The Sony PS3 thread (apparently *still* obnoxious!)
You can update the whole ST screen in under a frame - more than 20% under, if it's all MOVEMs. I already had routines to do all kinds of parallax scrolling using prerotated backgrounds from my R&D into cloning Thunderforce III - that was targetted at 25 fps, but it had to have headroom because it wasn't predictable.
I then had some code that worked out what was visible and what wasn't and dropped sections of the background - so the average overdraw wasn't that high, 1.2 or so, and only the .2 was masked. I also didn't need to redraw bits I knew hadn't changed - if you designed the front layer carefully you could easily give people the impression that you were scrolling the whole screen when in fact 40% or so was completely ignored on most frames.
That was the bit that I never quite finished; it was starting to get really hairy in there.
And if I was just short, I was going to drop 16 pixels off either side as well - if I'd been clever with the way the intro was coded (i.e. didn't use the area either, and using rasters cleverly) nobody would probably have noticed. 10% off for free
.
I then had some code that worked out what was visible and what wasn't and dropped sections of the background - so the average overdraw wasn't that high, 1.2 or so, and only the .2 was masked. I also didn't need to redraw bits I knew hadn't changed - if you designed the front layer carefully you could easily give people the impression that you were scrolling the whole screen when in fact 40% or so was completely ignored on most frames.
That was the bit that I never quite finished; it was starting to get really hairy in there.
And if I was just short, I was going to drop 16 pixels off either side as well - if I'd been clever with the way the intro was coded (i.e. didn't use the area either, and using rasters cleverly) nobody would probably have noticed. 10% off for free
Last edited by Dio on Sat Sep 29, 2007 3:57 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Wolfenstein? On my Atari?silent_unicorn wrote:DOOM is a work of art, highly effective and efficient I have always agreed with that. Wolfenstein on an STE with 16mhz (MEGA STE) is possible but Doom probably not so easy but not for programming competence reasons.
It was more a comment about Amiga/ST/Mac architecture perks than his skill at coding assembler. Doom has clever PC specific coding....
It's more likely than you think.
the hairy pies
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Agreed, it took a long while to get to the true power of the PS2, and it looks like Sony has repeated the mistake.Yak wrote:er. Being a "horrendously complex machine to code for" is not an advantage, it's a huge liability. The simple fact is that most software houses will code identical games for both platforms because that is by far the most effective use of resources in a very expensive and difficult business. Nobody is going to sit and wank over so-called extra capabilities in a ps3 version because it's simply not viable for them to do so, except in the case of exclusives funded by Sony chucking money at them.
No code shop in the known universe is going to go "Oh, boy, that Sony's so tricky to code, can't wait to get cracking on that then!" without Sony lobbing loads of cash at them.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
There are coders out there in the biz who get their kicks from wringing performance out of tricky to code hardware. They tend to eventually end up working first party for the platform holders direct, because as Yak said, no third party company can afford to develop for just the one this generation without supporting cash to make it worth their while.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
I know someone in the biz who was looking forward to getting to grips with the PS3 and its Cell processor.. don't know whether anything he's been working on has made it past the starting gate yet.Dio wrote:Flabio wrote:There are coders out there in the biz who get their kicks from wringing performance out of tricky to code hardware.I need to hold my hand up there I suppose. It's very true in the PC space too.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
- WiteWulf
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10125
- Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
- PSN: WiteWulf
- Location: Loughborough(ish)
http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=define ... =firefox-a
Related phrases: my big fat obnoxious boss
Definitions of obnoxious on the Web:
* objectionable: causing disapproval or protest; "a vulgar and objectionable person"
wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn
:::G:::
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
-
Kronos
Warning HEAVILY OFF TOPIC for gravy's benefit.
Last point first. I presume you mean lo-res and lo-res interlace (as hi-res and hi-res interlace only have 4 bitplanes). Amiga standard OCS/ECS and even non 64 colour NTSC A1000 chipsets, actually have 6 bitplanes. For HAM mode (and Extra Halfbrite on OCS only). Bullfrog's first Amiga game Fusion used all 6 bitplanes (slowly) in EHB which runs on my PAL A1000 right here. Unlike PCs where graphics memory dictate PC resolution and colour depth, the 512kb/1mb chipram Agnus chips make no difference, 6 bitplanes for either.
