The definitive Space Giraffe thread
Yeah I've read all of that.Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote: And in any case, you are of course dodging the issue and shifting the goalposts again. Jeff's allegation was, and I quote:
Note the plural, there. Jeff claims that ALL of my reviews of his work are biased and prejudiced, even though they date back to the early 1990s and even then I praised his work (Super Gridrunner, yay!) as much as criticised it (Photon Storm, boo!). I've already covered all this, but you choose to ignore it because it completely fucks up the allegation of prejudice and there's no way to reply to it without admitting you're wrong. Which is the point I made an hour or so ago.his personal dislike of me taints his reviews
I'm pretty sure the plural refers to the SG review and the T3k one not everything you've ever written ever. Again that's a serious bit of writing tainted again with a few personal attacks on Jeff's approach to making the game ("half-arsed", "ill-thought-out", "sheer arrogant cuntery", cheers forum search).
It's patently clear from the fact that what you think about these games isn't the key thing here however much you try and steer the conversation that way.
The SG and T3k reviews are chalk and cheese in terms of critical response, the only similarity between both pieces is your choice to personalise it and, crivens jings what a surprise, it's been taken personally.
Yeah I know, it taints your reviews, duh!I do think Jeff is a colossally-hypocritical paranoid twat.
- Rev. Stuart Campbell
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3995
- Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
- Location: From Heck
Um, there's so much utter bullshit in that sentence I'm not sure I have time to cover it all in the hour before I have to leave for my poker game. Help me out and quote me some of the "vile, insulting bad treatment" Jeff's had to endure on WoSF, there's a dear.HGFB wrote:You're a bit obsessed really. If you really were thick skinned like you say you wouldn't keep coming back here time after time whenever anyone calls you a miserable irrelevant cunt. The enablers comment would only really work if you didn't have your own forums where just the same things go on only much, much more vile and insulting. Or would you like to argue that you've been treated as badly here as Jeff has on your forums?Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:But then, that's because I'm not insanely, debilitatingly thin-skinned and paranoid, and surrounded by enablers.
Yes, that's an excellent summary of the posts on, for example, this page. No attempt whatsoever to discuss the issue there. And this post is certainly just "firing off some insults", rather than a calm and reasoned explanation, backed up by evidence, as to why the allegations of prejudice are ridiculous:Of course when anyone dares to argue with your magnificence you fall back on your normal tactic of just firing off some insults about their intelligence.
http://www.yakyak.org/viewtopic.php?p=1 ... id#1187600
(It was completely ignored, of course, in favour of - guess what? - the firing off of some lame one-line insults.)
As far as I know, the trigger as far as this forum goes was the Tempest 3000 review on my website. Even though many people on this very forum argued that it was a reasoned, honest and heartfelt point of view, Jeff's never forgiven me for it, and has since revealed his bitterness about past reviews, primarily of Defender 2000. I've tried many times to resolve it in a rational, reasoned and calm manner, including by PM, but it never works because Jeff can never get past the fact that I've harshly criticised some of his work and finds it more comfortable to pretend that I have some personal vendetta against him, in the face of all the available evidence (namely that he's never done anything to me to cause such a thing, and that I've been effusively positive about as many of his games as I've slagged off).Serious questions: What started all this? And what's stopping you trying to resolve it, instead of just feeding the flames?
And no, I don't think I've got anything about Photon Storm archived.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
- Rev. Stuart Campbell
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3995
- Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
- Location: From Heck
And there, I believe, I shall safely rest my case. Time for some poker, where you actually get paid for knowing when people are talking shite.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
- Tetra Elemental
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1225
- Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 8:08 pm 0
- Location: Earth
- Rev. Stuart Campbell
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3995
- Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
- Location: From Heck
I truly have no idea what you mean by that, since you've just quoted "personal attacks" in both the T3K and SG pieces (though in fact nothing you've quoted qualifies for such a description). And why should they be similar? One's a review of a brilliant game and one's a review of a shit-awful one. You'd logically expect a rather different tone. And yet still, if the T3K piece contains "personal attacks" then the Defender 2000 ones on my site do too, and those are from 1995, so what your point is fuck only knows.gravy wrote: The SG and T3k reviews are chalk and cheese in terms of critical response, the only similarity between both pieces is your choice to personalise it and, crivens jings what a surprise, it's been taken personally.
