*HELP* (serious), positive vibes needed ..
- p-saurus
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1282
- Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 8:56 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: p_saurus
- Location: Tucson, Arizona
- Contact:
I know tis thread has taken off in a different direction but I just wanted to pipe up and say that I recieved the controllers from Skah-T tonight and finally got to play Tempest 3000 on the analog stick with a proper range of motion. I came to two conclusions. Minter, you are a true genius and a massive cunt! I love that game!
Anyhow, I've been pimping SG to my clients at the video game store I work at and am eagerly anticipating its release on the PC. (unfortunately I don't have a 360 and don't plan on having the funds to get one any time in the near future.) It really saddens me to see the difficulties that you guys are in at the moment but I have faith that things will pick up again in the near future. You guys are just too damn good for that not to happen.
Anyhow, I've been pimping SG to my clients at the video game store I work at and am eagerly anticipating its release on the PC. (unfortunately I don't have a 360 and don't plan on having the funds to get one any time in the near future.) It really saddens me to see the difficulties that you guys are in at the moment but I have faith that things will pick up again in the near future. You guys are just too damn good for that not to happen.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2007/nov/29/games
Why Space Giraffe v Frogger is no contest
Simon
Why Space Giraffe v Frogger is no contest
Not entirely positive article, but basically supportive for our Jeff and Giles...When scriptwriter William Goldman opened his book Adventures in the Screen Trade with the immortal line, "Nobody knows anything", he was of course referring to the vagaries of the movie industry - the fact that utter stinkers often make millions, while beautifully crafted masterpieces sometimes sink like Antarctic cruise ships. His succinct assertion on the randomness of public taste can easily be applied to videogames, too.
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
Compared to Psychonauts with the line "Weird, difficult, but brilliant"? High praise any day of the week.goldfish wrote:Not entirely positive article, but basically supportive for our Jeff and Giles...
I reckon going to do a proper interview with the Guardian would be a great move. They clearly know and respect Jeff and Giraffe. Free publicity...
- teamonkey
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12082
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
- PSN: teamonkey_ca
- Contact:
That's the best method for a FPS or RPG-type game, IMO. No tutorials, just help messages every time something new happens or the first time someone is expected to do something. Ideally you'd pace it - make the player do something, repeat until they've mastered it and can do it by themselves, then on to the next skill.Harlequin wrote:This reminds me of the very successful method which Valve employ in their games. Their developer commentaries also provide much insight as to how to make games easily accessible for a modern audience.
In something like SG that would be really distracting though - if you read the text, you die. Maybe something like a postmortem instead: "You died, a bullet hit you." And then a random selection of tips each time: "Listen for the sound a bullet makes when fired." "Hoof shots are very useful for deflecting bullets, use <R> to aim them while the power zone is extended." "You can shoot bullets back down the web, but eventually they'll return even faster." "These enemies shoot bullets: ..." "Watch out, these bullets can be fired diagonally across the web."
Patronising, maybe, but advanced users could make it disappear by squeezing the trustly LT.
- benedictw
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6012
- Joined: Thu Mar 25, 2004 3:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CoderBen
- Location: Poole, UK
- Contact:
Another vote for this - the problem with tutorials is that people dont use them, ditto for manuals. Its in game, or it doesn't exist.Arganoid wrote: So, on level 1 the displayed message would simply be "LEFT STICK = MOVE". On level 2 it would be "RIGHT STICK = AIM". On each of these levels, whenever a power up appeared, the word "POWERUP" would be shown next to it.
Gamertag\PSN: CoderBen
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
No, I think that's a reasonably good idea - it's like the attract sequences on arcade games..teamonkey wrote:That's the best method for a FPS or RPG-type game, IMO. No tutorials, just help messages every time something new happens or the first time someone is expected to do something. Ideally you'd pace it - make the player do something, repeat until they've mastered it and can do it by themselves, then on to the next skill.Harlequin wrote:This reminds me of the very successful method which Valve employ in their games. Their developer commentaries also provide much insight as to how to make games easily accessible for a modern audience.
In something like SG that would be really distracting though - if you read the text, you die. Maybe something like a postmortem instead: "You died, a bullet hit you." And then a random selection of tips each time: "Listen for the sound a bullet makes when fired." "Hoof shots are very useful for deflecting bullets, use <R> to aim them while the power zone is extended." "You can shoot bullets back down the web, but eventually they'll return even faster." "These enemies shoot bullets: ..." "Watch out, these bullets can be fired diagonally across the web."
