RIP Oink (Was: Oink Invites Going Begging)

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
WiteWulf
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10125
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2004 11:20 am 0
PSN: WiteWulf
Location: Loughborough(ish)

Post by WiteWulf »

Jimaroid wrote:
WiteWulf wrote:AFAIK (and I was a member of Oink for about 3 years) there was no monetary profit made whatsoever from the site. You may consider that anyone downloading music that they haven't paid for is profiting, after a fashion.
I do suggest exactly that. Profit does not mean only financial gain. People were encouraged to maintain a high share ratio (expenditure) in order to continue gaining assets (profit).
Okay, I'm cool with that...I was just fed up seeing reports of the guy making huge amounts of money from this site that he charged people money to access. That simply wasn't true.

I have a very simple/naive view that copyright theft is acceptable (to me, at least) if no one makes a profit out of it. I accept people downloading pirated software or media off the Internet but it makes me angry when I see people then selling it for financial gain. I know, naive, but that's my outlook...
:::G:::

PSN: WiteWulf
Switch: SW-3941-2878-7584
Steam: WITEWULF66
User avatar
GBH
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 477
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 12:55 am 0

Post by GBH »

Jimaroid wrote:
WiteWulf wrote:
Jimaroid wrote:My biggest issue with this is that people generally seem unable to see that there is view present that is both against piracy and for electronic distribution. Not all piracy is electronic distribution, and vice versa, but in the case of Oink there was a fundamental bias towards ripping people off. People were encouraged to "profit" through the trading of other people's assets. That's piracy, electronic or not. The issues surrounding traditional physical media and the future of electronic distribution holds no place in Oink's shutdown.

There's a big difference between casual bootlegging between mates and an orchestrated scheme to distribute and profit from the same bootleg. Oink was shutdown because of that difference and I think it's a good thing that works in favour of and for the artists, the "big bad record companies" barely factor into the moral contract between an artist and their audience.
AFAIK (and I was a member of Oink for about 3 years) there was no monetary profit made whatsoever from the site. You may consider that anyone downloading music that they haven't paid for is profiting, after a fashion.
I do suggest exactly that. Profit does not mean only financial gain. People were encouraged to maintain a high share ratio (expenditure) in order to continue gaining assets (profit).
I'd also suggest that to think it didn't make any money when all you're paying for is bandwidth which on the relative scale of things is pretty cheap is a little nieve.

I'm guessing he was making a VERY tidy sum out of it and that is where he should be made an example of. In fact knowing some warez sites owners going back 10 years ago even then they used to take money to allow leech access to their site. Moreover it was a feature of many of the servers to hide users and their download stats. I'd be shocked if he didn't have regular subscribers paying him a monthly fee for invisible leech to the site. Which is why I don't care too much for his situation or the fact Oink is gone. I'm more concerned about the industry tactics in general.

G
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Post by Dio »

Good thought, actually. Wonder how many emails he got with "I would gladly donate if I had leech..."

I'm also of the general agreement that copyright breach with something you cannot buy falls into that grey area we've discussed so much with MAME, etc., but I do think there's a proper way to do this - for me the gold standard is World Of Spectrum, which has made a genuine, open effort to archive everything perfectly, tell everyone, and block distro of the stuff when the authors don't want it done.

Much better than the abandonware sites. I still feel kicked in the teeth when I see my game on there. I mean, if I had a proper company website it'd be up there for free download - there's a link on Rodent to it in a forum thread somewhere - but that don't give anyone else the right to give it away. If you see what I mean.
User avatar
Acronym
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3982
Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
Contact:

Post by Acronym »

GeeZa wrote: quite famous record shop in San Francisco
Amoeba? I could *live* in that place. Managed to find the Disintegration Loops there on holiday this summer. :D
User avatar
Ryan
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1634
Joined: Sun Feb 09, 2003 10:28 pm 0
Location: Gelderland, Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Ryan »

Acronym wrote:I'm really fucking annoyed at this thread - "THE RECORD COMPANIES ARE EVIL THE RECORD COMPANIES ARE EVIL repeat ad infinitum". Sure, maybe the Big Four aren't nice guys. Everyone knows that. Go read Steve Albini's 'The Problem With Music'. But many, or most, releases are on labels which are run, financed, and employ maybe a couple of people. Even labels like XL, Merge and Matador are a lot smaller than you'd think; then you've got the Warps and City Slangs and Kompakts of this world, and then the genuinely small labels - Hyperdub, City Centre Offices, n5MD...
Guess that's aimed at me.

