anything until they
have some text to go with" ?
Why they should then have the right to throw shite and leave people in
the shite without giving any reason and hiding behind "formalisms" ?
Is that "proper journalism" ? Is that "a jobe well done" ?
I think not ! I think this is a job made with the arse and someone should
be responsible for it, in this case the editor and the curator of the OXM website.
The problem is in throwing numbers "they have power to make bad and
good weather" before to even clarify what they said.
To say "2 because I think this and that" and to throw a "2" well before
anything else is said but leave people in the blank with speculations is
very damaging.
I am sure would LS be some US big company there would be already a
lawsuit againist OXM because we could claim "image damages" as
in the way they done the thing ( not publising the FULL review text AND the vote together ) they mis-conditioned the user.
Think about it .. do you think I could not really try a court with that and
discuss the system of publishing information ? I think if I really would like I'd be able to.
I don't discuss here the reasons he gave 2, he could have all the reasons
he want but I discuss a fact he threw out that thing without the reasons
well knowing that an act like that can well be damaging.
I think more than once that all the "internet thing" and responsibilities of acts
should be well reconsidered.
From a "professional point of view" I could say "OXM is UNprofessional"
and that kind of work is "done with the arse".
That's based on the way to work.
Give a vote AND explain why and everyone will be happy and able to
make a real talk about it.
Work like that and to me is arse, I think that's the biggest fault in all that.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
As has been mentioned before I don't think MS actually have much to do with OXM at all, it's just a licensing deal.
Anyway I think it's best just to let the game speak for itself really. It's true that some people will just dismiss it and go "wahh wahh too bright couldn't see anything waah" and hey, so be it, their loss. What is certain is that those who do like "that kind of thing" will absolutely love SG
.
Anyway I think it's best just to let the game speak for itself really. It's true that some people will just dismiss it and go "wahh wahh too bright couldn't see anything waah" and hey, so be it, their loss. What is certain is that those who do like "that kind of thing" will absolutely love SG
Justified and Ancient.
- PVB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 32542
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 10:16 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: PVBuk
- PSN: PVBuk
- Location: Medway, U.K.
There's a few here:gilesgoat wrote:I have quite a lot ...Fuseball wrote:Any chance you guys could get some more eye-popping screengrabs out into the wild? Seems like there's only a couple of pics being constantly recycled by the media.
I'm sure the punters are geting a bit tired of seeing the same old pic every time they read about SG. It's by no means one of the best levels either.
Want something specific ? PM me ?
We did quite a number of HD snaps for Famitsu time ago.
http://www.medwaypvb.com/giraffe2.html
Edit:
I really should read all the new posts before posting, shouldn't I?Yak wrote: I've linked some more SG resources off the launch blog page, a whole bunch of screenies and links to the videos again.
Edit2:
I take it the re-direct from http://www.llamasoft.co.uk to go straight to the blog is intentional?
Last edited by PVB on Sat Aug 18, 2007 8:48 pm 0, edited 2 times in total.
My advice would be, no at least to start with, if you want to counter it do it a bit indirectly... kind of "Its possible to play SG badly, which might not be that fun, heres some tips....".Yak wrote:I'm wondering if I should use the launch blog to pre-empt the OXM nonsense by mentioning it and then pointing out our analysis of his Partnernet leaderboard entry and showing that he played it like a complete moron, or whether we should just deal with that as it arises... thoughts?
HS had similar problems when the demo hit PSN, some people concluded "crap game, combat is crap, not buying" without really trying to play it as intended. Tam made some forum posts with a few hints and advice and that seems to help.
Anyway I want my SG!! damn working on PS3 and not getting access to partnernet
Don't folks post the Edge scores in here without any reviews or text to back them up? I never see anyone complain about that...
But anyway, I'm intrigued by what the review text contains myself but c'mon folks, this is getting mental now when there's suggestions of setting MS on the magazine to sort them out.
What Jeff said really. Let the game do the talking, it looks spankingly sexy - Andy's write up isn't just glowing, its glorious and all the testamonials so far seem to agree.
Better to look to the future, no? I hear its kinda bright...and glowy, and a bit oily at times...
New screenshots are fucking lush, btw.
But anyway, I'm intrigued by what the review text contains myself but c'mon folks, this is getting mental now when there's suggestions of setting MS on the magazine to sort them out.
What Jeff said really. Let the game do the talking, it looks spankingly sexy - Andy's write up isn't just glowing, its glorious and all the testamonials so far seem to agree.
Better to look to the future, no? I hear its kinda bright...and glowy, and a bit oily at times...
New screenshots are fucking lush, btw.
\m/