Patronising, maybe, but advanced users could make it disappear by squeezing the trustly LT.
[Sir_LANs-a-lot]
Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
I think it's part semantics mate... a lot of people I know can't get on with it (and not just because of the visuals), and even Kris is able to play it better than me. Yes, me, the bloke who used to be near the top of every Lleague table, cannot get on with SG. But I've accepted that and I'm still looking forward to playing the next Llamasoft game anyhow.PVB wrote:I think it's more to do with the whining that SG is unplayable and/or broken, when it's plainly not.
Without beating about the bush, Jeff's blog comments regarding the performance of SG compared to Frogger have gone down extremely badly in a number of places I inhabit, prompting some very negative comments in response from many users. Unfortunately that does make for some rather bad PR even though I agree Jeff has a right to be annoyed that something with plenty of potential and challenge (even though as I pointed out above, I'm not "getting it") is being trounced by a repacked arcade game.
So where to go from here? I think I have to agree with some other people, get a game out there that people will recognise the name already (Gridrunner), double the points cost, get some promotion and advertising going before it is released, and maybe offer OXM an exclusive review of it to reverse the SG mark (okay so that last one is part tongue in cheek, but anything helps if they decide to mark it well!). Would it need a tutorial? Maybe, but as just mentioned, having useful little comments appear during play (and maybe STOPPING play at that moment so people can read them?) to inform the player what is happening in this mode would help people new to it.
Pretty much everything except writing the game... I know in the heart of hearts that Jeff will put everything again into this and turn up something good
Lie with passion and be forever damned...
Xbox: Mayhem64
Xbox: Mayhem64
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
Long time lurker here. Just wanted to add my support for Jeff at the moment as he sounds like he needs it. I bought SG yesterday as a means of showing my support. I've been a fan of Jeff's stuff since the VIC20 days and I think the games industry would be a bleak place without him, so dont give up please!
I sort of know where you are coming from as I put my heart and soul into the first game I worked on when I entered the industry only to see it sell hardly any copies at all because most people didnt really get it. Over time though the disappointment disappeared and now I can look back and feel proud of the game we made because the small amount of people who played it loved it and that means it wasnt a complete waste of time. Hopefully one day you will look back with the same feelings for SG.
I dont know you so please excuse the informality but big hugs from me.
I sort of know where you are coming from as I put my heart and soul into the first game I worked on when I entered the industry only to see it sell hardly any copies at all because most people didnt really get it. Over time though the disappointment disappeared and now I can look back and feel proud of the game we made because the small amount of people who played it loved it and that means it wasnt a complete waste of time. Hopefully one day you will look back with the same feelings for SG.
I dont know you so please excuse the informality but big hugs from me.
- FatherDougal
- Posts: 24
- Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2007 9:31 am 0
A bit late to the thread, but just wanted to say that I hope things improve for you soon. I remember my dad buying me a Commodore 64 when I was just a nipper, and I got three games with it - Hunchback, Manic Miner and Revenge of the Mutant Camels. I don't think I've ever spent as much time with a game since as I did with each of those. And although all 3 were quality (in my young eyes), I loved the quirkiness and warmth of Revenge - the music, the J Minter signature, the phone boxes etc. It really felt like an individual's creation.
From that point onwards, although I didn't buy every Llamasoft game, I bought the majority, and subscribed to Nature of the Beast, and even then felt like part of a community, unlike the Oceans and US Golds of the software industry. The games just felt like a labour of love.
Anyway, to cut a long story short, 5 or 6 years ago as I got more access to the internet, I revisited that period in my life, hence finding this place. There were a few standout names from that period that I checked up on, Jeff was one, Martin Galway was another. I was really surprised to learn that Martin Galway was also working at Microsoft, checked up on what he'd been doing and realised that from a point where I had bought games just based on the fact that he had written the music for them, that he appeared to have disappeared into a large games music studio as part of a large team, and I didn't feel like I had heard anything that was uniquely HIS voice for a very long time.
And that's something which I definitely can't say for Jeff. I've read about all of the problems in this thread and elsewhere, but I just wanted to say that I for one love the fact that you are still making games, and have a very unique voice and style all of your own. And I know it's no consolation, but playing SG really took me back to when I was younger, playing things like Sheep in Space, and just playing with a big grin on my face. I appreciate that commercially it may not have achieved what you wanted, but if it helps, it made me feel really happy to still be a gamer.
