The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Locked
User avatar
Marius
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3095
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2005 11:34 pm 0
Location: Oslo, Norway

Post by Marius »

silent_unicorn wrote:
GeeZa wrote:
Bubba wrote:For the last time, 1080p gaming on the PS3 is a myth :D
Ridge Racer 7 looks fab imo and is still the pick of the PS3 games for me. It's 1080p. So is Virtua Tennis, SuperStardust HD, Flow, and the new NBA08 demo. Oh and Tekken5. There might be a few others I suppose. They all look pretty good to me but are likely full of compromises in other areas. Is it worth worrying about? Probably not. There's still something to be said for the PS3's 1080p output even if it's only a marginal comment. I imagine it makes folks with large 1080p TVs quite pleased with themselves.

But yeah, the GPUs of both the 360 and PS3 are somewhat underwhelming and I doubt we'll see too many full-range 1080p games on the PS3.
Picked up RR7 for 20 quid. Will be here soon so will be interesting to compare to RR6 on 360 :)

1080p will be quite important for PC gaming too, 1920x1080 is a regular option on PC games and there will be some awesomely powerful GPUs for PCs in the next 6-12 months so just want the maximum useage from my telly in the longrun really. 800 quid is just too much for anything below 42inches 1080p IMO, LCD is overpriced still!
If Gears of War is 720p, who the hell needs 1080? It's certainly more than pretty enough on my samsung 32" 720p HDTV to satisfy my cravings for next-gen graphics for at least another four-five years.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Post by merman »

RedOktober wrote:
gravy wrote:Having wrote Kick Start he can do no wrong :)
v1.3 ?
Nope, the motorbike game on 8-bit machines. Which technically was called Kik Start, so as not to infringe the BBC's copyright...
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

gravy the troll wrote:
silent_unicorn wrote:And what the hell has coding got to do with knowing that Lotus II is infinately smoother sprite scaling than ANY other Amiga game for example including the 4 years worth of games releases following it? eh eh? Exactly
silent_unicorn wrote:Ditto A500 copy of Lotus 2 is faster and smoother than a 100mhz PC's Lotus III
The major variation there is the coder. Shawn Southern is pretty awesome. PC games back in those days were pretty niche, never had particularly good programmers on or a lot of time and money spent on development.

Your argument that a 100mhz Pentium is worse than the Amiga for games is just cock really.

Good coders on PC around that time produced (mostly for the larger US market) games like Quake and Descent, stuff you just can't do convincingly on your Amiga.

If you actually knew anything about the hardware you're talking about you'd realise how stupid you sound. Then again this entire thread is a testament to your ignorance :D
I said the game was faster and smoother not the hardware. Look at the apostrophe ;) SPAG Nazi clarification request please :P

And it was 100mhz PC not specifically Pentium (IBM Bluelightning DX4s, AMD K5s etc etc) the P1 chip also ushered in PCI sound/graphics aswell as a much better CPU architecture than AMD K5/Cyrix 6x86/i486 based motherboards generally which affects PC performance quite a lot. I would have had more respect for you if you had pointed out
a. There was no Lotus II on the PC
b. Lotus III wasn't as slick on framerate on the Amiga aswell (not tried the CD32 compilation version and it never ran on KS3 Amigas).
c. Whether it was running a Diamond Viper64 VRAM card or some cheap shit OAK Technologies ISA bollox, which funnily enough was an 8mhz 16bit bus IIRC similar to the Amiga chipset design.

Magnetic Fields (was Shaun Southern still with them then?) did a pretty awesome job in the 90s on their PC rally game for DOS (flame me for not remembering the exact title if you like). And lack of effort on PC games front shows quite badly with many Amiga classics only having an EGA PC version and no VGA at all (Cinemaware??) even in America.

You call me stupid and yet the reason DOOM (which was one of the first 3D games that really stunned people and well Quake was it's son born of their profits) is so fast on the PC and not the Amiga has gone right over your little head .....

