Well allow me to start withDio wrote:Feel free to provide one that proves there isn'tGBH wrote:Please feel free to provide me with a link that proves there is any link between piracy and reduced album sales/income..
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn4831.html
meanwhile this story
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainmen ... 995885.stm
states for the specific demographic of US students there was a loss in sales (though doesn't contradict the first one as the demographic is different)
So I'll happily concede that in reality no one knows. My guess is it has some effect but not anywhere near the scale that <industry association> claims. Also my guess is, as those 2 surveys tend to imply, in some demographics its negative, in others its a positive effect.
There seems to be precious little research by anyone other than the music industry into any of this and I believe anything they produce about as far as I could throw their HQ's.
The bottom line is however that the people and now seemingly the artists (Radiohead, NiN, Madonna) are starting to see it's not very good for them either. In 20 years time I'd like to hope we'll be looking back at all this and wondering what all the fuss is about.
After all, lets be honest here it's not the first time the entertainment industry has talked complete bollocks and lied in order to preserve profits.
"Home taping is killing music" anyone?
Check out this perspective from Australia in 2003. Interesting reading (and bias as well certainly)
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/12/ ... 32286.html
G






