iPhone
Hmmm, thats even more expensive than I thought it would be.
The thing is, nobody spends £269 on a phone, least of all when it's on an 18 month £35 contract. You expect the phone for free. In reality you're paying for the phone over an 18 month period so I can't see why it's so expensive.
Can't see it being a hit to be honest.
The thing is, nobody spends £269 on a phone, least of all when it's on an 18 month £35 contract. You expect the phone for free. In reality you're paying for the phone over an 18 month period so I can't see why it's so expensive.
Can't see it being a hit to be honest.
- WiteWulf
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10125
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
- PSN: WiteWulf
- Location: Loughborough(ish)
Aye...they had a head start in The States as mobile phones are generally way behind Europe, feature-wise, and the iPhone really stood out from the crowd. They're gonna have a much harder time selling it over here, especially at those prices, imho.
:::G:::
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
See I would have thought Apple being Apple, they would have just flogged the phone out the box sim-free. Disrupt the market and all that, rather than going for the call revenue (which is presumably part of the deal with o2?
Last edited by TT on Tue Sep 18, 2007 12:39 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Be strong, and Shout at the Devil...
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
I did some arithmetic on my bike on the way into the office.
Let's assume that Apple get 50% of the retail cost (they probably do better than this, but that's a typical retail assumption).
So that's £130 a unit, more or less. At the reported 40% revenue share, after tax, they get about £6 a month per customer - or around £70 a year. In total, therefore, a customer's worth £200 to Apple in the first year in revenue (plus about £35 in the second).
How many customers? Let's assume 50m mobile phones in the UK, replaced once every three years - so that's about 15m handsets a year. Let's assume Apple get 1% of that, so that's 150,000 customers.
So in the first year, you're looking at 200*150,000 = £30m in revenue to Apple a year. If my back of the envelope calculation's right, this isn't actually *that* big a deal straight away...
Let's assume that Apple get 50% of the retail cost (they probably do better than this, but that's a typical retail assumption).
So that's £130 a unit, more or less. At the reported 40% revenue share, after tax, they get about £6 a month per customer - or around £70 a year. In total, therefore, a customer's worth £200 to Apple in the first year in revenue (plus about £35 in the second).
How many customers? Let's assume 50m mobile phones in the UK, replaced once every three years - so that's about 15m handsets a year. Let's assume Apple get 1% of that, so that's 150,000 customers.
So in the first year, you're looking at 200*150,000 = £30m in revenue to Apple a year. If my back of the envelope calculation's right, this isn't actually *that* big a deal straight away...
- WiteWulf
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10125
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
- PSN: WiteWulf
- Location: Loughborough(ish)
Which would explain why they're so keen to keep a percentage of the revenue from the carrier coming in rather than just selling it as a carrier-free device. Apple are obviously banking on this being a long-term money-spinner for them.Acronym wrote: So in the first year, you're looking at 200*150,000 = £30m in revenue to Apple a year. If my back of the envelope calculation's right, this isn't actually *that* big a deal straight away...
:::G:::
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
-
offyoutoddle
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2644
- Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
- Location: London
- Contact:
I think this will sell in the UK, despite it being an atrocious deal. It's apple. Have a look in the macrumors forums and watch the usual 'apple can do no wrong' crowd at work on this already.
No 3g - Edge isn't really that big over here, without 3g this will be sloooowwwww when there is no wifi. Yet we get a load of guff about battery length that the faithful swallow whole heartedly. I'm sure it will do better with battery life as a 2g phone, but I have an e65, it has wifi and it is 3g. That lasts about 2 days with moderate to heavy use, 3-4 with virtually no use. Even taking into account using it to play music and video a lot, which I do also on my e65 via the sling player (which the iphone doesn't have). If a phone lasts a day, that will suit most people. A charge a night is no hardship, and at least you know where you stand - a day and a half is a pain in the arse
Price - UK market does not expect an 18 month lock in on contract, over 25 a month rental plus you have to pay 269 for a phone. Frankly this sort of deal is ridiculous - the iphone just isn't good enough to justify this.
Comparing the rest of the technologies in this phone to the phones available to the American market, the iphone looks incredible. In the UK market it doesn't look so special, other than the interface. It wouldn't do half of what my e65 will do though, so I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. Logically this shouldn't do too well over here - expensive tariffs, expensive phone, lacklustre technologies. However, I bet it will sell because most apple stuff will sell as long as there are people who value the classic apple 'style over substance' approach.
I'm not an apple hater, quite the contrary, I love my mac's but I'm not blinkered to their ways.
