The all new PS3 thread. (Bright, shiny and plays dvds well)
Well, I'm basing my speculation on the assumption that a price drop is less than a week away. At its current price it isn't even an option.
It seems to me the 360 would be the "safe" choice. Quality to be sure, if nothing else in the form of XBLA, but hardly anything that hasn't been seen before. Higher-res rehashes of things already seen on the original Xbox or PC. I'm not sure how excited I can get about that. The PS3, on the other hand, seems to have a lot more potential for stuff that pushes the limits, especially when it comes to graphics. The question is how much of it is just empty hype.
It seems to me the 360 would be the "safe" choice. Quality to be sure, if nothing else in the form of XBLA, but hardly anything that hasn't been seen before. Higher-res rehashes of things already seen on the original Xbox or PC. I'm not sure how excited I can get about that. The PS3, on the other hand, seems to have a lot more potential for stuff that pushes the limits, especially when it comes to graphics. The question is how much of it is just empty hype.
- WiredWorm
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3162
- Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2005 4:48 pm 0
- Location: Right here on the edge of my seat......
I'm not quite sure on what basis you could ever say that - figures and 'theoretical' poly counts issued by Sony are one thing but ultimately it's always going to come down to the skill of the developers and how easy it is to develop for the platform.Peet wrote:The PS3, on the other hand, seems to have a lot more potential for stuff that pushes the limits, especially when it comes to graphics. The question is how much of it is just empty hype.
I can't really comment in this area as i'm not a developer - but I can say that i've heard good things said about the dev tools being offered to those working on the 360.
As for your comment pertaining to Xbox Live Arcade I think that's a very personal thing - personally i've spent a fortune on XBLA and I think there's quite a lot of other people on here who have also done the same. Sure a few of my purchases, such as Castlevania and Gauntlet, are just reissues of old games but the fact they've sold so well just proves there a market for them.
GamerTag: WiredWorm
It's like another mouth - LamptonWorm
It's like another mouth - LamptonWorm
- Terrypantsman
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Fri Dec 10, 2004 6:38 pm 0
- Location: The Hot Place
Is Blue ray really that much better than Hi Def or upscaling?
I have the 360's HD drive, and currently that looks like a waste of money. I don't mind all that much as I knew I was taking a chance anyway, but is it really that much better.
I've just bought a Denon 1940 DVD which upscales all my normal Dvd's to 1080p, and I got to say its fantastic on my plasma and the LCD's. A very good machine.
anyone out their who has them all, is blue ray better ? whats the current state, surely everyone is just going to upscale?
I have the 360's HD drive, and currently that looks like a waste of money. I don't mind all that much as I knew I was taking a chance anyway, but is it really that much better.
I've just bought a Denon 1940 DVD which upscales all my normal Dvd's to 1080p, and I got to say its fantastic on my plasma and the LCD's. A very good machine.
anyone out their who has them all, is blue ray better ? whats the current state, surely everyone is just going to upscale?
I haven't really paid attention to Sony hyping the hardware. I'm specifically talking about games that are out or in development. I've already namedropped the titles I'm interested in.WiredWorm wrote: I'm not quite sure on what basis you could ever say that - figures and 'theoretical' poly counts issued by Sony are one thing but ultimately it's always going to come down to the skill of the developers and how easy it is to develop for the platform.
That's great. Too bad so few of them seem to have any imaginative ideas though.I can't really comment in this area as i'm not a developer - but I can say that i've heard good things said about the dev tools being offered to those working on the 360.
Uhhh...? I thought I'd made it clear enough that XBLA is the main reason I'm interested in the 360. I'm just a bit worried that it's the only reason.As for your comment pertaining to Xbox Live Arcade I think that's a very personal thing - personally i've spent a fortune on XBLA and I think there's quite a lot of other people on here who have also done the same. Sure a few of my purchases, such as Castlevania and Gauntlet, are just reissues of old games but the fact they've sold so well just proves there a market for them.
The fact that they sell well doesn't really interest me at all though.
- WiredWorm
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3162
- Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2005 4:48 pm 0
- Location: Right here on the edge of my seat......
As far as i'm aware both HD-DVD and Blue-Ray use the same compression codecs - the only difference is the way in which the data is stored on the disk.
I seem to recall the main benefit of BlueRay is an increased capacity on the disk - something like 25GB on each disk as opposed to the 20GB offered by HD-DVD. It also offers an additional layer of security, but this isn't really a benefit to the end user but to the Studios.
So in terms of picture quality I don't think there's much to choose between the two formats. As for are they better than upscaling? Well upscaling is manufacturing extra data from what's available so i'm sure that in a side by side comparison some people may be able to notice a difference, particularly the way i've heard some people raving about HiDef DVD.