And, y'know, I hate to point out the obvious, but in a Top 100,000 list of people fit to give pious lectures about personal attacks, you don't even make it into the also-rans.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
You may not agree that your T3k review is laced with personal digs but if you've a memory even slightly more bale than a goldfish you do know what I'm "on about". There was a 23 page thread car crash of thread after where a number of people took exception to you personalising the review rather than how you critiqued the game and accompanied with a spectacular display of sturettes.Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:I truly have no idea what you mean by that, since you've just quoted "personal attacks" in both the T3K and SG pieces (though in fact nothing you've quoted qualifies for such a description).gravy wrote: The SG and T3k reviews are chalk and cheese in terms of critical response, the only similarity between both pieces is your choice to personalise it and, crivens jings what a surprise, it's been taken personally.
Yeah, yeah. You're this, you're that, your mum.Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:And, y'know, I hate to point out the obvious, but in a Top 100,000 list of people fit to give pious lectures about personal attacks, you don't even make it into the also-rans.
Why are you here? You're obviously spoiling for a fight in this last slew of posts. First you pop over to call me a liar by implication, then you defend the incredibly shoddy work of OXM Dan (someone on your own forum you've branded an idiot) then it's yet more invective about Jeff, then about this forum and now back to abusing me.
- Rev. Stuart Campbell
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3995
- Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
- Location: From Heck
Hmm, yes. Well, since you bring it up, let's revisit "that" thread, shall we?gravy wrote: You may not agree that your T3k review is laced with personal digs but if you've a memory even slightly more bale than a goldfish you do know what I'm "on about". There was a 23 page thread car crash of thread after where a number of people took exception to you personalising the review rather than how you critiqued the game and accompanied with a spectacular display of sturettes.
Romanista, a user of both WoS and YakYak forums, posted a notice about the T3K piece, saying "* this thread is not meant to start a discussion about stuart but to discuss his arguments *"
He was responded to by Giles on page 2:
So there's where the insults started - from Llamasoft, directed at someone who hadn't posted ANY criticism of them or their games whatsoever. Next up was Hairy Pete, who called my observations about the game "whining", but I didn't rise to it and discussed the issue in a civil and polite way. Nothing much happens for the next few pages, except HP talking a load of ridiculous bollocks about there being no such thing as "left" and "right" in Tempest, which is pretty funny. Jeff and I both post, disagreeing strongly but without flinging any abuse at each other, until Bog decides on page 6 that a useful and constructive contribution would be to call meGiles wrote:You wanted reactions to what you wrote ?
Ok, here mine, I think you Romanista you are simply a miserable fool
To which I retort by calling him a "humourless arsewit". Then, flying somewhat mystifyingly in the face of the evidence, Disciple suddenly pops up with:Bog wrote:You pompous cunt.
(Actual chronology of insulting posts: Giles>>Hairy Pete>>Bog>>me.)Disciple wrote:Look, it's bloody simple, it's always seems to be *you* that brings the discussions down to a personal level, it's *you* that starts with the personal insults and lowers the level of the discussions. If you really can't see that then it's no wonder you're consistently disappointed.
Things then settle down a bit and we have a slightly fractious but still basically civil exchange of debate for another couple of pages, until Jeff decides to add these helpful and positive lines on page 8:
I note that this post is "petulant" and "boring" (difficult to contest, really), to which Jeff responds that all of mine are "rabid semi-literate shit-flinging", in fairly striking disregard of the obvious facts. It seems pretty clear which direction all the escalation of abuse is coming from in this debate so far. Round about here you wade in with a spectacularly clumsy piece of point-missing, and Thalamus continues his dogged attempts to have reason prevail by posting lots of extremely rational and sensible points, but is ignored by the baying hordes. Nevertheless, the debate continues at no particularly alarming temperature, despite the likes of WinterMute weighing in by calling me:Yak wrote:blah blah rant fume shit rubbish blah blah you are all so thick blah blah blah fanboys not at all like the people on my own vanity site blah blah blah useless blah rant rant oh oh look look at me everyone...
*yawn*
and posting some implied threats about what would happen to me if I turned up at a Retrovision event. Nevertheless, there's still no great abuse (certainly not from me, despite the likes of the above), and on page 14 Elizian comes in with a long, reasoned, detailed, thoughtful and rational defence of T3K, which I respond to in a long, reasoned, detailed, thoughtful and rational way, adding:WinterMute wrote:a self rigteous [sic], arrogant, egotistical little prick hiding behind the internet
Then the same thing happens with skip and Defender 2000. We have a nice, detailed, grown-up and polite disagreement about it, with Fuseball later joining in with some interesting chat and debate, and everything's rather pleasant for a while, with even a few good-natured jokes. Oddly, at this point TT decides that:me wrote:Wow. Just 14 pages in and someone's finally constructed a reasoned argument. However much I might disagree with the following, respect to you.