As Doom is primarily regarded as the 256 colour VGA 32bit CPU'd wonderkind I compared it to the 8 bitplane 256 colour architecture of 32bit AGA Amiga chipsets for direct comparison, surely to compare an OCS version of Doom would be only fair to compare it to the 8086 EGA port of it on youtube no? Writing eight sodding bits individually to 8 bitplanes to colour ONE pixel on the screen of even 320x200 units (64000x8 writes per screen refresh!) was a bit shit no? And again the ONLY reason the CD32 was mentioned was because it has the chunky to planar firmware AKIKO chip, but seeing as you can't add Fastram to a stock CD32 again it's fucked as the CPU is effectively strangled down to 50% performance with just chipram so no good for CD32 already CPU intensive Doom type game again no?
The Amiga (OCS/ECS) did indeed have simple native hardware 2 plane parallax scrolling (3 if you used the limited hardware sprites artisticly as they run the full vertical length of the screen indeed), it's called dual playfield mode available even on the very early 'non 64 colour mode A1000 NTSC rare as rocking horse shit' chipsets let alone KS 1.2 A500/A1000/A2000s. And hence pretty piss easy to do even on Blitz Basic
The biggest challenge is reduced onscreen colours, but that's for the pixel artist to deal with not the coder. The reason people don't use dual playfields on Amiga games generally is due to the fact the Amiga splits the 6 bitplanes into 3 bitplanes per playfield which equals just 8 colours per playfield. Bit shit really. However SotB and others get round this limitation and reduce it to 8 colours per scan line using the copper. You could of course try doing it the "PC way" using the blitter too but it's asking a lot of the poor old OCS/ECS blitter and that 7.14/7.28mhz 68000 processor isn't going to help you either.
PC parallax scrolling is done entirely in software, which a 100mhz P1 is about 20x more powerful in raw CPU power than an 010 or 68000 @ 7mhz. There is NO PC hardware parallax (although many had blitter equipped graphics cards by then) on even Pentium 1 PCI graphics cards available. Megadrive/Snes yes, Amiga yes, PC of the time no hardware parallax. Agony and SotB 1-3 use it quite a lot aswell as Lionheart IIRC. And in the late 80s/early 90s the EGA/VGA ports of PC platformers I can remember were identical single plane upgrades of the Amiga ones with more colours on screen used only (Zool 2, Risky Woods, Cool Spot.....) and not the parallax Megadrive versions in general for this reason. You should know this being a seasoned journo in the industry around that time and tech assistant to Thalamus
Yes I'm sure you know more about the Amiga than me aha, it's very plain to see right there. I so obviously know fuck all about Amiga or general computer architecture or old school techniques of this type because I didn't hand assemble a Lotus II beater?
<jim carrey>
aaaallllriteeeeeey then.
As for PS3, yes a fair amount of stuff still looks 1st gen-ish (better than 1st gen on 360 still though which was the whole point at the time) which is where other posters who did get it have also commented in agreement....
complexity = longer time to produce (read more expensive) 2nd gen titles/exploit the hardware more effectively.
Which funnily enough was the whole point of comparing it to the Saturn/PS1 and Amiga/ST days from a [third party] publishers point of view. And to reiterate that, for the second time, Sony have gone for some esoteric solution to produce performance just as in the PS2 days, but in an even more iffy market for them [cost/significantly later to market] and with even more complexity this time round! This is stuff I already admitted and posted yonks ago dude.
Let it go really mate, you're a bit old to be playing in the playground seriously! You have an opinion of me fair enough, but that's no reason to keep derailing the whole damned thread. You don't like the PS3, we get it dude, enough already!