Bitplanes!, eight of the bastards on the Amiga [for 256 colours] with no custom assistance in general for the kind of graphics that DOOM does, instead of byte per pixel on VGA on PC ASWELL AS the CPU grunt usually used to offset not having good 2D 'tools' in it's design available to the PC anyway.
<pedant>Oh yes there is AKIKO libraries for the A1200/4000 OR the AKIKO chunky to planar firmware "solution" on ONLY the CD32 motherboard of course none of which really helps</pedant>.
Slower processor, nearly 6-8 times more work writing to the screen using slower screen memory (the Amiga's own Chipram) and you have no Doom on Amiga worth mentioning, added to their lack of 680x0 skills at ID you can see why they would never attempt it.
3D games require CPU grunt and sod all else really, exactly the opposite of what the Amiga didn't have at the time due to lack of investment on replacement/upgrade to the 1984 basic original prototype of the A1000 being carried on until the A3000 (which still had more or less identical Blitter/Sound/Copper hardware tacked to a faster CPU). Assuming I don't know that Actua Soccer is impossible on an A500 is just stupid. I love the Amiga, always will but I DO know what can and can't be done on the collective hardware that is either OCS/ECS or AGA. 3D gaming killed the Amiga...via incompetence of Commodore milking that cash cow like there was no tomorrow and not thinking of tomorrow's Amigas until it was way too late financially for them.

C64-->Amiga 1000 2yrs--->A1200 10 yrs 8O There is your problem right there!

But remember how many attempts those DOS games took to run at all? and all the pissing about with MSCDEX and EMS/XMS Qemm type managers for the Config.sys/Autoexec.bat?. Haha took ages to get Super Stardust96 on the PC to work 100%. The PC was fine, DOS gaming was NOT. That was the problem with PC gaming not the actual hardware (assuming your sound card and graphics card were not cock as you put it, and ofcourse compatible with the particular standards supported by the game e.g. Soundblaster 16/AWE compatible sound or not)

Truth is Dave Haynie knew exactly what the Amiga chipset needed to compete(rumoured to be on a par with the Saturn on 3D but should have launched 2 yrs before the Saturn for example), sadly coupled with comments from Irvine Gould reported to have said a 68000 is fine for the Amiga in the late 80s and Medhi Ali's extreme incompetence putting things like native 3D in the Amiga AAA chipset on the backburner, which Dave Haynie had already prototyped. Cue no competition once PCs started coming out of their prehistoric EGA era. I know full well what is and isn't possible on both platforms (486PC/Amiga OCS) and what talented coding can and can't overcome. Your assumption I don't is a sign of your own ignorance aswell as a general problem with me on here anyway. To appreciate the difference between a picture and a fine painting does NOT require being able to paint that picture exactly. Gaming is an artform, a basic understanding of machines involved technically helps when cross referencing, being a coder or not of cutting edge games is of no significance at all.

Now that this serious derailment of the thread is in effect, let's try and get back on topic. The original point which I will try and put in an easier context was akin to the early PS1/Saturn situation. The Saturn is a fine machine, and when in the right hands could do things fabled not to be possible. eg transparency in Burning Rangers or just a super fast 30FPS racing game with excellent graphics like Sega Rally as opposed to the drivel before which was held up against Tekken and RidgeRacer of PS1 with say Daytona/Virtua Racing and Virtua Fighter [Remix] of the Saturn taken as the machines utlimate capability but in reality is down to inefficient coding. The 360 is a more straight forward beast to code for than the PS3 for getting the maximum out of it. Evolution studios have given us a peek at what is possible when talented coders are involved even on 1st gen launch titles, the general message was wait and see, it's only the first year of a probably long product lifecycle of a horrendously complex machine to code for. Capish?

</Discussion on PC vs Amiga in the mid-late 80s>

You need to move on mate seriously....If you really want to discuss PC vs Amiga in the late 80s gamingwise (which I suspect you don't) start a thread for that for god's sake :roll:


Image

On the other hand keep em coming, I do enjoy a good laugh at your trolling/baiting, hell for the laughs you generate I'd gladly fund a whole year's worth of hosting of yakyak :lol:
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Post by Yak »

er. Being a "horrendously complex machine to code for" is not an advantage, it's a huge liability. The simple fact is that most software houses will code identical games for both platforms because that is by far the most effective use of resources in a very expensive and difficult business. Nobody is going to sit and wank over so-called extra capabilities in a ps3 version because it's simply not viable for them to do so, except in the case of exclusives funded by Sony chucking money at them.