Hilariously, after this startling and unprovoked personal attack he then tries to claim the moral high ground, and things go downhill, not least when you pipe up with some link five years old to me arguing with someone on a newsgroup (apparently trying to make some point about my ego), and then Bog comes in with a wildly over-the-top attack and that's pretty much it for anything worthwhile. But that's page 18 of the 23, and until then I've actually been extremely reasonable in the face of several unprovoked personal insults. Even after that, the only real nastiness is between Bog and me, and it's pretty clear who started that, way back on page 6.TT wrote:The main reason the thread is still going is because Stuart "Listen to me you cunts" Campbell is whining like a spoilt two year old because people are disagreeing with him.
So actually, all your "car-crash" thread proves is that:
1. Llamasoft started the name-calling, insulting someone for merely alerting people that there was a review to read.
2. Despite strong feelings on both sides, most of the thread was actually a very reasonable, adult and civil discussion, with the exception of a bit of a petulant sulk from Jeff when it didn't go all his way and some people had the temerity to agree with bits of my review.
3. The overwhelming majority of the witless abusive insulting was directed AT me, not FROM me, I didn't start any of it, and your only contribution was a series of attemped goading attacks on me which I didn't rise to.
You seem unable to distinguish criticism of a piece of game design from personal criticism of the designer. Except I'm sure you can, because you're not a total cretin, so the only conclusion it's possible to draw is that you're the one who's trolling here. I shouldn't even try to respond reasonably to it, I guess, but I've got nothing else to do this morning while I wait for the guy to turn up with my new fridge, and I do find it reassuring to go back and check the facts and make sure that you ARE just talking hypocritical antagonistic pish as usual. And the empirical, observable truth of that thread is that almost nobody "took exception to you personalising the review rather than how you critiqued the game", and "a spectacular display of sturettes" was in fact merely a brief flurry of insults exchanged at the very end, with someone who offensively and repeatedly attacked me first.
Hey ho. If you're going to try Stalinist rewriting of history, Gaz, it's probably best not to actually post links to things that prove you wrong in black and white.
Last edited by Rev. Stuart Campbell on Tue Sep 11, 2007 10:48 am 0, edited 1 time in total.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
- Glyndwr
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3802
- Joined: Thu Jul 17, 2003 5:12 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: glyn_richards2003
- Location: Norwich
Oooh! I'd like to see this list. Do you have it? Was it in FHM?Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote: but in a Top 100,000 list of people fit to give pious lectures about personal attacks
Please post it.
Thanks.
Code: Select all
public class Geeks : TheEarth {
}- Rev. Stuart Campbell
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3995
- Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
- Location: From Heck
Sadly I don't have the full list (with 100,000 names it's too big to cut-and-paste in Notepad), but Bonnie Langford, Mother Theresa and Cliff Richard took the top 3 spots, Hitler came in at a surprisingly high 24,559th (apparently the vegetarianism counted in his favour), and poor Gaz was nowhere to be seen.Glyndwr wrote:Oooh! I'd like to see this list. Do you have it? Was it in FHM?Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote: but in a Top 100,000 list of people fit to give pious lectures about personal attacks
Please post it.
Thanks.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
- Glyndwr
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3802
- Joined: Thu Jul 17, 2003 5:12 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: glyn_richards2003
- Location: Norwich
I agree with you on the Bonnie Langford and Cliff Richard thing.Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote:Sadly I don't have the full list (with 100,000 names it's too big to cut-and-paste in Notepad), but Bonnie Langford, Mother Theresa and Cliff Richard took the top 3 spots, Hitler came in at a surprisingly high 24,559th (apparently the vegetarianism counted in his favour), and poor Gaz was nowhere to be seen.Glyndwr wrote:Oooh! I'd like to see this list. Do you have it? Was it in FHM?Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote: but in a Top 100,000 list of people fit to give pious lectures about personal attacks
Please post it.
Thanks.
Is Orville in it?
Code: Select all
public class Geeks : TheEarth {
}Yeah, yeah. A funny long list. We get it. You need a new thing, big guy. We've seen it before. Isn't time you got a new thing?Rev. Stuart Campbell wrote: Sadly I don't have the full list (with 100,000 names it's too big to cut-and-paste in Notepad), but Bonnie Langford, Mother Theresa and Cliff Richard took the top 3 spots, Hitler came in at a surprisingly high 24,559th (apparently the vegetarianism counted in his favour), and poor Gaz was nowhere to be seen.