The RIAA - who account for the vast majority of the industry - are, as you say, evil.

They're the guys who've been price fixing, and they're the guys now moaning / bribing officials etc. I.e. they're the cartel.

Indy labels are exactly whom we should be supporting. Personally, that's what I'm doing - buying CD & LPs from bands signed to Excelsior in Holland.

They're actually really clever - they play summer shows for free, taking a cut from the drinks sold (250ml for £2). There they sell t-shirts and merchandise. Lots and lots of people attend and they get lots of promo. Plus they sell lots of records/ts/CDs.

What's really needed for GOOD music to flourish is a weakening of copyright. Or some form of blanket license (excluding the cartel, of course). Then you'll see ultimate music services like LastFM om steroids.
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Post by GeeZa »

Acronym wrote:
GeeZa wrote: quite famous record shop in San Francisco
Amoeba? I could *live* in that place. Managed to find the Disintegration Loops there on holiday this summer. :D
Not that one, although Ameoba is very dreamy. :D The other one, the legendary Aquarius. Their amazingly detailed new release bulletins are always bad *bad* news for me. My last order there was a few hundred dollars and that was after hours of cutting back. Best customer service in the biz too, love 'em.
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
User avatar
Ryan
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1634
Joined: Sun Feb 09, 2003 10:28 pm 0
Location: Gelderland, Netherlands
Contact:

Post by Ryan »

GBH wrote:None of the online sales that were not from the major companies are counted . They make estimates but unless you're in the big 5 and activly submit your figures theres no record of it. So now there are many 1000's of artists who regularly get listened to with no imput to these figures. Also always remember that a huge number of people take their existing media and convert it (which is what the music industry hates). Previously with any new technology (vinyl>tape, tape>cd, vhs>dvd) people were re-buying almost everything they used to have again. This time it's COMPLETELY different. There is no new technology in music to force people to re-buy what they already have. This, I'm sure, has had a huge impact on that market (hence all this DRM crap to make sure it can't happen again - they want to force you to re-buy it for every single new format)
G
Mobile phones. They're making a massive amount of money from ringtones.

I guess the problem is that the artist's aren't doing so well now because they've probably signed away the rights to anything except CD sales to the fat cats.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Post by pogo »

GBH wrote:
pogo wrote: So the most popular albums, i.e. those that sold the most, are also the most popular downloads. Well, duh. And this proves what exactly?
It proves that despite these albums being downloaded very heavily they still did very well indeed. Meaning that if downloads were a significant negative factor that you would not see any album doing well and specifically the albums MOST heavily downloaded were still going double platinum (I believe 300k for a platinum). Very few artists sell 300k albums
It proves no such thing. Overall music sales are down, but over years. Doing a survey of downloads vs. album sales over a few months says nothing about this long term trend, and simply shows that the same music is enjoyed by people who pay for and steal their music. Someone posted the link so the original paper, and it's typical social science claptrap, not good economics at all.

As for the other points you raise
* DVD sale are irrelevant unless you also include VHS and Laserdisc.
* British artists doing well is nice but irrelevant - genres come and go all the time, in cycles or when something genuinely new comes along. It's be US RnB or Europop next.
* Paid digital downloads are up and that should push sales up (people able to buy more rare stuff, try before they buy). But the overall market is down, so retail sales are down far more than would be explained by iTunes etc.. And it was falling well before iTunes took off.
* The size of the whole market is pretty well known. Not all music sales are known, sure, and the singles and album charts are always an estimate base on sales in a few thousand stores. But all the companies, even the small ones, make money and publish accounts, each quarter and year with breakdowns, so the overall size of the market is known pretty well.
User avatar
Drew Badly
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 223
Joined: Mon Sep 17, 2007 11:02 am 0
Location: Scunthorpe (fiction section)
Contact:

