
Nicely put.
Also, Id say Advanced Wars is an S rank game myself, despite being far less in budget then probably any PS3 game.
I really dont see the point in continueing,. I mean, what a supprise, Im forced to pull those numbers out of thin air and then someone complains they are inconsistant.
AAA is a quality factor.
When most people agree something is AAA then it IS AAA.
Its self defineing, I dont know how else I can put it.
Its like trying to discribe what Sour tastes like, or what Blue looks like.
I just picked 95% of the top of my head. I made that very clear.
I dont give a rats arse if WiiSports wasnt there.
I didnt even say those games were AAA, I said "I believe they are", you would need to do a servay and such to see what the general impressions are.
I hoped someone wouldnt be so stupid as to use my inaccurate guess's of AAA games as a counter-point to my argument, evidently I was wrong.
So, if people like FOG insist on painting me into a corner, twisting my words, all so they could try to paint the Nintendo fanboy image back on me, when all I'm trying to merely define what is a common expression.
Maybe I was wrong about Wii Sports, sure.
Sorry, but its you painting that on me, I didnt even look at metacritic, I never claimed too, I been merely trying to pin down what is "AAA".
Hay, if you want to belief the PS3 has more AAA games then the Wii at the moment, then I rearly dont care.
That wasnt the point of what I was saying.
With regards to quality vs. budget, for a AAA game the quality is linked to the budget. You get mocap rather than hand-drawn animations, spoken dialogue for every line (usually by Wil Wheaton), high-budget CGI cutscenes, an expensive but solid engine, professional writers, high-value brands and names (Tom Clancy etc.), larger permanent staff, etc. etc.
A Hollywood blockbuster, essentially.
But not all "Hollywood blockbusters" are AAA are they
Its certain that there is a relationship between money and result, but the AAA result can come without the high budget.
(and likewise, a high budget can result in a certainly less then AAA reasult)
Thats why I say "AAA" is directly about quality (or, "average percieved quality", if you like), but I admit budget is a major influeceing factor to that.
It's a marketing term so it's nebulous at best. Smile
In theory it should be a continuous scale, but if you look at the games that are published and promoted you see that they all fall into one of the discreet categories. The publisher model is designed around producing only AAA-titles. Most games reviewed in magazines are AAA-titles. If it hasn't invested much cash into it, or if it doesn't think that promotion is worth it for whatever reason, the publisher might cut its losses as an A-title, but really it wants to reinvest that cash into where there's more profit. B-titles are different beasties altogether - those Burger King games, for example.
Again, this may be how its like from the inside, but to an average Gamer,I am sure there is hundreds of games that had huge budgets yet wouldnt in a million years be called AAA.
The gameing world has its WaterWorlds too.
AAA for developers may be budget, but for players/reviewers its overall quality.