Sadly it would probably be quite nice to have an educated non personal discussion with you about these kind of things, how we ended up where we are in the computing world and why is probably my last interest in computing left outside of gaming. I doubt this will ever happen though. Ho hum. It's not like the old days where I'd pick up a copy of Byte or PCW and feaverishly read about radically different technologies appearing and how they do their "thing".
*Ahem* Back on topic.
I thought Kemper_boyd hit the nail right on the head. Had Motorstorm been a multiplatform release it probably wouldn't have looked as spectacular as it does. Wipeout HD is another in house product that should benefit from its single format concentration, and hopefully fully utilise the SixAxis to improve gameplay beyond any other version as the onscreen tilt icon hints at hopefully.
And more interestingly what about games that started out as PS3 exclusives then got a 360 production tagged on like RE5 or Devil May Cry, interesting times. The whole point is right now, a PS3 in full tilt say two years from now compared to a 360 in full tilt is an unknown quantity and given this complexity and the general cost of games production ever spiralling towards hollywood blockbuster propertions will we ever see it's full potential anyway.
Back to PS3 games......
Drake's Fortune new footage on GT here Looking rather special
And there is no 'rumble' on PS3 controllers apparently, just nectar apparently haha what's that all about?
God knows what I would be like if I had one of those 360s that needed to go back to Microsoft once or twice as opposed to the original 18 month old machine still going strong!
That's more your individual problem than mine, other people got the point ages ago.....Let's try again thengravy wrote:I honestly don't understand what point you're trying to make now. You're thrashing about.silent_unicorn wrote:Long post, lots of irrelevnace, stuff about CD in DOS, yet more ignorance, Bitplanes!
gravy wrote: As far as I can work out your point about bitplanes is agreeing with me, lack of a chunky mode is another reason why the machine fell behind.
Which I knew. I do understand this stuff, I've had to program the thing spending considerable effort to get it do a wrap around 2d scroller with parralax at a decent framrate. Something simple on the PC or consoles of the day but a bit of a mare on the Amiga.
You're trying to make a points about machine arhitectures based on specific bits of software but don't seem to have even a cursory understanding of what you're talking about.
(ps The OCS only had 5 bitplanes you dosey dick)
Last point first. I presume you mean lo-res and lo-res interlace (as hi-res and hi-res interlace only have 4 bitplanes). Amiga standard OCS/ECS and even non 64 colour NTSC A1000 chipsets, actually have 6 bitplanes. For HAM mode (and Extra Halfbrite on OCS only). Bullfrog's first Amiga game Fusion used all 6 bitplanes (slowly) in EHB which runs on my PAL A1000 right here. Unlike PCs where graphics memory dictate PC resolution and colour depth, the 512kb/1mb chipram Agnus chips make no difference, 6 bitplanes for either.
As Doom is primarily regarded as the 256 colour VGA 32bit CPU'd wonderkind I compared it to the 8 bitplane 256 colour architecture of 32bit AGA Amiga chipsets for direct comparison, surely to compare an OCS version of Doom would be only fair to compare it to the 8086 EGA port of it on youtube no? Writing eight sodding bits individually to 8 bitplanes to colour ONE pixel on the screen of even 320x200 units (64000x8 writes per screen refresh!) was a bit shit no? And again the ONLY reason the CD32 was mentioned was because it has the chunky to planar firmware AKIKO chip, but seeing as you can't add Fastram to a stock CD32 again it's fucked as the CPU is effectively strangled down to 50% performance with just chipram so no good for CD32 already CPU intensive Doom type game again no?