Post by Drew Badly »

Does make you wonder what else in the news is complete and utter tosh.
User avatar
GBH
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 477
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 12:55 am 0

Post by GBH »

pogo wrote: It proves no such thing. Overall music sales are down, but over years. Doing a survey of downloads vs. album sales over a few months says nothing about this long term trend, and simply shows that the same music is enjoyed by people who pay for and steal their music. Someone posted the link so the original paper, and it's typical social science claptrap, not good economics at all.
I'm simply stating that despite piracy, in fact particularly heavy piracy, the album went on to sell very well - double platinum. Whats there to dispute? The question is how much could it have sold were it not for these downloads for certain but to imply that monitoring illegal downlaods v legal purchases is worthless is somewhat missing the point. The claim is clearly that piracy is causing the downturn. From this evidence from single album sales the impact of piracy is clearly not as large as they try and make out. I'm not saying it has no effect I'm just trying to balance the "Oh Noes piracy is killing us" argument with a little reality check.

pogo wrote: As for the other points you raise
* DVD sale are irrelevant unless you also include VHS and Laserdisc.
How so? It was there to illustrate that there has been a huge growth in DVD slaes over the same period with a caveat that there is some ofsetting against VHS going down in sales. However I don't see what relevance laserdisk has. Was that ever more than a minority niché? The point you missed that I was attempting to convey was that there are competing goods for the same disposable income experiencing huge growth. I'm suggesting that at least some of the loss of CD sales is due to the increase of sales in other areas, DVD being one of them.
pogo wrote: * British artists doing well is nice but irrelevant - genres come and go all the time, in cycles or when something genuinely new comes along. It's be US RnB or Europop next.
Come and go for 10 years? I think you're selling this a little short. The industry often claims that music sales are going down and that piracy in the UK is hitting sales. This is somewhat stretching the truth. Sales have increased still, but arguably by less than they would have. The constant inference is that there people are poor and impoverished and on skid row because of piracy. This couldn't be further from the truth could it?

pogo wrote: * Paid digital downloads are up and that should push sales up (people able to buy more rare stuff, try before they buy). But the overall market is down, so retail sales are down far more than would be explained by iTunes etc.. And it was falling well before iTunes took off.
Overall market FOR THE LARGE CONGLOMERATES is down. There are no figures assessing if the independents and solo merchants are experiencing increased sales. I've already suggested a number of other causes (some proven some speculative)

Lets try again
The global entertainment & media (E&M) industry is experiencing sustained growth and will increase at a 6.4% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) to $2 trillion in 2011, according to PricewaterhouseCoopers Global Entertainment and Media Outlook 2007-2011, released today.
Taken from

http://www.pwc.com/extweb/ncpressreleas ... 010051F342

Heres another predicting growth

http://www.mobilemarketingmagazine.co.u ... oom-t.html

Heres an interesting take on the industry and pretty accurate I'd suggest

http://www.plunkettresearch.com/Industr ... fault.aspx

Hardly an industry in dire straights is it? I notice for corporate pallets it doesn't mention the music industry but clearly it's not enough to slow the huge growth elsewhere. As I said, almost every other sector of the industry is experiencing growth. It is just as plausible that people are shifting their habbits to other mediums and distribution methods.
Anyway you get the idea. It's been really interesting reading a lot of the material so thanks for that.

pogo wrote: * The size of the whole market is pretty well known. Not all music sales are known, sure, and the singles and album charts are always an estimate base on sales in a few thousand stores. But all the companies, even the small ones, make money and publish accounts, each quarter and year with breakdowns, so the overall size of the market is known pretty well.
The figures I posted are based on facts (the companies that do submit) and guesswork (those that don't). To imply that the guessed revenue figures has some research behind it is a gross exaggeration.

I'll give you an example. I play in a brass band that makes and sells its own CD's. We only sell a couple of 100 a year but those are not reported anywhere. There are about 650 registered bands in the UK and if even only 10% did the same thats 13,000 album sales that go uncounted. Just in my world. I dread to imagine how many pop bands/groups do the same. Many many 1000's I'm sure. Unless you are a ltd company, no one sees how much you're making and unless your only line of work is selling CD's your accounts would go un-noticed.

