fog wrote:rockwaldo wrote:Really feel for Jol though, hard decision to make with Robinson - I know he's made some howlers and he should be dropped, but I do respect the faith Jol has in him, and at least 6 points dropped where we have been harshly dealt a draw so far.
What difficult decision is this? Robinson is shit and has been for a long time. I can't believe Cerny is any worse.
They should boot Jol now while you can still get something out of the season. (Although I'm praying they wait a bit longer to see if the likes of Berbatov jump ship in January)
See, that's the decision right there. Robinson ISN'T shit, he never has been, he's just a keeper playing with very low confidence. I used to play keeper at a pretty decent level when I was younger and when your confidence is low you struggle with the easy things whenever you have time to think. This is clear in Robinson's play - his positioning from setplays is over cautious as he is desperately trying to avoid making an error. When a direct shot comes in he is desperate not to mishandle the ball. These are all natural goalkeeping skills but he is over-riding them because he doesnt have confidence in himself.
Two of the more common ways to get a keepers confidence back are: 1) let them play through 2) Drop them and let them regroup in the less important games.
We've been resolutely sticking to option 1 and so far Spurs as a team have been themselves playing under such immense pressure that Robinson to be fair hasn't had a chance to play through and get confidence. Pretty much everything that can go wrong luck wise has gone wrong, even in that Villa game we were the far better side, but everything the ball was in our area they scored. As well as that, we dont have a world class 2nd keeper, we havent had one for a long time - this is our major failing behind the big teams who generally gave 2 top top keepers in their squad. Cerny is a great little shot stopper, but he isn't good enough to step up and play regular first team football. With this being as it is, it wont have the desired effect on Robinson as he knows deep down that he doesnt risk losing his place permanently, so the short sharp shock part of the plan doesnt work. Also there is the added risk of us making even more mistakes (although admitedly at the moment we could barely find time to).
What we need to do is buy a decent keeper to breathe down Robinson's neck in January, THAT will be the proper solution in my opinion. Until then we stick it out.
As for Jol, sacking him would be inane in the extreme. Say what you like about the guy, but I cant remember a time in my lifetime where Spurs finished so well in the league regularly. We got to the semi final of the European cup last year for goodness sakes. The team ARE playing for Jol, we just arent catching the breaks and the media and board arent making it any easier.
I reckon we'll have a great game against newcastle and then build from there. My head agrees with my heart as well, so fingers crossed.