fog wrote:Have to admit that doesn't make good reading as, like it or not and agree with it or not, he at least makes some attempt at justifying his reasons for giving it a low mark. And he does indicate that he isn't the only one that played it which would suggest he did get a second opinion.
"Suggest" doesn't mean it's true, though. I suspect it's more a case of the "royal we" in this case where he's just trying to make himself look more credible through invoking OXM as a compound entity rather than individual shit gamer that he actually is.
And "failed game"? They've reviewed it before it's even out, how can they call it "failed" anything?
I've seen loads of people play SG by now and most of them have loved it. I've *never* seen anyone score so spectacularly badly as "OXM Dan" on the Partnernet leaderboards.
I know that SG simply won't be liked by some people; the way in which it works to put players in the zone is a kind of insistant synaesthesia, something with which the player has to willingly collude. For those people who enjoy that, SG will be the best thing they've ever played. For those who hate that kind of thing then I guess they'll moan and whinge about how they can't see anything and, well, boo-hoo, sucks to be you, but hey, that's what downloadable demos are for.
Doesn't make SG a "failed" anything. Doesn't make it bad at what it does - it does that very well indeed, as you can see from Sickers' review and the opinions of those who "get it".
The fact that someone calling himself the "senior editor" of *anything* can't understand that, and tries to claim that somehow SG is intrinsically bad rather than just something that he personally doesn't like, is simply shameful, and if I thought he might be a shitcock before, I *know* he's a shitcock now, and a hugely incompetent one to boot.
Anyway, the game will speak for itself. There will be people who really enjoy it a lot, and there will be people who don't care for it, and like I said, that's what demo downloads are for.
Justified and Ancient.