The biggest danger I think is that if this does work out for Apple, we could see other vendors and networks try it on in the same way, and spell the end of the good deals we enjoy in the UK today.
Think I'll be getting my touch instead....
No 3g - Edge isn't really that big over here, without 3g this will be sloooowwwww when there is no wifi. Yet we get a load of guff about battery length that the faithful swallow whole heartedly. I'm sure it will do better with battery life as a 2g phone, but I have an e65, it has wifi and it is 3g. That lasts about 2 days with moderate to heavy use, 3-4 with virtually no use. Even taking into account using it to play music and video a lot, which I do also on my e65 via the sling player (which the iphone doesn't have). If a phone lasts a day, that will suit most people. A charge a night is no hardship, and at least you know where you stand - a day and a half is a pain in the arse
Price - UK market does not expect an 18 month lock in on contract, over 25 a month rental plus you have to pay 269 for a phone. Frankly this sort of deal is ridiculous - the iphone just isn't good enough to justify this.
Comparing the rest of the technologies in this phone to the phones available to the American market, the iphone looks incredible. In the UK market it doesn't look so special, other than the interface. It wouldn't do half of what my e65 will do though, so I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole. Logically this shouldn't do too well over here - expensive tariffs, expensive phone, lacklustre technologies. However, I bet it will sell because most apple stuff will sell as long as there are people who value the classic apple 'style over substance' approach.
I'm not an apple hater, quite the contrary, I love my mac's but I'm not blinkered to their ways.
The biggest danger I think is that if this does work out for Apple, we could see other vendors and networks try it on in the same way, and spell the end of the good deals we enjoy in the UK today.
Think I'll be getting my touch instead....
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
I think that's a really fair statement.WiteWulf wrote:Aye...they had a head start in The States as mobile phones are generally way behind Europe, feature-wise, and the iPhone really stood out from the crowd. They're gonna have a much harder time selling it over here, especially at those prices, imho.
Most people who got iPhones in the states, at least the peeps I know, got them part for the status symbol (bragging rights), and the overall "coolness" of the phone. A few iPod converts too, no doubt.
None bought it because it was cheap, and functionality wise, other phones do a lot more than the iPhone does already (asides from the built-in iPod). UI-wise, Apple is unique for the time being.
Also, it's selling for $399 in the States for the 8GB model. Your model is going for £269 ($539), a whole $140 more expensive. I dunno if the pricing in the cell plans make up for it or not. The cheapest plan you can get with AT&T is $60/month, plus tax, with a 2-year agreement.
I personally hate cell phone plans. I use pay-as-you-go with Virgin Mobile, and average about $10/month in cell phone costs.
Yup, I do the same with Cingular/AT&T with a $10 phone from Wal-Mart. Certainly the US market lags quite a distance behind the UK and Europe in general. I actually find the mobile phone retail outlets here *more* depressing than the ones in the UK and those are real cathedrals of anguish and despair. It was like browsing round one of those now defunct small Virgin stores. Shelves full of tedious guff with the over-bearing store branding sucking the very life-essence out of every mindless customer. Fones4U (how terribly modern) seemed to only employ young spiky haired aggressive sales droids in pinstripe suits who were waving contracts under your nose the very nano-second you walked into the shop and seemed to say words like "mate" and "wicked" as if they were actually an old school friend. I actually became a BMW 3 Series whilst I was there.Dave wrote:I personally hate cell phone plans. I use pay-as-you-go with Virgin Mobile, and average about $10/month in cell phone costs.
And Carphonewarehouse were so mind-crushingly bland and bourgeois I genuinely felt suicidal just walking past one. I'm pretty convinced they wouldn't sell you anything if you weren't wearing a nice check shirt, slacks and shoes, and wanted to talk about cricket. Once you enter and (hopefully) leave these stores, a child in Africa dies. Every single time, remember that.
The iPhone UK launch has more than a whiff of hubris about it. I doubt it'll set the world on fire at that price. I'll have the iPod instead thanks. Apologies for the rant above, it just kinda slipped out.
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
More comparable than you think; UK prices, including the cheapest plan (£35), are all quoted including sales tax (17.5%). Factor that in and we're only getting lightly screwed.Dave wrote: Also, it's selling for $399 in the States for the 8GB model. Your model is going for £269 ($539), a whole $140 more expensive. I dunno if the pricing in the cell plans make up for it or not. The cheapest plan you can get with AT&T is $60/month, plus tax, with a 2-year agreement.