The Amiga (OCS/ECS) did indeed have simple native hardware 2 plane parallax scrolling (3 if you used the limited hardware sprites artisticly as they run the full vertical length of the screen indeed), it's called dual playfield mode available even on the very early 'non 64 colour mode A1000 NTSC rare as rocking horse shit' chipsets let alone KS 1.2 A500/A1000/A2000s. And hence pretty piss easy to do even on Blitz Basic
PC parallax scrolling is done entirely in software, which a 100mhz P1 is about 20x more powerful in raw CPU power than an 010 or 68000 @ 7mhz. There is NO PC hardware parallax (although many had blitter equipped graphics cards by then) on even Pentium 1 PCI graphics cards available. Megadrive/Snes yes, Amiga yes, PC of the time no hardware parallax. Agony and SotB 1-3 use it quite a lot aswell as Lionheart IIRC. And in the late 80s/early 90s the EGA/VGA ports of PC platformers I can remember were identical single plane upgrades of the Amiga ones with more colours on screen used only (Zool 2, Risky Woods, Cool Spot.....) and not the parallax Megadrive versions in general for this reason. You should know this being a seasoned journo in the industry around that time and tech assistant to Thalamus
Yes I'm sure you know more about the Amiga than me aha, it's very plain to see right there. I so obviously know fuck all about Amiga or general computer architecture or old school techniques of this type because I didn't hand assemble a Lotus II beater?
<jim carrey>
aaaallllriteeeeeey then.
It's due to your repeated dull [playing] dumb response posts...but I digress...gravy wrote: Which funnily enough now brings us right back on topic, this thread began as a set of assertions about the PS3 based on web movies of games that were coming out. It's the same dull arguing from the start point of interest followed by furious digging yourself into a deeper and deeper hole.
As for PS3, yes a fair amount of stuff still looks 1st gen-ish (better than 1st gen on 360 still though which was the whole point at the time) which is where other posters who did get it have also commented in agreement....
complexity = longer time to produce (read more expensive) 2nd gen titles/exploit the hardware more effectively.
Which funnily enough was the whole point of comparing it to the Saturn/PS1 and Amiga/ST days from a [third party] publishers point of view. And to reiterate that, for the second time, Sony have gone for some esoteric solution to produce performance just as in the PS2 days, but in an even more iffy market for them [cost/significantly later to market] and with even more complexity this time round! This is stuff I already admitted and posted yonks ago dude.
Let it go really mate, you're a bit old to be playing in the playground seriously! You have an opinion of me fair enough, but that's no reason to keep derailing the whole damned thread. You don't like the PS3, we get it dude, enough already!
Sadly it would probably be quite nice to have an educated non personal discussion with you about these kind of things, how we ended up where we are in the computing world and why is probably my last interest in computing left outside of gaming. I doubt this will ever happen though. Ho hum. It's not like the old days where I'd pick up a copy of Byte or PCW and feaverishly read about radically different technologies appearing and how they do their "thing".
*Ahem* Back on topic.
I thought Kemper_boyd hit the nail right on the head. Had Motorstorm been a multiplatform release it probably wouldn't have looked as spectacular as it does. Wipeout HD is another in house product that should benefit from its single format concentration, and hopefully fully utilise the SixAxis to improve gameplay beyond any other version as the onscreen tilt icon hints at hopefully.
And more interestingly what about games that started out as PS3 exclusives then got a 360 production tagged on like RE5 or Devil May Cry, interesting times. The whole point is right now, a PS3 in full tilt say two years from now compared to a 360 in full tilt is an unknown quantity and given this complexity and the general cost of games production ever spiralling towards hollywood blockbuster propertions will we ever see it's full potential anyway.
Back to PS3 games......
Drake's Fortune new footage on GT here Looking rather special
And there is no 'rumble' on PS3 controllers apparently, just nectar apparently haha what's that all about?
I guess the thread is classed as obnoxious by some people who do not like the PS3 or have any fondness for it's games (yet still like to participate in this thread) and deam me [possibly some others] as obnoxious in thread posts as do not agree with these non-PS3 liking people and don't write things like "oh god I wasted my money on a PS3" or "Oh god ALL PS3 games are shit compared to ALL 360 games" every other postgilesgoat wrote:Besides .. I never dared to ask but .. what the hell means "obnoxious"![]()
God knows what I would be like if I had one of those 360s that needed to go back to Microsoft once or twice as opposed to the original 18 month old machine still going strong!