From my own point of view, rather than my employer's, I do currently think that XBLA is a bit of a mess, with almost too many titles released, and gems getting lost in the midst of it. Going into the XBLA part of my 360 now lists about 65 games thanks to automatic download - I've not even played about half of them. I don't know what can be done marketing-wise, but I think it makes it tough for any game which doesn't have a recognisable established brand to stand out, and it's something I'd like to see changed. Maybe an "Arcade conversion" section and a "New Releases" section so that people aren't flicking through an amalgamated list, overwhelmed by it all and therefore being attracted to names they know...
Thats a huge amount of words to say - I feel for you that SG hasn't done as well as you'd hoped, but I hope you feel proud of what you've acheived, and I hope you know that you have made a large number of people very happy with your creation, and I hope it doesn't deter you from continuing to make standout, unique games. I have no idea how easy it would be, but I really would like to see some of your old IP (such as Ancipital, Revenge, AMC, Hovver Bovver) appear on XBLA.
Please don't give up.
PS - This is not meant to be critical of Martin Galway - I'm sure he's a lovely bloke
From that point onwards, although I didn't buy every Llamasoft game, I bought the majority, and subscribed to Nature of the Beast, and even then felt like part of a community, unlike the Oceans and US Golds of the software industry. The games just felt like a labour of love.
Anyway, to cut a long story short, 5 or 6 years ago as I got more access to the internet, I revisited that period in my life, hence finding this place. There were a few standout names from that period that I checked up on, Jeff was one, Martin Galway was another. I was really surprised to learn that Martin Galway was also working at Microsoft, checked up on what he'd been doing and realised that from a point where I had bought games just based on the fact that he had written the music for them, that he appeared to have disappeared into a large games music studio as part of a large team, and I didn't feel like I had heard anything that was uniquely HIS voice for a very long time.
And that's something which I definitely can't say for Jeff. I've read about all of the problems in this thread and elsewhere, but I just wanted to say that I for one love the fact that you are still making games, and have a very unique voice and style all of your own. And I know it's no consolation, but playing SG really took me back to when I was younger, playing things like Sheep in Space, and just playing with a big grin on my face. I appreciate that commercially it may not have achieved what you wanted, but if it helps, it made me feel really happy to still be a gamer.
From my own point of view, rather than my employer's, I do currently think that XBLA is a bit of a mess, with almost too many titles released, and gems getting lost in the midst of it. Going into the XBLA part of my 360 now lists about 65 games thanks to automatic download - I've not even played about half of them. I don't know what can be done marketing-wise, but I think it makes it tough for any game which doesn't have a recognisable established brand to stand out, and it's something I'd like to see changed. Maybe an "Arcade conversion" section and a "New Releases" section so that people aren't flicking through an amalgamated list, overwhelmed by it all and therefore being attracted to names they know...
Thats a huge amount of words to say - I feel for you that SG hasn't done as well as you'd hoped, but I hope you feel proud of what you've acheived, and I hope you know that you have made a large number of people very happy with your creation, and I hope it doesn't deter you from continuing to make standout, unique games. I have no idea how easy it would be, but I really would like to see some of your old IP (such as Ancipital, Revenge, AMC, Hovver Bovver) appear on XBLA.
Please don't give up.
PS - This is not meant to be critical of Martin Galway - I'm sure he's a lovely bloke
The Guardian David Lynch quote best thing I have heard yet and that alone should make you feel bloody good.
To be compared to David Lynch is one of the highest complements I could ever imagine being bestowed on a individual , unless its D L himself than you are just stating the bleeding obvious
To fake being a maverick is impossible you will be proven a fraud , but to be mainstream and keep your edge is easy for a maverick team like llamasoft.
I reckon the future is going to be bright for yourselves
To be compared to David Lynch is one of the highest complements I could ever imagine being bestowed on a individual , unless its D L himself than you are just stating the bleeding obvious
To fake being a maverick is impossible you will be proven a fraud , but to be mainstream and keep your edge is easy for a maverick team like llamasoft.
I reckon the future is going to be bright for yourselves
"Don't move, you're surrounded by armed bastards " DCI Gene Hunt. 