No code shop in the known universe is going to go "Oh, boy, that Sony's so tricky to code, can't wait to get cracking on that then!" without Sony lobbing loads of cash at them.
Justified and Ancient.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Yak wrote:er. Being a "horrendously complex machine to code for" is not an advantage, it's a huge liability. The simple fact is that most software houses will code identical games for both platforms because that is by far the most effective use of resources in a very expensive and difficult business. Nobody is going to sit and wank over so-called extra capabilities in a ps3 version because it's simply not viable for them to do so, except in the case of exclusives funded by Sony chucking money at them.

No code shop in the known universe is going to go "Oh, boy, that Sony's so tricky to code, can't wait to get cracking on that then!" without Sony lobbing loads of cash at them.
I think that can be justified only by "yeah but this machine can do INCREDIBLE things that NO ONE ELSE can do".

*IF* and *ONLY IF* this is really the case.

Yet .. it's still dangerous to invest lot to work on a complex case and then
do something so particular it can work only on one machine.

The question is "Can the PS3 really do INCREDIBLE things ?" I think the
answer is "NO, it does not do much more than what other machines can do".

Then the more complication is a handicap not a bonus.

"Costs VS Results" is the equation that always applies.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Yak wrote:er. Being a "horrendously complex machine to code for" is not an advantage, it's a huge liability. The simple fact is that most software houses will code identical games for both platforms because that is by far the most effective use of resources in a very expensive and difficult business. Nobody is going to sit and wank over so-called extra capabilities in a ps3 version because it's simply not viable for them to do so, except in the case of exclusives funded by Sony chucking money at them.

No code shop in the known universe is going to go "Oh, boy, that Sony's so tricky to code, can't wait to get cracking on that then!" without Sony lobbing loads of cash at them.
I never said it was an advantage or a otherwise though. I am stating the fact that the PS3 like it or lump it is more difficult to extract the same level of performance in most likelyhood.

Same as was the case with the Saturn and the PS1 and yes as you have pointed out Sega were the producers of the finest things in house and Wipeout was a bit shit on the Saturn as an example of cross platform releases that could have been better.

run out of unicorn pictures then? :P
User avatar
Bubba
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10013
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2003 12:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: BubbaFatAss
PSN: BubbaFatAs
Location: Cambridge

Post by Bubba »

silent_unicorn wrote:Slower processor, nearly 6-8 times more work writing to the screen using slower screen memory (the Amiga's own Chipram) and you have no Doom on Amiga worth mentioning, added to their lack of 680x0 skills at ID you can see why they would never attempt it.
Don't know / care that much about the Amiga architecture but I'd like to point out that John Carmack is one of the most tallented programmers out there, especially when it comes to getting the most from weak platforms. I'm sure a little bit of 680x0 assembler wouldn't have phased him :D

Cheers

Bubba
||Work || Flickr||
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

gilesgoat wrote:
Yak wrote:er. Being a "horrendously complex machine to code for" is not an advantage, it's a huge liability. The simple fact is that most software houses will code identical games for both platforms because that is by far the most effective use of resources in a very expensive and difficult business. Nobody is going to sit and wank over so-called extra capabilities in a ps3 version because it's simply not viable for them to do so, except in the case of exclusives funded by Sony chucking money at them.

No code shop in the known universe is going to go "Oh, boy, that Sony's so tricky to code, can't wait to get cracking on that then!" without Sony lobbing loads of cash at them.
I think that can be justified only by "yeah but this machine can do INCREDIBLE things that NO ONE ELSE can do".

*IF* and *ONLY IF* this is really the case.

Yet .. it's still dangerous to invest lot to work on a complex case and then
do something so particular it can work only on one machine.

The question is "Can the PS3 really do INCREDIBLE things ?" I think the
answer is "NO, it does not do much more than what other machines can do".

Then the more complication is a handicap not a bonus.

"Costs VS Results" is the equation that always applies.
I totally agree with you, I am not in dispute that the current generation has an even smaller gap, that Sony took a very complex and esoteric route to producing similar performance to the 360 and that neither really outshines a 700 gaming laptop from Dell anyway (which includes a 1080p 17inch screen built in).