Apologies TO ALL MEMBERS READING THIS for this excessive post to try and put gravy back in the context, there's many things I don't know, but the original Amiga is not one of those things trust me on this. The c64 also, writing sprite programs at the age of 9 does have an affect on your fanboy favouritism for the c64 after all I guess! When Jay Miner died the world lost a lot more than an Atari/Lorraine Computers engineer believe me
Coo, last word to me then 
Setting up the screen so it's moving about with 2 parralax layers is indeed a piece of piss.
Setting it up so you can smooth scroll multi directionally over a large map is a little trickier. And the settting up the screen so you can blit masked sprites into it in one blit a little tricky too.
It involvles a bit of copper work and setting to the screens and sprite data to have interleaved bitplaces. It's not using the Amiga in the way the chip designers intended it to be used and is dissapointingly fiddly to do something so incredibly prosaic that's easily accomplished on console / arcade systems.
You end up working hard to do something that looks pretty oridinary and is easy on other machines.
Isn't time better spent on making stuff that's fun to play rather than hard to do?
You're still doing HW top trumps though chap, bandying about buzzwords without demonstrating any in depth knowledge. Characterising Doom as code chock full of PC specific tricks is as laughable as using different versions of Lotus written by completely different people to say something about computer hardware.
And now claiming C64 knowledge on the basis of writing some sprite programs is akin to claiming an to be able to run a petrol refinery cos you filled you gold beamer up with 4 star.
The point I'm making stands, the PC your comparing to the Amiga just plain outclasses it.
I love these boards, I've learnt a fuckload of stuff about a wide variety subjects and it's a near constant delight.
But I don't get that from you, every time you write about anything technological I get the same itchy feeling conjured up by that little girl on Jurrasic Park saying ""This is a Unix system ... I know this!"
LOL
The facts of the matter are right now is that the PS3 has sold the least amount of consoles out of all the next gen machines and is selling the least amount of software too.
I have a PS3 and Sony's amazing fall from grace is the most interesting thing to discuss about it right now.
Setting up the screen so it's moving about with 2 parralax layers is indeed a piece of piss.
Setting it up so you can smooth scroll multi directionally over a large map is a little trickier. And the settting up the screen so you can blit masked sprites into it in one blit a little tricky too.
It involvles a bit of copper work and setting to the screens and sprite data to have interleaved bitplaces. It's not using the Amiga in the way the chip designers intended it to be used and is dissapointingly fiddly to do something so incredibly prosaic that's easily accomplished on console / arcade systems.
You end up working hard to do something that looks pretty oridinary and is easy on other machines.
Isn't time better spent on making stuff that's fun to play rather than hard to do?
You're still doing HW top trumps though chap, bandying about buzzwords without demonstrating any in depth knowledge. Characterising Doom as code chock full of PC specific tricks is as laughable as using different versions of Lotus written by completely different people to say something about computer hardware.
And now claiming C64 knowledge on the basis of writing some sprite programs is akin to claiming an to be able to run a petrol refinery cos you filled you gold beamer up with 4 star.
The point I'm making stands, the PC your comparing to the Amiga just plain outclasses it.
I love these boards, I've learnt a fuckload of stuff about a wide variety subjects and it's a near constant delight.
But I don't get that from you, every time you write about anything technological I get the same itchy feeling conjured up by that little girl on Jurrasic Park saying ""This is a Unix system ... I know this!"
LOL
The problem I have with you is the idiotic trumpeting of how great PS3 games were without seeing any. It's all there are the start of this thread, you got quite a lot of stuff wrong but won't own up to up.nobsak wrote:I guess the thread is classed as obnoxious by some people who do not like the PS3 or have any fondness for it's games (yet still like to participate in this thread) and deam me [possibly some others] as obnoxious in thread posts as do not agree with these non-PS3 liking people and don't write things like "oh god I wasted my money on a PS3" or "Oh god ALL PS3 games are shit compared to ALL 360 games" every other post![]()
The facts of the matter are right now is that the PS3 has sold the least amount of consoles out of all the next gen machines and is selling the least amount of software too.
I have a PS3 and Sony's amazing fall from grace is the most interesting thing to discuss about it right now.