So far i've not picked up the HD-DVD add-on for the 360 (although i'm edging closer and closer that way as I see more and more titles coming to the format). If you do decide to ditch your drive then let me know, I might be in the market for one!!
I seem to recall the main benefit of BlueRay is an increased capacity on the disk - something like 25GB on each disk as opposed to the 20GB offered by HD-DVD. It also offers an additional layer of security, but this isn't really a benefit to the end user but to the Studios.
So in terms of picture quality I don't think there's much to choose between the two formats. As for are they better than upscaling? Well upscaling is manufacturing extra data from what's available so i'm sure that in a side by side comparison some people may be able to notice a difference, particularly the way i've heard some people raving about HiDef DVD.
So far i've not picked up the HD-DVD add-on for the 360 (although i'm edging closer and closer that way as I see more and more titles coming to the format). If you do decide to ditch your drive then let me know, I might be in the market for one!!
GamerTag: WiredWorm
It's like another mouth - LamptonWorm
It's like another mouth - LamptonWorm
White Knight Story looks pretty, and has some nice ideas. But isn't a million miles away from Infinite Undiscovery and Lost Odyssey, which are both 360 exclusives. And then there's Last Remnant, which is on both.
PS3 is getting Final Fantasy of course, and if I don't have a PS3 by the time that comes out (unlikely, but still) then that'll be when I get one.
Dismissing Mass Effect though, tsk.
PS3 is getting Final Fantasy of course, and if I don't have a PS3 by the time that comes out (unlikely, but still) then that'll be when I get one.
Dismissing Mass Effect though, tsk.
At this rate though, I wouldnt be supprised to see FF pop up on other formats (other then the DS, or spin-off's).
If Square is putting a lot of money into it, and the userbase of the PS3 isnt high enough....
If Square is putting a lot of money into it, and the userbase of the PS3 isnt high enough....
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Well, "Final Fantasy" is on everything these days. As far as anyone is aware the FFXIII engine is pretty closely linked to the PS3 though, so I'd be surprised to see those appearing on anything else.
Lost Odyssey does look like it could be fun, especially if that Asian speed metal from the trailer carries over into the game.
Lost Odyssey does look like it could be fun, especially if that Asian speed metal from the trailer carries over into the game.
Just out of curiosity but how much did you pay for your 360 and when did you first pick one up?WiredWorm wrote:It's going to take an awful lot to make me spend that kind of money on a games console.
Personally I think anyone who has, or is thinking about getting a PS3 is forced to take a longer-term view. It's a nicely put together machine with a lot of functionality crammed in there, but I wouldn't say it's good value for money as a games console (sort of obvious). The PSN Store has gotten a lot better in recent weeks with demos arriving in good time and a slew of add-ons available for some of the current games. It definitely feels a bit clumsy but at least the content is arriving at last (at least in the US).
And the games *really* aren't that bad. I mean the exclusive stuff like Resistance, RR7 and Ninja Gaiden Sigma are all solid proper gamer's titles, and Motorstorm has improved with the add-ons. The PS3 port of Oblivion is very good if you missed it first time round, Warhawk is apparently good fun (and downloadable), and I've played enough Heavenly Sword now to want to buy it. It's eye sex mostly though but that's ok. And there's some reasonably good stuff in the pipeline, both exclusive and multi-format.
So I hate being a Sony advocate because they are hateful twunts (but who isn't in this game anymore?) and the machine is a joke (controllers and price particularly) but there are little rays of sunshine there if you look for them. Of course there is no doubt that the 360 is where all the best games are and where everyone is having all the fun at the moment, it's painful watching everyone getting together and enjoying stuff whilst all I have is yet another impossible boss on Ninja Gaiden to tackle all on my own for the thousandth time. The question is whether and how long it might take for Sony to close the gap.
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
Cheaper non backwards compatible version confirmed
http://www.mcvuk.com/news/28463/PS3-pri ... k-revealed
http://www.mcvuk.com/news/28463/PS3-pri ... k-revealed
New to the market on the same day will be the 40GB model. It will retail at £299 - the same price Xbox 360 Elite – but features only two USB 2.0 ports and no longer includes the multi memory card port. It will also lack backwards compatibility with PS2 games.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10449
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
It will be interesting to see if MS responds to this. They obviously already have cheaper options available but I don;t think they will like having the Elite the same price as a PS3.gravy wrote:Cheaper non backwards compatible version confirmed
http://www.mcvuk.com/news/28463/PS3-pri ... k-revealed
New to the market on the same day will be the 40GB model. It will retail at £299 - the same price Xbox 360 Elite – but features only two USB 2.0 ports and no longer includes the multi memory card port. It will also lack backwards compatibility with PS2 games.