It's an old fashioned and rose tinted view of the world where coders would clamber to produce the most efficient and impressive code on complex platforms. It's no longer the way forward, any new console needs to be both simple to produce simple to design and code for to be successful. Exotic hardware is only a bonus if the cost of manufacture and purchasing goes a long way to reducing the price against competition.
Muphex
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 775
Joined: Sun Oct 03, 2004 9:22 pm 0

Post by Muphex »

Image
"Have a good time all the time" - Spinal Tap
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Bubba wrote:
silent_unicorn wrote:Slower processor, nearly 6-8 times more work writing to the screen using slower screen memory (the Amiga's own Chipram) and you have no Doom on Amiga worth mentioning, added to their lack of 680x0 skills at ID you can see why they would never attempt it.
Don't know / care that much about the Amiga architecture but I'd like to point out that John Carmack is one of the most tallented programmers out there, especially when it comes to getting the most from weak platforms. I'm sure a little bit of 680x0 assembler wouldn't have phased him :D

Cheers

Bubba
DOOM is a work of art, highly effective and efficient I have always agreed with that. Wolfenstein on an STE with 16mhz (MEGA STE) is possible but Doom probably not so easy but not for programming competence reasons.

It was more a comment about Amiga/ST/Mac architecture perks than his skill at coding assembler. Doom has clever PC specific coding which needs to be recreated on each platform. Plus financially probably wasn't looking good for them to do it anyway. There were rumours but nothing ever surfaced that I have ever seen.
Kronos

Post by Kronos »

Muphex wrote:Image
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3q4SAQ9r7U

Full youtube vid for it there :) Also Virus on the speccy was pretty impressive and fully released IIRC but no track of a vid of it on the net that I have found.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Post by Dio »

silent_unicorn wrote:Doom has clever PC specific coding which needs to be recreated on each platform. Plus financially probably wasn't looking good for them to do it anyway. There were rumours but nothing ever surfaced that I have ever seen.
Hmmm, yes, all of about six different asm texmapping loops. All the rest is C; that's true of the console versions as well (certainly the Jaguar version, where the source code is available on the net).

You are aware that John Carmack coded the Jaguar version himself, yes? Note that the Jag couldn't do Doom at 320-wide, it uses 8-cycle pixels to give a 160-wide screen (as did Doom on a 386).

If it had been viable, he could trivially have ported it to the Amiga. It wasn't.
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

gilesgoat wrote:The question is "Can the PS3 really do INCREDIBLE things ?" I think the
answer is "NO, it does not do much more than what other machines can do".
I disagree. The PS3 could do far more, but I don't think more than a handful
of games will ever show the true potential. If they'd been first to release and
had good sales it might have attracted the necessary effort from developers.
With the situation as it is now very few developers will go for it. It's a real
shame as Cell is producing very impressive results for HPC applications.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:
gilesgoat wrote:The question is "Can the PS3 really do INCREDIBLE things ?" I think the
answer is "NO, it does not do much more than what other machines can do".
I disagree. The PS3 could do far more, but I don't think more than a handful
of games will ever show the true potential. If they'd been first to release and
had good sales it might have attracted the necessary effort from developers.
With the situation as it is now very few developers will go for it. It's a real
shame as Cell is producing very impressive results for HPC applications.
Snake that bites its tail.

Too few sales no worth to invest, too few investment not many big things too few sales.

Usual story.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

silent_unicorn wrote:Long post, lots of irrelevnace, stuff about CD in DOS, yet more ignorance, Bitplanes!
I honestly don't understand what point you're trying to make now. You're thrashing about.

As far as I can work out your point about bitplanes is agreeing with me, lack of a chunky mode is another reason why the machine fell behind.

Which I knew. I do understand this stuff, I've had to program the thing spending considerable effort to get it do a wrap around 2d scroller with parralax at a decent framrate. Something simple on the PC or consoles of the day but a bit of a mare on the Amiga.

You're trying to make a points about machine arhitectures based on specific bits of software but don't seem to have even a cursory understanding of what you're talking about.

Which funnily enough now brings us right back on topic, this thread began as a set of assertions about the PS3 based on web movies of games that were coming out. It's the same dull arguing from the start point of interest followed by furious digging yourself into a deeper and deeper hole.


(ps The OCS only had 5 bitplanes you dosey dick)
Locked