The media world is changing drastically. It's getting to the point where its not about the companies that sell millions of records or even the smaller companies you mention who sell 100000's it about Joe Average who sells 500. There are 1000000's of Joe Average doing exactly the same. THATS where the threat comes from. Every sale to JA is a sale that goes no where near the media "industry". No advertising, no promotion, no marketing. Just straight into Joe's pocket.

The major labels are always going to underestimate how much their revenue is being lost to the little guys and grossly overplay the impact of things like piracy. It's how they can then get through legislation that allows them to attempt to maintain control and their cartel to squeeze out lesser players.

This is an interesting conversation but I'm tired and I need bed.

G
Last edited by GBH on Thu Oct 25, 2007 2:36 am 0, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
GBH
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 477
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 12:55 am 0

Post by GBH »

Drew Badly wrote:Does make you wonder what else in the news is complete and utter tosh.
Almost everything on computer security is. I cringe when I see the vast majority of reporting on it. It's either fabricated or grossly eggagerated.

The Sun ran a front page headline a few years ago about some government classified documents that had been leaked proclaiming "The Sun has got hold of Top Secret government files" etc. only for the photo of the document to clearly have "RESTRICTED" at the top of it. Thats the lowest classification there is and barely any more sensitive than company confidential. About as far away from TS as you can get. I KNOW it's the Sun but I've never seen a single newspaper or tv report on IT security with anything other than a passing flirtation with the truth.

G
User avatar
fritx
Troll (2/10)
Posts: 912
Joined: Tue May 20, 2003 11:51 am 0
Location: Airstrip One
Contact:

Post by fritx »

Oink's made the front page of the Northern Echo yesterday with quite an impressive array of Actual Facts :)

Story in our local rag.
User avatar
Kon-Tiki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5594
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 9:54 pm 0
Location: Inside my BO
Contact:

Post by Kon-Tiki »

I've said it before, and I'll say it again: a good way to go forward, is the Tecnobrega way.

In short, musicians make their music, make records and sell them to black market street vendors, who sell them for 50 cents or so. Those musicians actively promote their music over the black market, seeing it as a way of making name and fame.

They make 5 times the local minimum wage a month though, even with their music being pirated, as they got a reputation that way, and people will come watch their performances.

When someone is really good, they're picked up by popular DJs and are played on parties and such, and the radio can't help but follow what those DJs do.

For the record, this is about thousands of little bands, mostly one-person one-instrument stuff, because they simply can't afford anything bigger when they start, and make a good living off of it. I think it's alot fairer than the record studio system, as in here, it's the ones with talent that break through, and those without will stay behind. No auto-corrects for people singing off-key, no lipsyncing dolls while an ugly crow does the actual singing, no faking. The good get rewarded, the bad just waste their own time.
User avatar
noodles
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2053
Joined: Wed May 15, 2002 1:04 pm 0
Location: France

Post by noodles »

Kon-Tiki wrote:I've said it before, and I'll say it again: a good way to go forward, is the Tecnobrega way.
Brazil's National Anti-Piracy Association dismisses tecnobrega as an insignificant movement that makes light of piracy, which it says costs the Brazilian economy two million jobs a year and $15 billion in lost tax revenues.

"Piracy in Brazil is undermining the ability of the music and film industries to invest in the next generation of local talent. Lower revenues from current sales mean less money to invest in new artists," the association's general director, Andre Borges, said when he announced the industry's plan to sue illegal downloaders in Brazil.
:lol: What a bunch of lying greedy clowns.


" Lower revenues from current sales mean less money to invest in new artists"
Translation :
"How am I going to pay for my indoor pool and my third porsche if this goes on ?"
User avatar
Kamineko
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7569
Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 2:53 pm 0
Contact:

Post by Kamineko »

fritx wrote:Oink's made the front page of the Northern Echo yesterday with quite an impressive array of Actual Facts :)

Story in our local rag.
There's nout there. :(
Post Reply