- Al
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 535
- Joined: Thu May 23, 2002 5:28 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Mintytorus
- Location: Weybourne, Surrey, UK
Thanks to a kind friend that just happened to be in San Francisco when a) the 8Gb iPhone dropped to $399 and b) the SIM unlock hack emerged, I've had one of these fellas for just over a day now and I thought I'd post me impressions.
First up is the haxxoring. Activation and Jailbreaking was a breeze thanks to a lovely Mac app called iNdependence. This leaves the iPhone in a state in which you can use WiFi and SFTP or SSH into it to start hacking it about. So far so good.
Next step was to install AnySIM on the iPhone to perform the unlock. This stumped me for a bit - I copied it over and ran it okay but it didn't seem to do anything. After an embarrassingly long period of faffing I realized I had to drag my finger on the screen to scroll to the bottom of the AnySIM credits to reveal the OK button that kicked off the unlock process. Despite an error message at the end, my Virgin Mobile SIM was accepted after a reboot. Take that Steve!
Unfortunately I've not used it much as a phone as the coverage around here on Virgin is awful. I managed to get GPRS working (in fact a little 'E' icon suggests I might even be getting EDGE access, which surprised me as Virgin/T-Mobile aren't supposed to support it) but unfortunately Virgin's lack of a decent data package meant I worked up a £10 dent on my bill in less than half an hour. I was caning the Google Maps app to do this, and I was actually quite impressed by it's responsiveness over GPRS. Ironically it looks like I might move to O2 for better coverage and data support.
In operation the phone is mostly awesome. MobileSafari is great - it makes it easy to hone in on the bits of a page that you're interested in so the small screen is not much of a hinderance. In fact I'm really enjoying zooming in on the content and pushing the guff outside the edges of the screen - just double-tap on what you're interested in and you're away.
The keyboard is rubbish for my freakishly big hands - even in landscape I can't get accurate enough with my thumbs. However I'm pecking this out reasonably quickly with one index finger.
The music and video playback is awesome - of course I have to munge DivX files through VisualHub before iTunes will deem them worthy, but once that's done iTunes and the iPhone do a great job of tracking what you've watched - the iPhone even asks if you want to delete a video once you've reached the end.
All in all I'm loving it. Hopefully an O2 SIM will mean I won't need to be so wary of the GPRS kicking in and I can use it uninhibited. And hopefully those sneaky hackers will stay ahead of the game and allow me to update the OS without fuggering the SIM unlock.
First up is the haxxoring. Activation and Jailbreaking was a breeze thanks to a lovely Mac app called iNdependence. This leaves the iPhone in a state in which you can use WiFi and SFTP or SSH into it to start hacking it about. So far so good.
Next step was to install AnySIM on the iPhone to perform the unlock. This stumped me for a bit - I copied it over and ran it okay but it didn't seem to do anything. After an embarrassingly long period of faffing I realized I had to drag my finger on the screen to scroll to the bottom of the AnySIM credits to reveal the OK button that kicked off the unlock process. Despite an error message at the end, my Virgin Mobile SIM was accepted after a reboot. Take that Steve!
Unfortunately I've not used it much as a phone as the coverage around here on Virgin is awful. I managed to get GPRS working (in fact a little 'E' icon suggests I might even be getting EDGE access, which surprised me as Virgin/T-Mobile aren't supposed to support it) but unfortunately Virgin's lack of a decent data package meant I worked up a £10 dent on my bill in less than half an hour. I was caning the Google Maps app to do this, and I was actually quite impressed by it's responsiveness over GPRS. Ironically it looks like I might move to O2 for better coverage and data support.
In operation the phone is mostly awesome. MobileSafari is great - it makes it easy to hone in on the bits of a page that you're interested in so the small screen is not much of a hinderance. In fact I'm really enjoying zooming in on the content and pushing the guff outside the edges of the screen - just double-tap on what you're interested in and you're away.
The keyboard is rubbish for my freakishly big hands - even in landscape I can't get accurate enough with my thumbs. However I'm pecking this out reasonably quickly with one index finger.
The music and video playback is awesome - of course I have to munge DivX files through VisualHub before iTunes will deem them worthy, but once that's done iTunes and the iPhone do a great job of tracking what you've watched - the iPhone even asks if you want to delete a video once you've reached the end.
All in all I'm loving it. Hopefully an O2 SIM will mean I won't need to be so wary of the GPRS kicking in and I can use it uninhibited. And hopefully those sneaky hackers will stay ahead of the game and allow me to update the OS without fuggering the SIM unlock.


